Currencies
Highlights EM tech stocks are overbought while banks are fundamentally vulnerable due to bad-loan overhang. EM stocks have never decoupled from the U.S. dollar and commodities prices. There has been no recovery in EM corporate profitability and EPS. We reiterate two equity trades: short EM banks / long U.S. banks, and short Chinese property developers / long U.S. homebuilders. Upgrade Thai stocks to overweight within the EM equity benchmark and go long THB versus KRW. Feature Our Reflation Confirming Indicator - an equal-weighted aggregate of platinum prices (a proxy for global reflation), industrial metals prices (a proxy for China growth) and U.S. lumber prices (a proxy for U.S. reflation) - has decisively rolled over, and is spelling trouble for emerging market (EM) equities (Chart I-1). In particular, platinum prices have relapsed after hitting a major resistance at their 800-day moving average (Chart I-2). Such a technical pattern often leads to new lows. If so, it could presage a major selloff in EM markets in the months ahead. Chart I-1A Red Flag From ##br##Reflation Confirming Indicator Chart I-2Platinum: A Canary##br## In A Coal Mine? The rationale behind using platinum rather than gold or silver prices is because platinum is a precious metal that also has industrial uses. Besides, we have found that platinum prices correlate with EM stocks better than gold or silver. The latter two sometimes rally due to global demand for safety, even as EM markets tank. Finally, platinum seems to be the most high-beta precious metal in the sense that it "catches a cold" sooner and, thus, might be leading other reflationary plays. In short, EM share prices have been flat since August 15, and odds are that they are topping out and the next large move will be to the downside. Can EM De-Couple From The U.S. Dollar? Many investors are asking whether EM risk assets can rally if the greenback continues to rebound. Chart I-3 illustrates that since the early 1980s, there have been no periods when EM share prices rallied amid strength in the real broad trade-weighted U.S. dollar (the dollar is shown inverted on this and the proceeding charts). The same holds true if one uses the nominal narrow trade-weighted U.S. dollar1 (Chart I-4). Chart I-3Real Trade-Weighted ##br##U.S. Dollar And EM Stocks Chart I-4Nominal Trade-Weighted ##br##U.S. Dollar And EM Stocks One could disregard these charts and argue that this time around is different. We don't quite see it that way. Chart I-5Nominal Trade-Weighted ##br##U.S. Dollar And Commodities Notably, the narrative behind the EM rally since February's lows has been based on the Federal Reserve backing off from rate hikes and the U.S. dollar weakening - with the latter propelling a rally in commodities prices. These arguments appear to be reversing: the U.S. dollar is already firming up and commodities prices are at best mixed. The broad index for commodities prices always drops when the U.S. dollar rallies (Chart I-5). In recent months, the advance in commodities prices has been uneven and narrow based. While oil prices have spiked substantially, industrial metals prices have advanced very little. The current oil price rally is proving a bit more durable and lasting than we thought a few months ago. Nevertheless, China's apparent consumption of petroleum products is beginning to contract (Chart I-6). Consequently, resurfacing worries about EM/China's demand for commodities will lead to a meaningful pullback in crude prices in the months ahead, especially since the likelihood that oil producers act to restrain supply at the current prices is very low. As for commodities trading in China such as steel, iron ore, rubber, plate glass and others, they have been on a roller-coaster ride in recent months (Chart I-7). Chart I-6China's Demand For Oil Products Is Very Weak Chart I-7Commodities Prices In China Bottom Line: There are reasonably high odds that as the U.S. dollar strengthens and commodities prices roll over, EM risk assets (stocks, currencies and credit markets) will start to relapse. EM Beyond Commodities: Still Shrinking Profits Table I-1EM Sectors Weights: In 2011 And Now Another question that many investors have been asking is as follows: Is there not a positive story in EM beyond commodities? Given that the weight of the EM equity market benchmark in commodities stocks - energy and materials - has drastically declined in recent years, from 29.2% in 2011 to 13.7% now (Table I-1), and the weight in technology stocks has risen substantially (from 12.9% in 2011 to 23.9% now), couldn't non-commodities stocks drive the index higher? In this regard, we have the following observations: Information technology stocks are overbought. The EM information technology equity index has surged to its previous highs (Chart I-8, top panel). This sector is dominated by five companies that have a very large weight also in the overall EM benchmark: Samsung (3.6% weight in the EM equity benchmark), TMSC (3.5%), Alibaba (2.9%), Hon Hai Precision (1%) and Tencent (3.8%). Their share price performance has been spectacular, and some of them have gone ballistic (Chart I-9). TMSC and to a lesser extent Samsung have benefited from the rising prices of semiconductors (Chart I-9, second panel from top). However, it is not assured that semiconductor prices will continue soaring from these levels as global aggregate demand remains very weak. In short, the outlook for semi stocks is by and large a semiconductor industry call, not a macro one. As for Alibaba and Tencent, they are bottom-up stories - not macro bets at all. At the macro level, we reassert that EM/China demand for technology goods and services as well as for health care will stay robust. Hence, from a revenue perspective, technology and health care companies will outperform other EM sectors. This still warrants an overweight allocation to technology and health care stocks, a recommendation that we have had in place since June 2010 (Chart I-8, bottom panel). Odds are that tech outperformance will persist, but we are not sure about absolute performance, given overbought conditions and not-so-cheap valuations. Excluding information technology, the EM benchmark is somewhat weaker (Chart I-10). Chart I-8EM Technology Stocks: Sky Is Limit? Chart I-9Individual Tech Names Are Overbought Chart I-10EM Equities: Overall And Excluding Tech There is no improvement in EM corporate profitability The return on equity (RoE) for EM non-financial listed companies has stabilized at very low levels, but it has not improved at all (Chart I-11, top panel). The reason we use non-financials' RoE rather than overall RoE is because in EM the latter is artificially inflated at the moment, as banks are originating a lot of new loans but are not sufficiently provisioning for bad loans. Among the three components of non-financials RoE, net profit margins have stabilized but asset turnover is falling and leverage continues to mushroom (Chart I-11, bottom two panels). Remarkably, the relative performance between EM and U.S. stocks has historically been driven by relative RoE. When non-financial RoE in EM is above that of the U.S., EM stocks outperform U.S. ones, and vice-versa (Chart I-12). This relationships argues for EM stocks underperformance versus the S&P 500. Chart I-11EM Non-Financials: ##br##RoE And Its Components Chart I-12EM Versus U.S.: ##br##Relative RoE And Share Prices Overall EM EPS is still contracting in both local currency and U.S. dollar terms (Chart I-13). Even though the rate of contraction is easing for EPS in U.S. dollar terms, it is due to EM exchange rate appreciation versus the greenback this year. Furthermore, EPS in U.S. dollars is contracting in a majority of non-commodities sectors (Chart I-13A, Chart I-13B). The exceptions are utilities and industrials, which both exhibit strong EPS growth despite poor share price performance. The latter could be a sign that strong industrials and utilities EPS have been due to temporary factors and are not sustainable. Chart I-13AEM EPS Growth: Overall And By Sector Chart I-13BEM EPS Growth: Overall And By Sector Banks hold the key. Apart from commodities/the U.S. dollar and tech stocks, EM banks' share prices are probably the most important precursor to the direction of the overall EM benchmark. Financials are the second-largest sector in the EM equity benchmark (26.4% weight), so if bank share prices break down, the broader EM index will likely relapse. Our analysis of bank health in various EM countries leads us to believe that banks are under-provisioned for non-performing loans (NPL) (Chart I-14A, Chart I-14B). As EM growth disappointments resurface, investors will question the quality of banks' balance sheets and push down bank equity valuation. Hence, odds are bank share prices will drop sooner than later. Chart I-14AEM NPLs Are Unrecognized ##br##And Under-Provisioned Chart I-14BEM NPLs Are Unrecognized ##br##And Under-Provisioned In turn, concerns about EM banks will heighten doubts about overall EM growth and the EM equity benchmark will sell off. Bottom Line: EM tech stocks are overbought, while banks are fundamentally vulnerable due to the bad-loan overhang. As commodities prices relapse anew and worries about the EM credit cycle resurface, the EM benchmark will drop considerably. An Update On Two Relative Equity Trades We reiterate two relative equity trades: short EM banks / long U.S. banks, and short Chinese property developers / long U.S. homebuilders. For investors who do not have these positions, now is a good time to initiate them. Short EM banks / long U.S. banks (Chart I-15). The credit cycle in EM/China will undergo a further downturn: credit growth is set to decelerate as banks recognize NPLs and seek to raise capital. Even if a crisis is avoided, the need to raise substantial amounts of equity will considerably erode the value of EM bank shares. Meanwhile, risks to U.S. banks such as a flat yield curve and a possible spillover effect from European banking tremors are considerably less severe than the problems faced by EM banks. Importantly, unlike EM banks, U.S. banks' balance sheets are very healthy. Short Chinese property developers / long U.S. homebuilders (Chart I-16). Chart I-15Stay Short EM Banks##br## Versus U.S. Banks Chart I-16Stay Short Chinese Property ##br##Developers Versus U.S. Homebuilders Chinese property developers are on the verge of another downturn, as the authorities have tightened policy surrounding housing. Residential and non-residential property sales have boomed in the past 12 months, but starts have been less robust (Chart I-17). The upshot could still be high shadow inventories. Going forward, as speculative demand for housing cools off, property developers' chronic malaise - high leverage and lack of cash flow - will come back to play. Remarkably, property stocks trading in Hong Kong have failed to break out amid the buoyant residential market frenzy in the past 12 months, and are likely to break down as demand growth falters in the coming months (Chart I-18). Chart I-17China's Real Estate: ##br##Sales And Starts Will Contract Chart I-18Chinese Property Developers: ##br##On A Verge Of Breakdown? Arthur Budaghyan, Senior Vice President Emerging Markets Strategy & Frontier Markets Strategy arthurb@bcaresearch.com Thailand: Upgrade Stocks To Overweight And Go Long THB Versus KRW The death of King Bhumibol Adulyadej marks the end of an era not only because he symbolized national unity but also because his entire generation is passing. This generational shift has far-reaching consequences for Thailand's political establishment: in the long run it could hurt the Thai military's - and its allies' - attempt to cement their dominance over parliament. However, as Box II-1 (on page 17) explains, there is a low probability of serious domestic instability over the next 12 months2 - although beyond that risks will be heating up. For now, the military junta faces no major political or economic constraints: The junta has already consolidated control over all major organs of government and has purged or intimidated political enemies. The military will have to turn power back to parliament, or make a major policy mistake, for the opposition movement to rise again. The government's fiscal deficit has been stable (around 3% of GDP) over the past few years, public debt is at 33% of GDP, government bond yields are low and debt servicing costs are at 5% of total expenditures (Chart II-1). Hence, the military government can ramp up expenditures further to appease the disaffected. Indeed, the military junta has already accelerated public capital expenditures (Chart II-2) and investments have poured into the Northeast, a populous base of opposition to the junta. Chart II-1Thailand: More Room ##br##For Fiscal Stimulus Chart II-2Thailand: Government ##br##Capex Has Been Booming Likewise, fiscal expenditure has also accelerated in areas such as general public services, defense, and social protection (Chart II-3). Additionally, the Bank of Thailand (BoT) has scope to cut interest rates as the policy rate is still above a very low inflation rate (Chart II-4). This will limit the downside for credit growth and contribute to economic and political stability. Chart II-3Rising Public Spending Chart II-4Thailand: No Inflation; Room To Cut Rates The large current account surplus - standing at 11% of GDP - provides the authorities with plenty of fiscal and monetary maneuverability without having to worry about a major depreciation in the Thai baht (Chart II-5). Amid this sensitive political transition, the central bank will likely defend the currency if downward pressure on the baht emerges due to U.S. dollar strength. Therefore, we recommend traders to go long the Thai baht versus the Korean won (Chart II-6). Despite Korea's enormous current account, the won is at risk from depreciation in the RMB and the Japanese yen. Chart II-5Enormous Current Account ##br##Surplus Will Support The Baht Chart II-6Go Long THB Against KRW On the whole, although the Thai economy has been stagnant (Chart II-7), fiscal spending and low interest rates will limit the downside in growth. Bottom Line: We expect relative calm on the political surface in Thailand over the next 12 months and a stable macro backdrop. Therefore, we are using the latest weakness to upgrade this bourse from neutral to overweight within an EM equity portfolio (Chart II-8). Chart II-7Thai Growth Has Been Stagnant Chart II-8Upgrade Thai Stocks ##br##From Neutral To Overweight In addition, currency traders should go long THB versus KRW. Ayman Kawtharani, Research Analyst aymank@bcaresearch.com Matt Gertken, Associate Editor mattg@bcaresearch.com BOX 1 The Military Coup In 2014 Pre-empted The King's Death... The May 2014 military coup was timed to pre-empt this event. The king's health had been declining for years and it was only a matter of time until he died. This raised the prospect of an intense political struggle that could have escalated into a full-blown succession crisis. Thus the military moved preemptively so that it would be in control of the country ahead of the king's death and could reshape the constitutional system in the military's favor before his death, as it has done. ... And This Means Stability For Now If the populist, anti-royalist faction had been in control of government at the time of the king's death, it could have attempted to manipulate the less popular new king and take advantage of the vacuum of royal authority in order to reduce the role of the military and their allies. That in turn could have sparked a wave of mass protests from royalists, pressuring the government to collapse, or a military coup that would not have carried the king's implicit approval like the 2014 coup. That would have fed the narrative that a final showdown between the factions was finally emerging, and would have been highly alarming to foreign investors. But Risks Still Linger Make no mistake: a new long-term cycle of political instability is now emerging. Potential military mistakes and the return to parliamentary rule are potential dangers. The country's deep divisions - between (1) the Bangkok-centered royalist bureaucratic and military establishment and (2) the provincial opposition -have not been healed but aggravated since the 2014 coup and the new pro-military constitution: The junta's constitutional and electoral reforms will weaken the representation of the largest opposition party, the Pheu Thai Party, and will marginalize a large share of the 65% of the country's population that lives in the opposition-sympathetic provinces. It is also conceivable that the new king could trigger conflict by lending support to the populist opposition. For instance, he could pardon the exiled leader of the rural opposition movement, or he could transform the powerful Privy Council. However, we do not expect discontent to flare up significantly until late 2017 or 2018 when the military steps back and a new election cycle begins.3 We will reassess and alert investors if we foresee a rapid deterioration in the palace-military network, or in the military's ability to prevent seething resistance in the provinces. 1 The narrow U.S. dollar is a trade-weighted exchange rate versus the euro, Canadian dollar, Japanese yen, British pound, Swiss franc, Australian dollar, and Swedish krona. Source: The Federal Reserve. 2 The exception is that isolated acts of terrorism remain likely and could well strike key areas in Bangkok, signaling the reality that the underground opposition to military dictatorship remains alive and well. 3 The junta will use the one-year national period of mourning to its advantage and opposition forces will not want to be targeted for causing any trouble during a time of mourning. The junta could very easily delay the transition to nominal civilian rule, including the elections slated for November 2017. Equity Recommendations Fixed-Income, Credit And Currency Recommendations
Highlights Global liquidity conditions are set to tighten in the months ahead. This could add some fire to a dollar rally, especially against EM and commodity currencies. The GBP has become the new anti-dollar, reflected by its strong sensitivity to the greenback. Financing the U.K.'s large current-account deficit is a difficult task when global liquidity tightens, the layer of political uncertainty now makes it a herculean labor. While the pound is now attractive as a long-term play, it still possesses plenty downside risk. A quick look at EUR/SEK, NOK/SEK, GBP/CAD, and AUD/JPY. Feature Global liquidity conditions have begun to tighten. This development is likely to send the dollar higher and inflict serious damage on EM and commodity currencies. The pound's weakness fits nicely into this larger story. Not only is the current political climate in the British Isles prompting investors to think twice about buying British assets, but a tightening in global liquidity makes financing the U.K. current account deficit even more onerous. This adjustment demands a cheaper GBP. Global Yields: A Step Forward, Half A Step Backward The main reason why global liquidity conditions are tightening is the recent back up in global bond yields. In normal circumstances, a 39 basis-point (bp), a 24bp, and a 16bp back-up in 10-year Treasury yields, JGB yields, and bund yields, respectively, would not represent much of a problem. But today is anything but normal. The shift in global monetary policy has been behind the back-up in yields. In aggregate, global central banks are about to begin decreasing their purchases of securities. This will not only lift interest rates on government paper, but it will also raise rates for private-sector borrowing, especially as global risk premia have been depressed by an effect known as TINA - or "There Is No Alternative" (Chart I-1). The Fed too is in the process of lifting global bond yields. For one thing, U.S. labor market slack is dissipating and we are starting to witness rising wage pressures (Chart I-2). As such, we expect the Fed to raise its policy rate in December, and to further push rates higher in 2017 and 2018. Given that only 62 basis points of hike are priced in until the end of 2019, there is scope for U.S. bond yields to rise. Chart I-1Central Banks Are Contributing##br## To Tightening Liquidity Chart I-2U.S. Labor Market Is ##br##Showing Signs Of Tightening In terms of investor sentiment, despite the recent back-up in long bond yields, investors remain surprisingly upbeat on the outlook for T-bonds (Chart I-3). This, combined with their still-poor valuations, is another reason to be worried about the outlook for U.S. and global bonds for the remainder of the year. Finally, we expect U.S. real rates to have more upside than non-U.S. rates. Why? The U.S. output gap is arguably narrower than that of Europe or Japan. Moreover, the U.S. economy has deleveraged more than the rest of the G10. With U.S households enjoying strong real income growth, strong balance sheet positions, and with banks easing their lending standards to households, U.S. private-sector debt levels can expand vis-à-vis those of other developed economies. This will lift U.S. relative real rates (Chart I-4). Chart I-3Upside For ##br##Yields Chart I-4Real Rate Differentials Should ##br##Move In The Dollar's Favor What does this all mean for currency markets? As we highlighted last week, we expect the U.S. dollar to display more upside, potentially rising by around 10% over the next 18 months. We also expect more tumultuous times to re-emerge in the EM space. Rising real rates have been a bane for EM assets in this cycle. This is because EM growth has been dependent on EM financial conditions, which themselves, have been a function of global liquidity conditions (Chart I-5). Exacerbating our fear, the recent narrowing in EM spreads has not been reflective of EM corporate health. This suggests that EM borrowing costs and financial conditions are at risk of a shakeout (Chart I-6). Chart I-5Global Liquidity Conditions Will Hurt EM Chart I-6EM Spreads Are Priced For Perfection This obviously leads us to worry about commodity currencies as well. For one, they remain tightly linked with EM equities, displaying a 0.82 correlation with that asset class since 2000. Moreover, as Chart I-7 and Table I-1 illustrate, commodity currencies are tightly linked with the dollar and EM spreads. Thus, a combo of a higher dollar and deteriorating EM financial conditions could do great harm to the AUD, the NZD, and the NOK. Interestingly, SEK and GBP are also two potential big casualties of any such development. Chart I-7The GBP Has Become The Anti-Dollar Table I-1Currency Sensitivities To Key Factors, Since 2014 That being said, these dynamics contain the seeds of their own demise. As they are deflationary shocks, EM and commodity sell-offs are likely to elicit a dovish response from global policymakers. This will limit the upside for yields, implying that any tightening in global liquidity conditions is likely to prompt another reflationary push early in 2017. Bottom Line: Global rates still have more upside from here. U.S. real rates could rise the most as the Fed is now confronted with an increasingly tight labor market. Moreover, the U.S. economy possesses the strongest structural fundamentals in the G10. Together, this set of circumstances is likely to boost the dollar, especially at the expense of EM, commodity currencies, and the pound. GBP: Another Arrow In The Eye Nine hundred and fifty years ago to this day, King Harold, the last Anglo-Saxon King of England, died on the battlefield at Hastings from an arrow to the eye.1 The kingship of Norman William the Conqueror ushered a long and complex relationship between the British Isles and the rest of the continent. Over the past two weeks, the fall in the pound has been a dramatic story. The collapse of the nominal effective exchange rate to a nearly 200-year low, is a clear indication that the battle between the U.K. and the rest of the EU is inflicting long-term damage on the kingdom (Chart I-8). The key shock to the pound remains political. PM May made it clear that Brexit means Brexit. Additionally, elements of her discourse, such as wanting firms to list their foreign-born employees, are raising fears among the business community that the Conservatives are taking a very populist, anti-business slant that could weigh on the long-term prospects for British growth. True, these policies may never see the light of day. But across the Channel, the EU partners are taking a hardline approach to Brexit negations. Investors cheered the announcement on Wednesday that PM Theresa May will allow deeper scrutiny from parliament before triggering Brexit. Altogether, this mostly means that the cacophony over the future of the U.K. will only grow louder. Thus, we expect political headline risks to remain a strong source of uncertainty. These political games are poisonous for the pound. The U.K. is highly dependent on FDI inflows to finance it large current account deficit of nearly 6% of GDP (Chart I-9). Not knowing the status of the U.K. vis-à-vis the common market heightens any risk premium on investments in the U.K. Also, any shift of rhetoric toward a more populist discourse increases the risk that regulations could be implemented that either hurt the future profitability of British firms or increase their cost of capital. At the margin, this makes the U.K. less attractive to foreign investors. Chart I-8Something Evil This Way Comes Chart I-9The U.K. Needs Capital This has multiple implications. The pound remains highly sensitive to global liquidity trends, a fact highlighted by its extremely elevated sensitivity to EM spreads. The pound will also remain correlated with EM equity prices. This suggests that if a rising dollar acts as a lever to tighten global liquidity conditions, the pound will continue to be the currency with the largest beta to USD. In other words, investors will continue to express bullish-dollar views through the pound. Domestic dynamics are also problematic. The recent fall in the pound is lifting British inflationary pressures, a reality picked up by our Inflation Pressure Gauge (Chart I-10). In normal times, this could have lifted the pound as investors would have expected a response by the BoE. Today, however, the British credit impulse is very weak, in part reflecting the lack of confidence toward the future of the U.K. (Chart I-10, bottom panel). Hence, the BoE is not responding to these inflationary pressures. This combo is very bearish for the pound. It means that British real rates are falling, especially vis-à-vis the U.S. (Chart I-11). The U.K. is now in a vicious circle where the more the pound falls, the higher British inflation expectations go, which depresses British real rates and puts additional selling pressure on the pound. In other words, the U.K. is in the opposite spot of where Japan was in the spring of 2016. Chart I-10Stagflation Light! Chart I-11A Vicious Circle For GBP What is the downside for the pound? On a 52-week rate of change basis, the pound is not as oversold as it was at long-term bottoms like in 1985, 1993, or 2009. More concerning, long-term bottoms are also characterized by the 2-year rate of change staying oversold for a prolonged period, which again, has yet to be the case (Chart I-12). On the valuation front, GBP/USD is cheap, trading at a 25% discount to its PPP. However, in 1985, the pound was trading at a 36% discount to PPP (Chart I-13). The uncertainty around the future of the British economy is much higher today than in 1985. A move away from the pro-business Thatcherite policies of the 1980s, could result in a GBP discount similar to that of 1985. The sensitivity of the pound to the dollar amplifies the probability that such a scenario materializes. This could imply a GBP/USD toward 1.1-1.05 at its bottom. Chart I-12GBP/USD: Not Oversold Enough Chart I-13GBP/USD Valuation When is that bottom likely to emerge? With the strong downward momentum currently weighing on the pound, and the progressive un-anchoring of market based inflation expectations in the U.K., the bottom in the pound is a moving target. Moreover, Dhaval Joshi, who runs our European Investment Strategy service, has written about the fractal dimension as a tool to identify turning points in a trend. When the fractal dimension hits 1.25, a reversal in the trend is likely. Essentially, this metric measures group-think. When both short-term and long-term investors end up uniformly expressing the same views, liquidity dries up as there are fewer and fewer sellers for each buyer (or vice-versa).2 Currently GBP/USD's fractal dimension has not yet hit that stage. While the 3-6 months risk-reward ratio for the pound remains poor, the pound is now attractive as a long-term buy. The recent collapse in real rates and sterling has massively eased monetary conditions in the U.K. (Chart I-14). Also, even if valuations are a poor guide of near term returns, the 25% discount currently experienced by the pound suggests that on a one- to two-year basis, holding the GBP will be a rewarding bet. What about EUR/GBP? EUR/GBP has moved out of line with its historical link to real-rate differentials (Chart I-15). However, the pound's beta to the dollar is twice as high as that of the euro. Moreover, the pound is many times more sensitive to EM spreads than the euro. This suggests that our view of a strong dollar and tightening EM liquidity conditions are likely to weigh on GBP more than on the EUR for the next few months. Thus we believe it is still too early to short EUR/GBP. In fact EUR/GBP could flirt with 0.95. Chart I-14A Glimmer of Hope For The Long-Term Chart I-15EUR/GBP Has Overshot Fundamentals Bottom Line: While the pound is cheap, it can cheapen further. Not only is the pound being hampered by the political quagmire surrounding Brexit, but the strong sensitivity of the pound to the dollar and EM spreads are two additional potent headwinds for the British currency. Altogether, while the pound is most likely a long-term buy at current levels, it could still experience significant downside in the near term. We remain long gold in GBP terms. Four Chart Reviews Four long-term price charts caught our eye this week. First is EUR/SEK. As Chart I-16 shows, despite the valuation, economic momentum, and balance of payments advantages for the SEK, EUR/SEK broke out. We think this reflects the SEK's strong sensitivity to the dollar and brewing EM risks. A move to slightly above 10 on this cross is likely. Second, while we remain positive on NOK/SEK, the next few weeks may prove challenging. As Chart I-17 illustrates, NOK/SEK is about to test a potent downward sloping trend line, exactly as it is becoming overbought. With NOK being slightly more sensitive to the dollar than SEK, punching above this trend line will require much firmer oil prices. While our energy strategists see oil in the mid- to upper-$50s for next year, they worry that the recent rally to $52/bbl may have been too violent and is already eliciting a supply response from U.S. shale producers. Chart I-16EUR/SEK Can Rise Higher Chart I-17Big Ceiling Above Third, since the early 1980s, GBP/CAD has formed long-term bottom in the 1.5 region, a zone we expect to be tested again (Chart I-18). While CAD is more sensitive to commodity prices than the GBP, it is much less sensitive to the USD and EM spreads than the British currency. Also, the loonie does not suffer from a massive political handicap. That being said, each time the 1.5 zone has been hit, GBP/CAD slingshots higher. We recommend buying GBP/CAD at that level. Finally, since 1991, AUD/JPY has been strongly mean-reverting in a trading band between 60 and 110 (Chart I-19). Any blow-up in EM in the next few months is likely to prompt this cross to hit the low end of this band once again. Chart I-18GBP/CAD: Target 1.5 Chart I-19AUD/JPY: A Model Of Mean Reversion Mathieu Savary, Vice President Foreign Exchange Strategy mathieu@bcaresearch.com 1 This story of his death is now considered more a legend than an historical event, but we like this story. 2 Please see European Investment Strategy Special Report, "Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model", dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "We're at a point where the economic expansion has plenty of room to run. Inflation's a little bit below our target, rather than above our target... so, I think we can be quite gentle as we go in terms of gradually removing monetary policy accommodation" - Federal Reserve Bank of New York President William Dudley (October 12, 2016) Report Links: The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market - September 16, 2016 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "Due to the role of global inflation, more stimulus is needed than in the past to deliver their domestic mandates; and where, due to the falling equilibrium interest rates, their ability to deliver that stimulus is more constrained" - ECB Executive Board Member Yves Mersch (October 12, 2016) Report Links: The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Clashing Forces - July 29, 2016) The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "Since the employment situation has continued to improve, no further easing of monetary policy may be necessary... at any rate, I would like to discuss this thoroughly with other board members at our monetary policy meeting" - BoJ Board Member Yutaka Harada (October 12, 2016) Report Links: The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 How Do You Say "Whatever It Takes" In Japanese? - September 23, 2016 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "If the MPC and other monetary authorities hadn't eased policy - if they had failed to accommodate the forces pushing down on the neutral real rate - the performance of the economy and equity markets, and the long-term prospects for pension funds, would probably have been worse" - BoE Deputy Governor Ben Broadbent (October 5, 2016) Report Links: The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Messages From Bali - August 5, 2016 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "Inflation remains quite low. Given very subdued growth in labor costs and very low cost pressures elsewhere in the world, this is expected to remain the case for some time" - RBA Monetary Policy Statement (October 3, 2016) Report Links: Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market - September 16, 2016 Messages From Bali - August 5, 2016 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "Interest rates are at multi-decade lows, and our current projections and assumptions indicate that further policy easing will be required to ensure that future inflation settles near the middle of the target range" - Reserve Bank Assistant Governor John McDermott (October 11, 2016) Report Links: Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market - September 16, 2016 The Fed is Trapped Under Ice - September 9, 2016 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "Policy is having its effects. And obviously we have room to maneuver but its not a great deal of room to maneuver and fortunately we have a different mix of policy today and the fiscal effects we talked about should be showing up in the data any time now" - BoC Governor Stephen Poloz (October 8, 2016) Report Links: The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market - September 16, 2016 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "We feel [negative interest rates and currency market interventions] is actually how we can ensure our mandate, namely by making the Swiss franc less attractive" - SNB Vice President Fritz Zurbruegg (October 12, 2016) Report Links: Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market - September 16, 2016 Clashing Forces - July 29, 2016 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "Review [of the monetary policy framework] is in order... I would, however, emphasise that our experience of the current framework is positive. This suggests a need for adjustments rather than a regime change" - Norgest Bank Governor Oeystein Olsen (October 11, 2016) Report Links: The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market - September 16, 2016 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "We have all the tools but there are limits since the repo rate and additional bond purchases can produce undesired side-effects... We don't really know for how long future interest rate cuts will work in an effective way." - Riksbank Deputy Governor Cecila Skingsley (October 7, 2016) Report Links: Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Dazed And Confused - July 1, 2016 Grungy Times - A Replay Of The Early 1990s? - June 10, 2016 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Closed Trades
We are pleased to share this <i>Special Report</i> rolling out our Global ETF Strategy (GETF) service's model ETF portfolios.
We are in the latter stages of developing the digital interface that will serve as the central nervous system for the GETF service and are excited to be rolling it out next month. In the meantime, the GETF team has embarked on its regular bi-weekly publication schedule. An ETF Primer <i>Special Report</i> will follow on October 26. It will discuss ETF architecture, operation and trading, and is meant to help investors determine how they can best deploy ETFs to accomplish their tactical and strategic goals.
Hillary Clinton has a 65% chance of winning the election; she receives 334 electoral college votes according to our model. Trump still requires an exogenous shock to win. Meanwhile, the USD is poised to rally - and leftward-moving policymakers will applaud its redistributive effects while MNCs suffer the consequences.
The U.S. dollar's corrective/consolidation phase is over, and it is about to rally. The risk-reward for EM stocks and currencies is extremely unattractive. We are reiterating our recommendation to short a basket of ZAR, BRL, TRY, MYR, IDR and CLP versus the U.S. dollar. There is a value opportunity in the Mexican peso. Go long MXN versus ZAR. Also, double down on the long MXN / short BRL trade.
As the U.S. median voter is shifting to the left, redistributive policy could come into play. A strong dollar helps to achieve this goal as it results in a bigger share of labor income in the economy. EM and commodity currencies could bear the brunt of the pain. Favor the euro on its crosses. Stay short CAD/NOK, but tighten stops.
Our <i>Fourth Quarter Strategy Outlook</i> presents the major investment themes and views we see playing out for the rest of the year and beyond.
In a February <i>Special Report</i> titled "Assessing Fair Value In FX Markets" we introduced a set of long-term valuation models based on various fundamentals. We have updated the results and added KRW, INR, PHP, HKD, CLP and COP to our analysis. The dollar still remains expensive, albeit with no signs of a dangerous overvaluation. The yuan is now at its cheapest level since 2009.
In September, the model outperformed the S&P 500, while it underperformed global equities in both USD and local-currency terms. For October, the model trimmed its allocation to stocks and boosted its weightings in bonds and cash.
It's hard to make a case for attractive returns from any asset class over the next year. We dial down risk a bit but ending our overweight on junk bonds. Investors should pick up yield where they can but without taking excessive risk.