Developed Countries

Last week marked the beginning of the 2021 Q1 earnings season, with the largest money center banks reporting. We will publish an in-depth analysis of the bank earnings on Monday, April 25, 2022, together with our colleagues from the US Investment Strategy team.  This week, 69 companies are reporting. In terms of market expectations: Quarter-on-Quarter earnings growth is expected to be -5% (Chart 1). Similar to previous quarters, we may expect a high number of earnings and sales beats.  However, it is forward guidance that will matter. Chart 1 Year-on-year earnings growth is expected to be 6.3% and 0.7% excluding the Energy sector Year-on-year revenue is expected to be 10.9%. Excluding the energy sector, the growth estimate is 8.3%. Clearly, analysts expect increasing cost pressures to take their toll on corporate profitability. There is a wide dispersion in sector-level expectations (Table 1).  Commodity sectors, such as Energy and Materials are expected to deliver the highest rates of earnings growth, driven by the shortages, exacerbated by the indirect effects of the war in Ukraine.  These are also the best-performing sectors YTD. Technology and Healthcare are expected to deliver strong earnings and sales growth, and so far appear to be immune to slowing growth and inflationary pressures. Earnings of the Consumer Discretionary sector are expected to contract as a result of soaring prices of food and energy, that sap consumer confidence and cut into discretionary spending.  In addition, demand for durable goods was pulled forward by the pandemic and is now waning.   The Financials sector is expected to experience a sharp drop in earnings.  Based on the earnings commentary of the largest banks that have reported so far (JPM, BAC, WFC, C, and MS), there are significant headwinds, which were widely  anticipated. A major drought in deal flow and slowing growth decreased demand for loans. On the bright side, banks with sizeable loan books announced that they expect net interest margins to expand. Table 1 Bottom Line: We continue monitoring 2022 Q1 earnings season for any anomalous results to gauge the health of the US corporations. 

Executive Summary Above Fair Value March’s CPI report will mark peak inflation for 2022. We recommend several ideas to profit from peak inflation. First, investors should keep portfolio duration close to benchmark. The bond market is fairly priced for the likely near-term pace of rate hikes, and long-dated forward yields are now above fair value. Second, investors should underweight TIPS versus nominal Treasuries. They should also favor inflation curve steepeners, real yield curve flatteners and outright short positions in 2-year TIPS. Third, investors should favor the 5-year nominal Treasury note relative to a duration-matched barbell consisting of the 2-year and 10-year notes. The Fed published its plan for shrinking its balance in the minutes from the last FOMC meeting. We estimate that the Fed will be able to shrink its balance sheet at its intended pace for at least the next two years before it is forced to stop. Bottom Line: Investors should position for peak inflation by keeping portfolio duration close to benchmark, by underweighting TIPS versus nominal Treasuries and by favoring the 5-year nominal Treasury note versus the 2-year and 10-year. Feature Chart 1Base Effects Kick In Next Month Last week’s March CPI report showed that 12-month core consumer price inflation came in at 6.44%, a level that will almost certainly mark the peak for the year. Several reasons justify our peak inflation call. First, base effects will send year-over-year core CPI sharply lower during the next three months (Chart 1). Monthly core CPI growth rates were 0.86%, 0.75% and 0.80% in April, May and June 2021 (Chart 1, bottom panel). These exceptionally high prints will roll out of the 12-month average during the next three months. Second, monthly core CPI grew 0.32% in March, a significant step down from the 0.5%-0.6% range that had been the norm since October. If monthly core CPI growth rates remain between 0.3% and 0.4% from now until the end of the year, then 12-month core CPI will fall to a range of 4.19% to 5.13%. We think that trends in the major components of core inflation make this outcome likely, and we could even see inflation falling to below that range. Chart 2 shows the contributions of shelter, goods and services (ex. shelter) to overall core CPI. Chart 2Monthly Core Inflation By Major Component Starting with core goods, we see that prices fell in March for the first time since February 2021. This represents an important inflection point. Core goods, particularly autos, have been the principal driver of current extremely high inflation rates (Chart 3), and these prices will continue to fall in the coming months as supply chain issues are resolved and as goods spending reverts to its pre-pandemic trend (Chart 3, bottom panel). Few dispute that core goods inflation will be weaker going forward. However, one critical question is whether the impact from falling goods prices will simply be offset by the rising cost of services. There was indeed some evidence for this in March. Core services (ex. shelter) prices rose 0.71% in March, up from 0.55% in February. While this is a strong print, it was not sufficient to prevent a drop in overall core inflation from 0.51% to 0.32%. What’s more, March’s core services print was heavily influenced by a surge in airfares that represents a rebound from steep declines seen near the end of last year. With airfares excluded, core services inflation would have only come in at 0.50% in March (Chart 4). Chart 3Goods Inflation Chart 4Services & Shelter Inflation Finally, we turn to the outlook for shelter inflation. Monthly shelter inflation has rebounded to above its pre-COVID levels, but its acceleration has abated during the past few months (Chart 4, bottom panel). Trends in home prices and some indicators of market rents suggest that shelter inflation has some further near-term upside.1 However, shelter inflation is also very sensitive to the economic cycle and the unemployment rate. With that in mind, rapid shelter inflation during the past 12 months is mostly explained by the fact that the unemployment rate fell by almost 2.5%! With the labor market already close to full employment, this sort of cyclical economic improvement will not be repeated during the next 12 months. All in all, we think monthly shelter inflation will average close to its current level during the next nine months. Bottom Line: March’s CPI report marked an inflection point for inflation. Year-over-year inflation will fall sharply during the next few months and will settle close to 4% by the end of the year. Profiting From Peak Inflation Portfolio Duration We have been recommending an “at benchmark” portfolio duration stance in US bond portfolios since mid-February, yet Treasury yields have continued their upward march during the past two months. Our sense is that bond yields now look somewhat too high, and some pullback is likely as inflation moves lower during the next few months. First, let’s consider that the bond market is priced for 262 bps of tightening during the next 12 months (Chart 5), the equivalent of more than ten 25 basis point rate hikes at the next eight FOMC meetings. Our view is that this pricing is close to fair. Chart 5Rate Expectations A 50 basis point rate hike at the May FOMC meeting is now a near certainty. The minutes from the last meeting revealed that “many” participants would have preferred a 50 bps increase in March, but uncertainty surrounding the war in Ukraine prevented that view from becoming consensus. The Treasury curve has also re-steepened significantly during the past few weeks, a development that will ease any concerns about near-term over-tightening. It’s also worth noting that the precedent for a 50 bps hike has now been set by the Reserve Bank of New Zealand and the Bank of Canada. Both central banks lifted their policy rates by 50 bps at their most recent meetings. Chart 6Above Fair Value Beyond May, we expect to see more 25 basis point rate hikes than 50 basis point hikes. Falling inflation will ease some of the Fed’s urgency and the Fed will continue to tighten policy with the goal of getting the fed funds rate close to estimates of the long-run neutral rate by the end of the year. A 25 basis point rate increase at every meeting after May would bring the fed funds rate to a range of 2.0% - 2.25% by the end of the year, just below the Fed’s median estimate of the long-run neutral rate (2.4%). One additional 50 bps hike would bring the funds rate right up to neutral, and such a path would still be consistent with what is currently priced in the curve. Meanwhile, bond pricing at the long end of the yield curve now looks a touch cheap. The 5-year/5-year forward Treasury yield – a market proxy for the long-run neutral rate – has moved up to 2.87%, significantly above survey estimates of the long-run neutral rate (Chart 6). Some pullback closer to survey levels is likely as inflation trends lower. Bottom Line: Keep portfolio duration close to benchmark. Front-end pricing looks fair and long-dated forward yields are somewhat too high. TIPS Perhaps the most obvious way to profit from peak inflation in 2022 is by shorting TIPS versus nominal Treasuries. The 10-year TIPS breakeven inflation rate has risen to 2.91%, well above the Fed’s target range of 2.3%-2.5% (Chart 7). The combination of Fed tightening and falling inflation will send this rate back toward the Fed’s target between now and the end of the year. However, the potential downside in the 10-year TIPS breakeven inflation rate is nothing compared to the 2-year rate. The 2-year TIPS breakeven inflation rate is 4.4% (Chart 7, panel 2) and this short-maturity rate is much more sensitive to the incoming inflation data. Finally, long-maturity TIPS breakeven inflation rates look elevated compared to survey estimates of long run inflation. The 5-year/5-year forward TIPS breakeven inflation rate is currently 2.46%, above the range of estimates from the New York Fed’s Survey of Primary Dealers (Chart 7, bottom panel). In addition to underweight positions in TIPS versus nominal Treasuries, we continue to see the opportunity for an outright short position in 2-year TIPS. The 2-year TIPS yield has risen significantly since the end of last year, but this has been driven by a rising 2-year nominal yield (Chart 8). Going forward, the 2-year TIPS yield still has room to rise but it’s increase will be driven less by a rising nominal yield and more by a falling 2-year TIPS breakeven inflation rate. Chart 7Inflation Expectations Chart 8Sell 2-Year TIPS Consistent with our view that the cost of short-maturity inflation compensation has more downside than the cost of long-maturity inflation compensation, we view positions in 2-year/10-year inflation curve steepeners and 2-year/10-year TIPS curve flatteners as likely to profit during the next nine months (Chart 8, bottom panel). Bottom Line: Investors should underweight TIPS versus nominal Treasuries. They should also position in inflation curve steepeners and real yield curve flatteners and hold outright short positions in 2-year TIPS. Nominal Treasury Curve Chart 9Go Long 5yr Versus 2/10 One final idea is for investors to take a long position in the 5-year Treasury note versus a short position in a duration-matched barbell consisting of the 2-year and 10-year notes. This 5 over 2/10 trade currently offers an attractive 18 bps of yield pick-up, which is much higher than we normally see when the 2-year/10-year Treasury slope is this flat (Chart 9). In fact, a simple model of the 2/5/10 butterfly spread versus the 2-year/10-year slope shows the 5-year bullet to be very cheap relative to history (Chart 9, panel 2). This position will profit from continued 2-year/10-year curve steepening, or more likely, it will profit if the 2-year/10-year slope remains near its current level but the 2-year/5-year slope flattens as the Fed tightening cycle progresses (Chart 9, panel 3). Bottom Line: The recent steepening trend in the 2-year/10-year Treasury slope is likely exhausted, but the 5-year Treasury yield is too high relative to the current 2-year/10-year slope. Investors should go long the 5-year bullet versus a duration-matched 2-year/10-year barbell. The Fed’s Balance Sheet Plan The minutes from the March FOMC meeting revealed the Fed’s plan for shrinking its balance sheet. This plan will likely be put into action at either the May or June FOMC meeting. Specifically, the Fed intends to allow a maximum of $60 billion of Treasuries and $35 billion of MBS to passively run off its portfolio each month. The Fed also hinted that it may decide to start with lower caps and raise them up to the $60 billion and $35 billion targets over a period of three months. However, with the market already well positioned for Quantitative Tightening (QT), this phase-in period will probably not be deemed necessary. For its Treasury securities, the Fed intends to allow a maximum of $60 billion of coupon securities to run off its portfolio each month. If fewer than $60 billion of coupon securities are maturing that month, then the Fed will redeem T-bills to reach the $60 billion target. For MBS, the Fed’s $35 billion per month cap will probably not be binding. Given the slow pace of mortgage refinancings, which will only slow further as interest rates rise, it is unlikely that there will be many months with more than $35 billion of maturing MBS. In fact, some recent Fed research estimated that average MBS runoff will be closer to $25 billion per month going forward.2 Assuming the Fed’s plan starts in June and that MBS runoff averages $25 billion per month, we calculate that the Fed’s Treasury holdings and total assets will still be above pre-COVID levels in 2026 (Chart 10). More important than the Fed’s total assets, however, are the total reserves supplied to the banking system. It is the amount of reserves, after all, that determine whether the Fed can maintain adequate control over interest rates. If too few reserves are supplied, then the fed funds rate will threaten to break above the upper end of the Fed’s target band and the Fed will be forced to increase reserves by either re-starting purchases or engaging in repo transactions. This is exactly what happened when the Fed was forced to abandon its last QT effort in September 2019 (Chart 11). Chart 10Fed Asset Projections Chart 11Reserve Projections Making a few additional assumptions about the growth rate of currency-in-circulation and the size of the Treasury’s General Account, we are able to forecast the path for reserves going forward (Chart 11, top panel). We estimate that reserves will fall to roughly $2 trillion by the end of 2025, still slightly above the levels that caused problems in fall 2019. Ultimately, neither us nor the Fed knows exactly what level of reserves will be adequate to maintain control of interest rates going forward. The Fed will track usage of its new Standing Repo Facility as it shrinks its balance sheet. If usage of the repo facility increases, that will be the sign that the Fed has done enough QT and it is time to start slowly increasing the balance sheet once again. Given the recently published pace of runoff, we think this won’t be story for at least another two years.   Ryan Swift US Bond Strategist rswift@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 For more details please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “A Soft Landing Is Still Possible”, dated March 15, 2022. 2 https://www.newyorkfed.org/newsevents/speeches/2022/log220302 Recommended Portfolio Specification Other Recommendations Treasury Index Returns Spread Product Returns