Special Report
Highlights Higher corporate taxes mean that the structural profit margin will drift lower. Combined with only modestly rising sales, aggregate stock market profits will continue to go nowhere, as they have since 2008. Hence, the continuation of the structural bull market will depend on multiple expansion and a declining global bond yield, as it has since 2008. The good news is that the relationship between a declining bond yield and stock market valuation is exponential. This means that the equity bull market will end when the yield on the US 10-year T-bond and the yield on the Italian 10-year BTP reach zero. Until then, long-term investors should stay in equities. But avoid the three sectors whose profits are in terminal decline: oil and gas, basic resources, and banks (other than for brief countertrend trades). Fractal trade: underweight European basic resources. Feature Feature ChartThe Post-2008 Bull Market Is Due To Higher Valuations, Not Profits A core tenet of investment is under threat. The core tenet is that the stock market goes up because profits go up. This tenet is under threat because, since 2008, the global stock market has nearly doubled while profits have gone nowhere. Granted, the pandemic took its toll on profits in 2020. But we are looking at forward earnings per share, the profits anticipated over the next 12 months. Forward earnings per share are discounting a V-shaped recovery in 2021, and have recovered almost all their pandemic losses. Yet the remarkable thing is that even after this snapback, profits are no higher today than they were in August 2008! This remarkable observation leads to a salutary conclusion. The global stock market has nearly doubled since 2008 because the multiple paid for unchanged profits has nearly doubled (Feature Chart). Furthermore, the reason that the multiple has nearly doubled is that the global bond yield has collapsed. Empirically, the valuation of the global stock market is tightly connected with the simple average of the (inverted) yields on the safest sovereign bond, the US T-bond, and the riskier sovereign bond, the Italian BTP. The salutary conclusion is that the raging bull market since 2008 is entirely due to the collapse in bond yields (Chart I-2). Chart I-2The Post-2008 Bull Market Is Due To The Collapse In Bond Yields Flat Profits Hide Big Winners And Big Losers The preceding analysis applies to the global stock market, and its profits, taken as a sum of the parts. But among the parts are some big winners and some big losers. Although overall profits have gone nowhere since 2008, some sector profits have been in major structural uptrends while other sector profits have been in terminal decline. The major profit uptrends are in technology +170 percent, and healthcare +110 percent (Chart I-3). And the terminal declines are in oil and gas -80 percent, basic resources -40 percent, and banks -35 percent (Chart I-4). Chart I-3The Sector Profits In Structural Uptrends Chart I-4The Sector Profits In Structural Downtrends It follows that among stock markets, the major profit uptrends are in those markets with a high weighting to the sector profits in uptrends: specifically, tech-heavy US +55 percent, healthcare-heavy Denmark +40 percent, and tech-heavy Korea +25 percent (Chart I-5). And the major profit downtrends are in those markets with a high weighting to the sector profits in terminal decline: specifically, bank-heavy Spain -55 percent, Italy -45 percent, and Austria -45 percent (Chart I-6). Chart I-5The Stock Market Profits In Structural Uptrends Chart I-6The Stock Market Profits In Structural Downtrends When profits are in terminal decline, the valuation boost from lower bond yields is not enough to take the stock market higher. Hence, ask an investor in Spain or Italy when the equity bull market will end, and he will look at you quizzically. In Spain and Italy, the bull market ended thirteen years ago! In Spain and Italy, the bull market ended thirteen years ago. One important message for long-term investors is that when a sector’s profits go into structural decline, it is terminal. It is almost unheard of for these sectors to return to structural growth. Furthermore, the support to the sector price from falling bond yields is not enough to offset the weight of collapsing profits. In any case, bond yields cannot fall forever. Hence, long-term investors should stick with the growth sectors. And avoid the three sectors whose profits are in terminal decline: oil and gas, basic resources, and banks. Profit Margins Peaked In 2008 It seems counterintuitive that aggregate stock market profits have gone nowhere since 2008. After all, the world economy has experienced a long expansion during which the revenues of globally listed companies have grown by over 40 percent (Chart I-7). Chart I-7Post-2008, Sales Have Expanded But Profits Have Gone Nowhere If sales are up while profits have gone nowhere, then, as an accounting identity, it means that the profit margin has eroded (Chart I-8). In turn, if profits are taking a smaller share of sales, then, as another accounting identity, some other component must be taking a larger share. That other component has been wages. Wages, as a share of income, reached their low-point just after the 2008 financial crisis, since when they have been trending higher, eroding the profit margin (Chart I-9). Chart I-8The Profit Margin Peaked ##br##In 2008 Chart I-9The Wage Share Of Income Bottomed After The 2008 Crisis Interestingly, this demonstrates that if wages are rising faster than income, it does not necessarily lead to consumer price inflation. Instead, as we have seen since 2008, it can just erode the profit margin. Hence, looking ahead, a key question is what will happen to the wage share of income? What will happen to the profit margin? Another component of income that can erode the profit margin is corporate taxes. So, a further question is what will happen to the corporate tax rate? Predicting The End Of The Bull Market The longevity of the bull market depends on four things: sales, wages, taxes, and the bond yield. Let’s address all four in turn. Sales tend to grow most strongly immediately after a severe recession. Unlike the severe sales recessions of 2008 and 2015, the pandemic recession only made a short-lived dent to the revenues of listed companies. From this starting point, we can expect only modest growth in sales through the next few years. Wages will be subject to opposing forces. High structural unemployment in the post-pandemic world will constrain wage growth. Against this, the wage share of income should benefit from a coordinated global agenda of ‘levelling up’ through, for example, higher minimum wages and increased rights and benefits for workers. Taken together, the wage share of income is likely to go sideways. The much bigger threat to profits is higher corporate taxes. Indeed, after reaching a low after the 2008 financial crisis, the US corporate tax rate did start to rise for a while, before the Trump tax cuts took the corporate tax rate back to a low. However, the newly installed Biden administration, supported by a Democratic House and Senate, is highly likely to reverse the Trump tax cuts, with corporate taxes bearing the brunt (Chart I-10). Chart I-10Corporate Taxes Will Go Up Elsewhere in the world too, governments are desperately seeking ways to mitigate – or at least, contain – ballooning deficits that have paid for the pandemic. Raising corporate taxes is an easy and politically expedient answer. The UK finance minister, Rishi Sunak, is strongly hinting that corporate taxes are going up. The big threat to profits is higher corporate taxes. Higher corporate taxes with a flat wage share of income means that the structural profit margin will continue to drift lower. Combined with gently rising sales, the likely outcome is that aggregate stock market profits will continue to go nowhere, just as they have since 2008. Hence, the continuation of the structural bull market will depend on multiple expansion and a declining global bond yield, just as it has since 2008. Here we can present some good news. The relationship between the declining bond yield and stock market valuation is exponential. This is because as bond yields approach their lower bound, bond prices have less additional upside but more downside. This extra riskiness of bonds means that investors demand a reduced (and ultimately no) risk premium on equities versus bonds. In effect, as bond yields decline, the required return on equities collapses. And as valuation is just the inverse of required return, valuations soar. Chart I-11 demonstrates this exponential relationship in practice. Note that the bond yield is on the logarithmic left scale while the stock market earnings yield is on the linear right scale. The logarithmic versus linear scales visually demonstrate that at a lower bond yield, a given change in the bond yield has a much greater impact on the earnings yield. Chart I-11The Relationship Between Bond Yields And Stock Market Valuations Is Exponential We conclude that the equity bull market will end when the global bond yield can go no lower. In practical terms, this means when the yield on the US 10-year T-bond and the yield on the Italian 10-year BTP reach zero. Until then, long-term investors should stay in equities. Fractal Trading System* The recent outperformance of European basic materials is vulnerable to reversal, given that its fragile 65-day fractal structure has reliably indicated previous reversals. Accordingly, underweight European basic resources versus the market, setting a profit target and symmetrical stop-loss at 4 percent. The rolling 12-month win ratio now stands at 59 percent. Chart I-12Europe: Basic Resources Vs. Market When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report “Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model,” dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com. Dhaval Joshi Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading System Cyclical Recommendations Structural Recommendations Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart I-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart I-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart I-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Interest Rate Chart I-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart I-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart I-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart I-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations
