Global

We are publishing the November issue of Charts That Matter. The key message from the charts on the following pages is that investor sentiment on global growth is elevated and the reflation trade is a bit overstretched. As a result, risk assets and commodities prices will likely correct, and the US dollar will rebound. Investors should keep dry powder to buy EM assets at a better entry point. A trigger for a selloff could be one or a combination of the following: the lack of a large US fiscal stimulus package, falling activity in Europe, peak stimulus in China or the recent jitter in the Chinese onshore corporate bond market. CHART OF THE WEEKThe Global Stock-To-Bond Ratio Is At A Critical Juncture US Equity Sentiment Is Elevated US equity sentiment is somewhat elevated and is consistent with a correction in share prices. Chart 1US Equity Sentiment Is Elevated Chart 2US Equity Sentiment Is Elevated   Peak Growth Sentiment Investors are quite optimistic on global growth. A record large net long positions in copper corroborate a very bullish investor stance on China/EM growth. From a contrarian perspective, this heralds a correction in commodities prices and EM as well as a rebound in the US dollar. Chart 3Peak Growth Sentiment Chart 4Peak Growth Sentiment   Defensive Versus Cyclical Equity Segments Defensive sectors/markets have been underperforming and are oversold. Their outperformance is likely in the near term. Chart 5Defensive Versus Cyclical Equity Segments Chart 6Defensive Versus Cyclical Equity Segments   Near-Term Risks To Industrial Metal Prices The Baltic Dry index is falling and iron ore prices have relapsed. This is consistent with diminishing Chinese imports of iron ore. However, iron ore inventories in China are not excessive, so odds are it is a correction and not a bear market in iron ore prices.  Chart 7Near-Term Risks To Industrial Metal Prices Chart 8Near-Term Risks To Industrial Metal Prices   Chart 9Near-Term Risks To Industrial Metal Prices Chinese Imports Of Commodities Are At Risk From Destocking  Starting April-May, Chinese imports of copper and other commodities was running at very high rates, exceeding any reasonable estimates of final demand. This suggests China has been accumulating commodities. Even as final demand continues recovering, China might diminish imports of commodities weighing on their prices in the near term. Chart 10Chinese Imports Of Commodities Are At Risk From Destocking Chart 11Chinese Imports Of Commodities Are At Risk From Destocking   Oil Prices, Energy Stocks And Glencore Share Price Oil prices and energy stocks are facing a technical resistance. Yet, the share price of the world’s largest global commodity trader – Glencore – seems to be breaking out. The coming weeks will reveal which way the commodities complex will trade. Our bias is that a near-term correction is overdue. The US dollar holds the key, please refer to the next page. Chart 12Oil Prices, Energy Stocks And Glencore Share Price Chart 13Oil Prices, Energy Stocks And Glencore Share Price   Rising US Real Rates (TIPS Yields) Will Lead To A US Dollar Rebound US inflation expectations – which have risen sharply since March – are likely to retreat as the US Senate does not approve a large fiscal stimulus package. Falling US inflation expectations will translate into higher TIPS yields. The latter and very bearish sentiment/positioning on the US dollar will trigger a rebound in the greenback. Chart 14Rising US Real Rates (TIPS Yields) Will Lead To A US Dollar Rebound Chart 15Rising US Real Rates (TIPS Yields) Will Lead To A US Dollar ReboundChart 16Rising US Real Rates (TIPS Yields) Will Lead To A US Dollar Rebound   US Elections And The US Dollar: Is 2020 The Opposite Of 2016? After the 2016 US elections, the US dollar rallied strongly for several weeks and then it sold off considerably. It seems the broad trade-weighted dollar is following a reverse pattern now.  It was selling off before the 2020 US elections and has continued weakening afterwards. If the reverse of the 2016 pattern persists, it means the US dollar is about make a major bottom and stage a playable rebound. Chart 17US Elections And The US Dollar: Is 2020 The Opposite Of 2016? Chart 18US Elections And The US Dollar: Is 2020 The Opposite Of 2016? Chart 19US Elections And The US Dollar: Is 2020 The Opposite Of 2016?   More Reasons To Expect A US Dollar Rebound The periods when US share prices outperform their global peers in local currency terms often coincide with strength in the US dollar. Recently, this relationship has broken down. The greenback might soon recouple to the upside, re-establishing this relationship (Chart 21). Besides, the broad trade-weighted dollar is very oversold (Chart 22). Chart 20More Reasons To Expect A US Dollar Rebound Chart 21More Reasons To Expect A US Dollar Rebound   Rising Real US Yields And Growth Stocks Rising US TIPS yields could create headwinds for growth stocks. FAANG and Tencent share prices have risen about 20-fold since January 2010 – as much as the Nasdaq 100 did in the 1990s before topping out. Chart 22Rising Real US Yields And Growth Stocks Chart 23Rising Real US Yields And Growth Stocks   Drivers Of EM Corporate And Sovereign Credit Spreads EM corporate and sovereign credit spreads are driven by EM exchange rates and commodities prices. A potential US dollar rebound and a correction in commodities prices warrant near-term caution on EM credit markets. Chart 24Drivers Of EM Corporate And Sovereign Credit Spreads Chart 25Drivers Of EM Corporate And Sovereign Credit Spreads Messages From Indicators And Chart Patterns Various indicators and technical chart configurations send mixed signals. Our bias is to expect a correction in risk assets in the near term.  Chart 26Messages From Indicators And Chart Patterns Chart 27Messages From Indicators And Chart Patterns   Chart 28Messages From Indicators And Chart Patterns Chart 29Messages From Indicators And Chart Patterns   Peak Stimulus In China Fiscal stimulus is running out. In addition, the PBoC has been tightening liquidity in the interbank market and interest rates have risen. Banks’ loan approvals have rolled over. All these point to a peak in the credit and fiscal impulse as well as money impulses in Q4 2020. Does it mean China’s economy is about to decelerate? – refer to the next page. Chart 30Peak Stimulus In ChinaChart 31Peak Stimulus In China Chart 32Peak Stimulus In China   China: Business Cycle Expansion To Continue In H1 2021 Our credit and fiscal spending impulse points to a continuous expansion in the Chinese economy for now. If the credit and fiscal impulse rolls over in Q4 2020, as shown in the previous page, the business cycle in China will peak around middle of 2021 given the nine-month time lag between this impulse and economic data. Chart 33China: Business Cycle Expansion To Continue in H1 2021Chart 35China: Business Cycle Expansion To Continue in H1 2021 Chart 34China: Business Cycle Expansion To Continue in H1 2021   Stress In The Chinese Onshore Corporate Bond Market The recent defaults by several SOEs on their bond payments have led to a spike in corporate bond yields. However, there is no stable historical relationship between onshore corporate bond yields and the A-share market. Chart 36Stress In The Chinese Onshore Corporate Bond Market Chart 37Stress In The Chinese Onshore Corporate Bond Market   Chart 38Stress In The Chinese Onshore Corporate Bond Market China: Can Share Prices Rally Amid Rising Corporate Borrowing Costs? During periods of rising onshore corporate bond yields, the MSCI ex-TMT Investable equity index rallied if Chinese EPS expectations where improving. The latest rollover in EPS growth expectations amid rising corporate bond yields is a warning to share prices. Chart 39China: Can Share Prices Rally Amid Rising Corporate Borrowing Costs? Chinese And EM Equity Relative Performance Versus Global Stocks China’s outperformance versus global stocks has been due to its TMT stocks (Alibaba, Tencent and Meituan). In turn, excluding Chinese stocks, EM ex-China has not really outperformed the global equity index. Chart 40Chinese And EM Equity Relative Performance Versus Global Stocks Chart 41Chinese And EM Equity Relative Performance Versus Global Stocks Various EM Equity Indexes Till very recent (before the announcement of progress in vaccines), EM small caps, the equal-weighted index, EM ex-TMT stocks and the EM index ex-China, Korea and Taiwan had been lackluster. Will the latest spike persist? It depends on the S&P500 and global risk asset performance. Chart 42Various EM Equity Indexes Chart 43Various EM Equity Indexes   Chart 44Various EM Equity Indexes Chart 45Various EM Equity Indexes   Emerging Asia And Overall EM Relative Equity Performance Versus Global Stocks Emerging Asia’s and overall EM relative performance versus global stocks is unlikely to break out now. We continue recommending a neutral allocation to EM equities in a global equity portfolio. Chart 46Emerging Asia And Overall EM Relative Equity Performance Versus Global Stocks Chart 47Emerging Asia And Overall EM Relative Equity Performance Versus Global Stocks   Chart 48Emerging Asia And Overall EM Relative Equity Performance Versus Global Stocks Chart 49Emerging Asia And Overall EM Relative Equity Performance Versus Global Stocks   Equities Recommendations Currencies, Credit And Fixed-Income Recommendations

Highlights The stock market’s 60 percent rally since mid-March is reaching a near-term valuation test. Sell stocks and wait on the side lines if the 10-year T-bond yield rises by 0.3 percent. Go aggressively overweight T-bonds on any modest rise in yields. New recommendation: Go overweight healthcare versus technology on a 6-12-month investment horizon. New recommendation: Go overweight Europe versus Emerging Markets on a 6-12-month investment horizon. Fractal trade: Fractal analysis supports the decision to go overweight healthcare versus technology. Feature Since early 2018, a rise in the long bond yield has sent shudders through the stock market on four occasions: February 2018, October 2018, April 2019, and January 2020. On all four occasions, the tipping point was the earnings yield premium on tech stocks versus the 10-year T-bond yield falling towards its lower limit of 2.5 percent (Chart of the Week). Chart of the WeekSell Stocks If The Bond Yield Rises By 0.3 Percent Today, this all-important yield premium stands at 2.8 percent. Meaning that it would take the 10-year T-bond yield to rise by just 30 basis points to retest this four times tipping point. Alternatively, with the T-bond yield unchanged, the tipping point would be retested if tech stocks rallied by around 10 percent. The stock market’s 60 percent rally since mid-March is reaching a near-term valuation test. Crucially, this means that the stock market’s 60 percent rally since mid-March is reaching a near-term valuation test. We recommend selling stocks and waiting on the side lines if the earnings yield gap on tech stocks versus the T-bond yield approaches its lower limit of 2.5 percent – from any combination of moderately higher bond yields or higher stock prices over the coming weeks. Record Low Bond Yields Have Lifted The Stock Market To An All-Time High   ‘A once-in-a-century global pandemic lifts the world stock market to an all-time high’ sounds like an obscene headline. Yet this is the correct narrative for 2020. Yes, the European stock market is still languishing 10 percent below its mid-February peak. But the much larger and tech-heavy US stock market stands 10 percent higher, taking the world market to around 5 percent higher (Chart I-2). How can the aggregate market stand at an all-time high when a terrible plague continues to ravage the global economy? The simple answer: because of record low bond yields. Chart I-2Record Low Bond Yields Have Lifted The Stock Market To An All-Time High Back on February 27, we wrote: “for stock markets, the best inoculation against Covid-19 is ultra-low bond yields.” And so it proved. Though stock market profits are down by 15 percent this year, the multiple paid for those profits is up by 20 percent, resulting in a 5 percent uplift in the market price (Chart I-3). Chart I-3Valuations, Not Profits, Are Driving The Stock Market Specifically, tech sector valuations have become hyper-sensitive to any change in the long bond yield (Chart I-4). Meaning that for those stock markets with a high weighting to tech stocks, the valuation boost from a decline in bond yields has more than countered the profit slump from the pandemic. In fact, the pivotal role of bond yields precedes the pandemic. For the past three years, a good motto for investors has been: don’t focus on profits, focus on valuations. Chart I-4Valuations, Not Profits, Are Driving The Tech Sector The Biggest Threat To The Stock Market Is Higher Bond Yields   Through 2018-19, stock market profits drifted sideways. Yet the stock market fell 30 percent, then rose 30 percent – because the multiple paid for the profits plunged in 2018 then surged in 2019. In 2020, as the pandemic devastated profits, a further surge in the multiple immunised the stock market against the ravages of Covid-19. The dramatic swing in multiples was driven by the dramatic swing in bond yields. This is hardly surprising given that the prospective return on equities is sensitive to the prospective return offered by competing long-duration bonds. But at ultra-low bond yields, this sensitivity becomes hyper-sensitivity. When bond yields approach their lower limit, bond prices approach their upper limit. This means that the scope for further price rises diminishes while the scope for price collapses increases. For proof, just look at Swiss 10-year bonds. Their prices can barely rise anymore! Yet they can fall precipitously (Chart I-5). In short, the lower that bond yields go, the riskier that bonds become as an investment. Chart I-5Swiss Bond Prices Can Barely Rise, But They Can Fall A Lot As bonds become a riskier investment, the excess return on equities versus bonds, the equity risk premium (ERP), collapses towards zero. After all, if the riskiness of equities and bonds converges, then any risk premium must disappear. The result is that the prospective return (discount rate) required on equities declines exponentially, because both of its components – the bond yield plus the ERP – decline in tandem. Given that valuation is just the inverse of the discount rate, the valuation of equities rises exponentially when the bond yield declines to an ultra-low level. Conversely, the valuation of equities falls exponentially when the bond yield rises from an ultra-low level. The valuation of equities rises exponentially when the bond yield declines to an ultra-low level. Yet doesn’t a higher bond yield also imply a higher nominal growth rate for profits, which should be good for the stock market? Yes, but understand that the increase in the discount rate (nominal bond yield plus ERP) will be much larger than the increase in the profit growth rate. The result is a plunge in the stock market’s net present value. Once you grasp this exponential relationship, the penny suddenly drops. The pandemic has proved that the biggest structural threat to the stock market does not come from a negative growth shock like a once-in-a-century global plague. The pandemic has been good for the aggregate stock market because it has forced bond yields to decline to ultra-low levels. Instead, the biggest threat to the stock market is higher bond yields. Please note that this disagrees with the BCA house view – which does not preclude stocks from rising even if yields rise by 0.3 percent, if this takes place against the backdrop of better growth prospects. Sell Stocks If The Bond Yield Rises By 0.3 Percent As the first chart powerfully illustrates, higher bond yields sent shudders through the stock market on four occasions in the past three years. We are close to a similar near-term valuation test. Of course, given enough time, a gradual rise in earnings can lift the tech earnings yield gap versus the bond yield to well above its danger level of 2.5 percent. However, over shorter periods, it would require stock prices and/or bond yields to stop rising. Or indeed, to reverse. For equities, the upshot is that the 60 percent rally since mid-March is reaching near-term exhaustion. We recommend selling stocks and waiting on the side lines if the 10-year T-bond yield was to rise by another 30 bps. For bonds, the upshot is that all else being equal, 10-year bond yields can rise by no more than 30 basis points before sending shudders through the stock market. Which would then cause bond yields to give back their gains, as they did on each of the four previous occasions that higher bond yields spooked the stock market. On this basis, it is not worth underweighting bonds. The much smarter strategy is to go aggressively overweight T-bonds on any modest rise in yields. Within equity sectors, there are three arguments in favour of healthcare. First, while the tech sector earnings yield gap versus the T-bond yield is approaching its lower limit of 2.5 percent, the healthcare sector earnings yield gap stands at a very comfortable and attractive 4.1 percent, well above its recent lower limit of 2.0 percent (Chart I-6). Second, unlike tech, the healthcare sector rally is being driven by profits, not by a valuation uplift (Chart I-7). Third, fractal analysis confirms that the massive underperformance of healthcare versus technology is reaching technical exhaustion (see last section). Chart I-6Healthcare's Earnings Yield Premium Looks Very Attractive Chart I-7Profits, Not Valuation, Are Driving The Healthcare Sector Hence, today we are recommending that on a 6-12-month horizon, equity investors should go overweight healthcare versus technology.  Go Overweight Europe Versus Emerging Markets Finally, sector strategy has huge implications for regional and country allocation. Given that the European stock market is overweight healthcare and emerging markets (EM) is overweight technology, the decision to overweight Europe versus EM is simply the decision to overweight healthcare versus technology. Nothing more, and nothing less (Chart I-8). Chart I-8Europe Versus EM = Healthcare Versus Tech Hence, today we are also recommending that on a 6-12-month horizon, equity investors go overweight Europe versus emerging markets. Fractal Trading System* Supporting the fundamental arguments for healthcare versus tech in the main body of this report, the 130-day fractal structure of relative performance is extremely fragile. This implies that the massive underperformance of healthcare versus tech is at a potential inflection point. Accordingly, this week’s recommenced trade is to go long healthcare versus technology. Set the profit target and symmetrical stop-loss at 6 percent. In other trades, we are pleased to report that long financials versus basic resources achieved its 3.5 percent profit target, and short MSCI India versus MSCI Czech Republic achieved its 8 percent profit target. The rolling 1-year win ratio now stands at 54 percent. Chart I-9 When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report “Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model,” dated  December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com.   Dhaval Joshi Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading System   Cyclical Recommendations Structural Recommendations Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields   Interest Rate Chart II-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations