Global
In a recent insight, we highlighted that Caterpillar’s underperformance since mid-March confirms the current interruption in the reflation trade and suggests that the cause of the pause is global growth concerns. The recent outperformance of Swiss…
In a recent insight, we highlighted our Global Investment Strategists’ view that slowing growth, fears that the Fed is turning more hawkish, and technical factors are all contributing factors to recent US yield curve flattening. The former was brought to the…
Highlights Yield curves have flattened considerably in the major economies since April. Slowing global growth, the perception that the Fed is turning more hawkish, and technical factors have contributed to flatter yield curves. Looking out, we expect the forces pushing down bond yields to abate, with the US 10-year Treasury yield ultimately rising to 1.8%-to-1.9% by the end of the year. Shrinking output gaps, rebounding inflation expectations, and stepped-up Treasury issuance should all push yields higher. Higher yields will benefit bank shares at the expense of tech stocks. Investors should favor value over growth and non-US equities over their US peers. We are closing our long global energy stocks/short copper miners trade. In its place, we are opening a trade to go long the December 2022 Brent futures contract at a price of $66.50/bbl. Flatter Yield Curves Yield curves have flattened considerably in the major economies since April. The US 10-year yield has fallen to 1.31% (and was down to as low as 1.25% intraday last Thursday) from a recent peak of 1.74% on March 31st. The US 2-year yield has risen 7 bps over this period, which has translated into 50 bps of flattening in the 2/10 yield curve. The German bund curve has flattened by 20 bps, the UK curve by 28 bps, the Canadian curve by 52 bps, and the Australian curve by 57 bps. Even the Japanese yield curve has managed to flatten by 13 bps (Chart 1). Chart 1AYield Curves In The Major Economies Have Flattened Since April (I) Chart 1BYield Curves In The Major Economies Have Flattened Since April (II) Chart 2US Economic Surprise Index Is Near A Post-Pandemic Low Three major factors account for the recent bout of yield-curve flattening: Slowing growth: Decelerating growth is usually accompanied by a flatter yield curve. Chinese growth peaked late last year. US growth peaked around March, with the Citi Economic Surprise Index falling to a post-pandemic low last week (Chart 2). European growth will peak over the course of this summer (Table 1). The emergence of the Delta variant has amplified growth concerns. Table 1Growth Is Peaking, But At A Very High Level Fears that the Fed is turning more hawkish: About one-third of the flattening in the US yield curve occurred in the two days following the June FOMC meeting. The shift in the median Fed forecast towards a 2023 rate hike was interpreted by many market participants as a signal that the Fed was unwilling to tolerate a prolonged inflation overshoot (Chart 3). As a result, short-term rate expectations moved up while long-term rate expectations declined (Chart 4). Chart 3The Fed Dots Have Shifted Towards An Earlier Rate Hike Chart 4Markets Saw The June FOMC Meeting As A Turning Point Chart 5Treasury Cash Balances Are Declining Technical factors: Investors were positioned very bearishly on bonds earlier this year, helping to set the stage for a short-covering rally. Meanwhile, with yet another debt ceiling showdown looming in Congress, the Treasury department began to slash T-bill issuance, drawing on its cash balances at the Fed instead (Chart 5). Treasurys, which were already in short supply due to the Fed’s QE program, became even scarcer. All this happened at a time when seasonal factors normally turn bond bullish (Chart 6). Chart 6Seasonality In Markets How these three factors evolve over the coming months will dictate the path of bond yields, with important implications for stocks and currencies. Let’s examine each in turn. Global Growth Will Slow, But Remain Firmly Above Trend Chart 7High Vacancies Suggest Strong Demand For Labor While global growth will continue to decelerate, it will remain well above trend. This is important because ultimately, it is the size of the output gap that determines the timing and magnitude of rate hikes. In the US, the high level of job vacancies suggests that there is no shortage of labor demand (Chart 7). What is missing are willing workers. As we noted in our Third Quarter Strategy Outlook, labor shortages should ease in the fall as expanded unemployment benefits expire, schools reopen, and immigration picks up. The recent rapid decline in initial unemployment claims is consistent with an acceleration in job gains over the coming months (Chart 8). The share of small businesses planning to increase hiring also jumped in June to the highest level in the 48-year history of the NFIB survey (Chart 9). Chart 8Declining Unemployment Claims Point To Further Strong Employment Growth Chart 9Small US Businesses Are Keen To Hire Delta Risk In the US, 32,000 new Covid cases were reported on Wednesday. This pushed the 7-day average to 25,000, double the level it was the first week of July. According to the CDC, more than 90% of US counties with high case counts had vaccination rates below 40% (Map 1). As is in other countries, the highly contagious Delta variant accounts for the majority of new US infections. Map 1AUS Covid Vaccination Coverage Map 1BUS Covid Infection Trends Chart 10Vaccine Makers Are On Track To Produce Over 10 Billion Doses In 2021 The latest Covid wave will slow US economic activity, but probably not by much. The CDC estimates that over 99% of recent US Covid deaths have been among the non-vaccinated population. Vaccinated people have little to fear from the Delta strain and hence, will likely continue to go on with their daily lives. Non-vaccinated people, in most cases, are presumably not very concerned about contracting the virus, so they too will go on with their daily lives. Thus, it is difficult to see how the Delta strain will lead to major behavioral changes. And politically, it will be difficult for governments to legislate lockdowns when everyone who wants a vaccine has been able to receive one. Outside the US, the Delta strain will cause more havoc. Nevertheless, there is a light at the end of the tunnel. Globally, vaccine makers are set to produce over 10 billion doses this year (Chart 10). Many of these vaccines will make their way to emerging economies, which have struggled to obtain adequate supplies. That should help boost EM growth. China Policy Support Chinese retail sales, industrial production, and fixed asset investment all rose faster than expected in June. Yesterday’s solid activity data followed strong trade numbers released earlier this week. Chart 11Chinese Credit Growth Should Stabilize In The Second Half Of The Year Chinese policy is turning more stimulative, which should continue to support growth. Effective this Thursday, the PBOC cut its reserve requirement ratio by 0.5 percentage points, releasing about RMB 1 trillion of liquidity into the banking system. It was the first such cut since April 2020. Total social financing, a broad measure of Chinese credit, rose by RMB 3.7 trillion in June, well above consensus estimates of RMB 2.9 trillion. Credit growth has fallen sharply since last October and is currently running near its 2018 lows (Chart 11). Looking out, Chinese credit growth should pick up modestly as local governments issue more debt. As of June, local governments had used only 28% of their annual bond issuance quota, compared with 61% over the same period last year and 65% in 2019. The proceeds from local government bond sales will likely flow into infrastructure spending, which has been tepid in recent years (Chart 12). Increased infrastructure spending will boost metals prices. With that in mind, we are closing our long global energy stocks/short copper miners trade for a gain of 8.5%. In its place, we are opening a trade to go long the December 2022 Brent futures contract at a price of $66.50/bbl. As Chart 13 shows, BCA’s Commodity and Energy service expects oil prices to keep rising in contrast to market expectations of a price decline. Chart 12China: Weak Infrastructure Spending Should Pick Up Chart 13Oil Prices Have Further Upside The Fed Will Stay Dovish Chart 14Excluding Pandemic-Affected Sectors, Core CPI Has Not Surged As Much As Headline Measures Market participants overreacted to the shift in the Fed’s dot plot. The regional Fed presidents tend to be more hawkish than the Board of Governors. Jay Powell himself probably penciled in one hike for 2023. Lael Brainard, who may end up replacing Powell next year, likely projects no hikes for 2023. Granted, inflation has surged. The CPI rose 5.4% year-over-year in June, above expectations of 4.9%. Core CPI inflation clocked in at 4.5%, surpassing expectations of 4.0%. However, most of the increase in the CPI continues to be driven by a few pandemic-affected sectors. Excluding airfares, hotels, and vehicle prices, the core CPI rose by a modest 2.5% in June. The level of the CPI outside these pandemic-affected sectors is still below trend, suggesting little imminent need for monetary tightening (Chart 14). Many input prices have already rolled over (Chart 15). The price of lumber, which at one point was up 93% from the start of 2021, is now down for the year. Steel prices are well off their highs. So too are memory chip prices. Even used car auction prices are starting to decline (Chart 16). Chart 15Input Prices Have Rolled Over Chart 16Used Car Prices Have Probably Peaked Chart 17Both The Fed And Market Participants Have Revised Down Their Estimate Of The Neutral Rate Of Interest Chart 18Inflation Expectations Have Fallen Back Below The Fed's Target Zone Despite the widespread perception that US monetary policy is ultra-accommodative, current policy rates are only two percentage points below both the Fed’s and the market’s estimates of the terminal rate (Chart 17). Given the zero lower bound constraint on nominal policy rates, tightening monetary policy prematurely could be a grave mistake.Market-based inflation expectations are signaling the need for easier, not tighter, monetary policy. After rising earlier this year, the 5-year/5-year forward TIPS breakeven inflation rate has fallen back below the Fed’s comfort zone (Chart 18). It is highly unlikely that the Fed will commence tapering if long-term inflation expectations remain below target. More likely, the Fed will ramp up its dovish rhetoric over the coming months, allowing inflation expectations to recover. This should put some upward pressure on long-term bond yields. Technical Factors Are Turning Less Bond Friendly Chart 19Investors Were Heavily Short Bonds Earlier This Year While seasonal factors should remain bond bullish over the remainder of the year, other technical factors are turning less supportive. Investors surveyed by J.P. Morgan increased duration exposure over the past four weeks, after having cut it to the lowest level since 2017 (Chart 19). Traders also cut short positioning on the 30-year bond by two-thirds from record levels. Treasury issuance should normalize by the fall. While the obligatory brinkmanship over the debt ceiling is likely to extend beyond the August 1st deadline, BCA’s chief political strategist Matt Gertken believes that Democrats will ultimately be able to raise the ceiling. Senate Democrats may end up using the reconciliation process to both raise the debt ceiling and pass President Joe Biden’s $3.5 trillion American Jobs and Families Plan with 51 votes along. They are also likely to move forward on passing Biden’s proposed $600 billion in traditional infrastructure, with or without Republican support. The combination of increased Treasury supply and more fiscal spending should translate into higher bond yields. Higher Bond Yields Favor Value Stocks We expect the US 10-year Treasury yield to move back up to 1.8%-to-1.9% by the end of the year. Bond yields in other markets will also rise, but less so than in the US, given the relatively “high beta” status of US Treasurys (Chart 20). In contrast to tech stocks, banks usually outperform when bond yields are rising (Chart 21). The recent pickup in US consumer lending should also help bank shares (Chart 22). Chart 20US Treasuries Have A Higher Beta Than Most Other Government Bond Markets Chart 21Bank Shares Thrive In A Rising Yield Environment Chart 22Recent Pickup In US Consumer Lending Will Help Bank Shares Chart 23Outperformance Of Tech Stocks Not Backed By Trend In Earnings Estimates Chart 24Non-US Stocks And Value Stocks Typically Perform Best When The Dollar Is Falling It is worth noting that the outperformance of tech stocks over the past six weeks has not been mirrored in relative upward revisions to earnings estimates (Chart 23). Without the tailwind from relatively fast earnings growth, tech names will lag the market over the remainder of 2021. The US dollar usually weakens when growth momentum rotates from the US to the rest of the world, which is likely to occur in the second half of this year. A dovish Fed will put further downward pressure on the greenback. Non-US stocks and value stocks typically perform best when the dollar is falling (Chart 24). Peter Berezin Chief Global Strategist peterb@bcaresearch.com Global Investment Strategy View Matrix Special Trade Recommendations Current MacroQuant Model Scores
Central bankers have given investors a lot to think about regarding the future path of global monetary policies recently. To recap, since July 6: the European Central Bank unveiled a new symmetric interpretation of its 2% inflation target the Reserve Bank…
Over a 12-month horizon, investors should maintain a modest overweight allocation to equities. Although pandemic-related uncertainties linger – particularly regarding the emergence and impact of variants – global growth will remain strong. And even though…
The spectacular outperformance of global equities versus bonds since the pandemic trough has been accompanied by declining volatility in all asset classes globally. But investors are now close to fully invested in US equities. Sentiment in financial markets…
Highlights Inflation is set to decelerate, job creation has a speed limit, and super-spreaders of new-variant Covid-19 infections will create speed bumps in the economy. This means that in the second half of the year: Bonds will rally. The US dollar will rally. Growth stocks will outperform value stocks. US stocks will outperform non-US stocks. Fractal trade shortlist: Brazilian real, Saudi Tadawul All Share, and Marine Transportation. Feature Chart of the WeekThe 60 Percent Correction In Lumber Shows What Happens When Supply Bottlenecks Ease. Are Used Cars Next? As Supply Bottlenecks Ease, Inflation Will Cool Since mid-March, US inflation has surged to 5 percent. Yet bond yields have drifted lower, by almost 50 bps in the case of the 30-year T-bond yield, equating to a handsome return of 12 percent. The seeming contradiction between rising inflation and declining bond yields has puzzled some people, but it shouldn’t. In 2009, the same pattern occurred in reverse. Inflation collapsed, culminating in a modern era low of -2 percent in July 2009. Yet while inflation was collapsing, bond yields rose sharply (Chart I-2 and Chart I-3). Chart I-2In 2009, Bond Yields Rose When Year-On-Year Inflation Fell Chart I-3In 2021, Bond Yields Fell When Year-On-Year Inflation Rose We can explain this seeming contradiction with an analogy from driving. The inflation rate is like your average speed over the past mile. But the bond market cares much more about your average speed over the next mile, or even over the next 5-10 miles. If you are driving at a constant speed, then your speed over the past mile is a good guide to your future speed. But if you have been driving unusually fast or unusually slowly, there is a more important predictor of your future speed. That important predictor is your acceleration – meaning, what is happening to your speed over successive hundred yards stretches. In the same way, during episodes of unusually low or unusually high inflation, the bond market focusses on the monthly rate of inflation, and specifically the moment that it stops decreasing, as in early-2009, or stops increasing, as in mid-2021. In 2008, after a long sequence of declining monthly rates of inflation that went deep into negative territory, the December 2008 print marked the first substantial increase. Hence, the bond yield also bottomed in December 2008 (Chart I-4), even though annual inflation did not bottom until July 2009. Chart I-4In 2009, Bond Yields Bottomed When Month-On-Month Inflation Bottomed Similarly, in 2020-21, after a six month sequence of increasing monthly rates of inflation, the May 2021 print marked the end of the rising trend. To the extent that this was anticipated, most of the decline in the bond yield has happened since mid-May (Chart I-5). Chart I-5In 2021, Bond Yields Topped When Month-On-Month Inflation Topped Since mid-May, the 60 percent crash in the lumber price shows what happens when supply bottlenecks ease. Other prices that are being supported by temporary supply constraints – such as used car prices – are likely to suffer the same fate (Chart of the Week). Hence, so long as the coming monthly prints confirm an ongoing deceleration in inflation, the current rally in bonds will stay intact. Jobs: The Hard Work Starts Now Staying on the theme of speed, there is a well-defined speed limit to every post-recession jobs recovery. In A Fed Rate Hike By Early 2023 Is Pie In the Sky, we pointed out the remarkable consistency in the pace of post-recession US jobs recoveries. The last five recessions had different causes, severities, durations and peak unemployment rates. Yet in the recoveries that followed each recession, the unemployment rate declined at a remarkably consistent pace of 0.4-0.5 percent per year (Table I-1). Table I-1After Every Recession, The Pace Of Recovery In The Jobs Market Is Near-Identical Reassuringly at the last FOMC press conference, Jay Powell supported this thesis: Most of the act of sort of going back to one's old job – that's kind of already happened. So, this is a question of people finding a new job. And that's just a process that takes longer. There may be something of a speed limit on it. You've got to find a job where your skills match, you know, what the employer wants. It's got to be in the right area. There's just a lot that goes into the function of finding a job. Powell’s comments lead to two further points: The act of going back to one’s old job for those on ‘temporary layoff’ is relatively straightforward. For job creation, this is the low hanging fruit, most of which has already been picked. Now comes the much harder part – finding jobs for those ‘not on temporary layoff’ whose numbers have barely declined from the peak (Chart I-6). Chart I-6For Job Creation, The Low Hanging Fruit Has Already Been Picked One way of encapsulating this is to observe that the unemployment rate – including those on temporary layoff – has already made 80 percent of the journey from its recession peak to the February 2020 trough, which makes it seem that the jobs recovery is largely done. However, the unemployment rate for those not on temporary layoff has made only 25 percent of the journey (Chart I-7). Moreover, this process is not a straight line, it is a curve. The first quarter of the journey is the easiest, then it gets harder. Chart I-7The Hard Part Is Finding Jobs For Those Unemployed 'Not On Temporary Layoff' As we, and Jay Powell, have pointed out, the process to reduce this unemployment rate has a remarkably consistent speed limit of 0.4-0.5 percent per year. Starting at the current rate of 2.5 percent and a target of 1.5 percent, this means full employment will not be reached before the second half of 2023. And even this assumes clear blue skies for the world economy through the next two years, which is a tall order. We conclude that the market pricing of a Fed funds rate lift-off in December 2022 is much too optimistic, making the December 2022 Eurodollar contract a good buy. The End Of Pandemic Restrictions Will Unleash Super-Spreaders On July 19, the UK will remove all its domestic pandemic restrictions – meaning no more facemasks, social distancing, and limits on the size of gatherings. This doesn’t mean that the pandemic is over in the UK. Far from it. The delta variant of the virus is rampant. Rather, with a large portion of the population vaccinated, the government is replacing state-imposed laws and regulations with a libertarian onus on personal responsibility. Given that Covid-19 is not going away, the UK strategy raises a fundamental question. Other than implementing a vaccination program, what role should a government take in containing the virus? In Who’s Right On The Pandemic – Sweden Or Denmark? we revealed two important findings: First, it is a misunderstanding that state-imposed restrictions cause the collapse in social consumption. This is a classic confusion between correlation and causation. The true cause of the recession is that a virulent disease focuses millions of people on self-preservation, shunning crowds and public places. But to the extent that the pandemic also leads to state-imposed restrictions, many people blame the slowdown on these correlated restrictions rather than on the underlying cause – the voluntary change in behaviour. Second, without state-imposed restrictions, the majority will voluntarily change their behaviour to avoid catching and spreading the virus, but a minority will not. When a virus is spreading, this is critical because a tiny minority of so-called ‘super-spreaders’ is responsible for most infections. Put simply, economic growth depends on the behaviour of the majority and in a pandemic the majority will voluntarily reduce their social consumption. This explains why libertarian Sweden and lockdown Denmark suffered similar contractions in their economies (Chart I-8). Chart I-8Libertarian Sweden Has Not Significantly Outperformed Lockdown Denmark... In contrast, containing the virus depends on restricting the minority of super-spreaders. Which explains why libertarian Sweden suffered a much worse outbreak of the disease than lockdown Denmark (Chart I-9). Chart I-9...But Libertarian Sweden Has Suffered Many More Covid-19 Casualties The worry now is that the end of state-imposed restrictions will unleash super-spreaders and super-spreading events. This will allow the virus to replicate, mutate, and create new variants which are potentially more transmissible and resistant to existing vaccines. Pulling together our three themes for the second half of the year, inflation is set to decelerate, job creation has a natural speed-limit, and super-spreaders of new-variant Covid-19 infections will create speed bumps in the economy. This means that: Bonds will rally. The US dollar will rally. Growth stocks will outperform value stocks. US stocks will outperform non-US stocks Candidates For Countertrend Reversal This week, we present three candidates for countertrend reversal. First, the Brazilian real’s recent surge has hit expected resistance at 65-day fractal fragility. A good way to play a continued reversal is to short BRL/COP (Chart I-10). Chart I-10The Brazilian Real Is Correcting Second, within emerging markets, the strong rally in the Saudi equity market is vulnerable to a setback, especially versus other markets. A good way to play this is to short the Saudi Tadawul All Share index versus the FTSE Bursa Malaysia KLCI, given that the 260-day fractal structure is at the point of fragility that marked the major top in 2014 (Chart I-11). Chart I-11The Saudi Stock Market Is Vulnerable To A Setback Finally, coming full circle to short-term supply bottlenecks, one major beneficiary has been the Marine Transportation sector which, since February, has outperformed the world market by 70 percent. As the supply bottlenecks ease, this is vulnerable to correction, especially as the 260-day fractal structure is at the point of fragility that marked the major top in 2007 (Chart I-12). Chart I-12Underweight Marine Transportation Hence, this week’s recommended trade is to underweight Marine Transportation versus the market, setting the profit target and symmetrical stop-loss at 16.5 percent. Dhaval Joshi Chief Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading System Fractal Trades 6-Month Recommendations Structural Recommendations Closed Fractal Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Equity Market Performance Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields - Euro Area Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields - Europe Ex Euro Area Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields - Asia Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields - Other Developed Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations
The MacroQuant global equity score is a market-weighted composite of all the regional equity scores within the model. It ranges between 0% and 100%, with 0% being most bearish and 100% being most bullish. Read the full details on MacroQuant in the recently…
Global manufacturing PMI in June was at robust 54.4, indicating that more than 50% of global manufacturing industries continue expanding. Such a robust reading of global manufacturing PMI was despite the weakness in Asian manufacturing PMIs including ones in…