Consumer Discretionary
Underweight Last Monday we executed our S&P homebuilders downgrade alert and reduced allocation in this consumer discretionary sub-group to below benchmark. While the media has been cheering homebuilder-related data recently, the reality is that the data has been fully priced in (top & bottom panels). We expect rates to continue climbing higher, which means that the catalyst that let homebuilders run wild in the first place will be heavily weighing on the index. In more detail, the middle panel of the chart shows that the ten-year US Treasury yield (shown inverted) has likely sealed the verdict for US homebuilders when looking at the sub-group in absolute terms, which makes relative outperformance a tall order. Bottom Line: We reiterate our recent underweight in the S&P homebuilding index; the position is already up 9% since the November 23 inception. The ticker symbols for the stocks in the index are: BLBG: S5HOME – LEN, PHM, DHI, NVR.
In this Monday’s Strategy Report we upgraded the S&P hotels, resorts & cruise lines index to an above benchmark allocation in light of the improving macro backdrop. Consumer sentiment has staged a W-shaped recovery and while still flimsy, the brightening vaccine efficacy news should catapult it higher in the coming quarters. The implication is that the wide gulf between consumer confidence and relative hotels share prices will narrow via a catch-up phase in the latter (top panel). Closely linked to the budding recovery in confidence are discretionary versus non-discretionary retail sales. The latter have been correlated with the oscillations in relative share prices, and the current message is positive (bottom panel). Finally, the ISM non-manufacturing survey is on a sling shot recovery following the depths of the spring readings. This rebound also suggests that the path of least resistance is higher for lodging stocks (middle panel). Bottom Line: Upgrade the S&P hotels, resorts & cruise lines index to overweight. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5HOTL – MAR, HLT, CCL, RCL, NCLH.
Dear Client, As is custom every year, next Monday November 30 instead of our regular Strategy Report you will receive BCA’s flagship publication “The Bank Credit Analyst” detailing the house views and themes for next year. Our regular publishing schedule resumes on December 7 with our 2021 High-Conviction Calls Strategy Report. On December 14 we will host a Webcast to discuss our calls in more detail and answer questions. Happy Thanksgiving. Kind Regards, Anastasios Highlights Portfolio Strategy A firming demand backdrop for lodging services courtesy of the positive vaccine news, enticing industry operating metrics along with compelling valuations encourage us to take a punt on the niche S&P hotels, resorts & cruise line index. In marked contrast, we recommend investors avoid the high-flying S&P homebuilding index. Home-related survey data paint a rosy picture for homebuilding demand in the coming months underpinned by low mortgage rates and low housing supply. Nevertheless, most of the good news is baked in resurgent homebuilder stock prices and the prospects of rising interest rates, a looming profit margin squeeze and extremely high earnings expectations warn that the time is ripe to shed S&P homebuilding exposure. Recent Changes Upgrade the S&P hotels, resorts & cruise lines index to overweight, today. Downgrade the S&P homebuilding index to underweight, today. Feature Similar to two Mondays ago, the SPX opened weekly trading with gusto courtesy of MRNA’s 94% efficacy vaccine news, but failed to breach previous all-time highs. The market has rallied roughly 10% this month, and while we remain cyclically and structurally bullish, a short-term consolidation period is likely in the cards. Extremely easy financial conditions along with a near halving in implied volatility – which have been key rally drivers since the March lows as we pointed out numerous times in our research – are nearly perfectly priced in the SPX. The implication is that were a meaningful rally to resume, further easing is required which is a tall order (top panel, Chart 1). Another factor underpinning the market’s recent advance is the drop in the CBOE’s implied correlation index (pair wise correlation of S&P500 constituents, shown inverted, bottom panel, Chart 1). However, correlations have collapsed and are near levels that have marked prior temporary peaks in the SPX. Beyond near-term jitters, output is poised to recover smartly next year and most importantly so are SPX EPS. In a recent Special Report we lifted our EPS target to $168 for calendar 2021 and introduced an end-2021 SPX target of 4,000. The GS Current Activity Indicator corroborates our macro four-factor profit growth estimate and heralds a slingshot EPS recovery next year (Chart 2). Chart 1Good News Is Priced In Chart 2One More V-Shape Is Coming Turning over to capital spending, the latest GDP report was revealing. On the surface private sector capex made a splash with non-residential investment contributing 2.88% to real GDP growth, the highest since Q4/1983 when the economy was recovering from that severe double-dip recession. In absolute terms, the Q/Q annualized growth clocked in at over 20%, a growth rate last seen in the late-1990s (Chart 3). Drilling deeper into capex is instructive. Technology investment was on fire. Surprisingly, software took the back seat and investment in tech goods roared. In other words, this data confirms that businesses and consumers alike prepared to work from home and bought up tech gadgets en masse, and stole demand from the future (Chart 3). Looking ahead we expect a reversal of this trend with software retaking the reigns and the rest of the tech sector fading. As a reminder, while base effects really augmented this capex rebound, recovering animal spirits signal that a capex upcycle is in the offing. We have shown in the past that as profits grow, CEOs become more confident in the longevity of the cycle and choose to deploy long-term oriented capital, albeit with a one-year lag. Eventually, this creates a virtuous upcycle where rising profits lead to rising capital outlays that further boost sales and profits and sustain the positive feedback loop (Chart 4). Chart 3Exploring Investment Data Chart 4Lagging Capex Will Also Recover This week we make two sub-surface consumer discretionary sector changes further adding exposure to our back-to-work reopening laggards and shedding exposure to work-from-home winners. Open For Business While admittedly we were early in locking in gains in the S&P hotels, resorts & cruises index last spring by lifting exposure to neutral from underweight, today we are compelled to augment this niche leisure index to an overweight stance. Relative share prices have bounced at a level last seen during the GFC and not far off the level hit post the 9/11 accelerated recession that dealt a big blow to everything travel related (top panel, Chart 5). The recent positive vaccine news is a key reason we are warming up to this consumer discretionary sub group. While neither lodging nor cruise line vacationing will return to their previous peaks any time soon, both industries will survive and thus should no longer be priced for bankruptcy. Industry pricing power has plunged, but it is trying to trough at an extremely depressed level (middle panel, Chart 5). As a result, profit margins have gone haywire (bottom panel, Chart 5), but again most of the negative news is likely priced into this negative profits backdrop. Chart 5Fell Off A Cliff… One key industry demand determinant is confidence. Consumer sentiment has staged a W-shaped recovery and while still flimsy the brightening vaccine efficacy news should catapult it higher in the coming quarters. The implication is that the wide gulf between consumer confidence and relative share prices will narrow via a catch up phase in the latter (top panel, Chart 6). Closely linked to the budding recovery in confidence are discretionary versus non-discretionary retail sales. Thus, the latter have been tightly correlated with the oscillations in relative share prices, and the current message is positive (top panel, Chart 7). Chart 6...But There Are Signs Of Life Moreover, the ISM non-manufacturing survey is on a sling shot recovery following the depths of the spring readings. This rebound also suggests that the path of least resistance is higher for lodging stocks (middle panel, Chart 6). Chart 7Enticing Signals On the business side, capex intentions are slated to increase in the coming year – as we highlighted above on the back of recovering animal spirits – and by extension so will business-related travel (bottom panel, Chart 7). Our hotel demand indicator does an excellent job at encapsulating all these different forces and forecasts an enticing lodging services demand backdrop into 2021 (bottom panel, Chart 6). Already, consumer outlays on hotels are staging a comeback albeit from an extremely depressed level. The upshot is that an earnings-led rebound is in the cards (middle panel, Chart 7). With regards to industry operating metrics, industry executives have reined in expansion plans: construction spending on hotels has been contracting all year long. At the margin, such a supply restraint on the heels of a seven-year expansion phase is quite encouraging (middle panel, Chart 8) as it will aid in the industry’s efforts to lift beaten down occupancy rates. Another reassuring industry operating metric is the confirmation that hotel workers are returning to work. Not only has leisure and hospitality employment absorbed more than half the losses suffered since the spring carnage, but also industry hours worked have ticked higher of late (bottom panel, Chart 8). Finally, washed out technicals and extremely alluring valuations provide an attractive reward/risk tradeoff at the current juncture (Chart 9). Chart 8Receding Supply Is Good Chart 9Plenty Of Upside Netting it all out, a firming demand backdrop for lodging services courtesy of the positive vaccine news, enticing industry operating metrics along with compelling valuations encourage us to take a punt on the niche S&P hotels, resorts & cruise line index. Bottom Line: Upgrade the S&P hotels, resorts & cruise lines index to overweight, today. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5HOTL – MAR, HLT, CCL, RCL, NCLH. Contrarian Housing Call Today we recommend a downgrade in the S&P homebuilding index to underweight. Since the March 23 SPX lows, consumer discretionary stocks are up 74%, besting the S&P 500 by 1500 basis points (bps). While single stock GICS4 sub-groups like household appliances (i.e. Whirlpool) have reached escape velocity rising over 200% over the same time frame, the S&P homebuilding index is also up a whopping 140%. While we were quick enough to close our underweight recommendation in March and cement impressive relative gains for the portfolio to the tune of 50%, we refrained from lifting exposure all the way to overweight and remained at benchmark. As a reminder, we opted instead to play a housing rebound via the sister home improvement retail index in mid-April that also added significant alpha to our portfolio. Residential real estate optimism abounds. The media’s bombardment is non-stop reminding consumers of runaway home prices, all-time lows in fixed mortgage rates (third panel, Chart 10) and nearly non-existent housing inventory (supply of homes shown inverted, middle panel, Chart 11), painting an urgency to stampede into home buying (top panel, Chart 11). Chart 10Positives Reflected In Prices Chart 11The Good… True, the COVID-19 recession has acted as an accelerant to the suburban housing boom and there is an element of at least a semi-permanent shift away from city centers and toward the suburbs as the work-from-home flexibility is not a fad. Tack on all-time highs on the overall NAHB housing sentiment survey and a number of sub-components like sales expectations (second panel, Chart 10) and no wonder mortgage applications to purchase a new home are also flirting with multi-year highs (bottom panel, Chart 10). Another survey, part of the Conference Board’s consumer confidence monthly survey, revealed that consumers’ plans to buy a new home are also probing all-time highs (second panel, Chart 10). Even the Fed’s October Senior Loan Officer survey highlighted that demand for residential mortgage loans is on the mend (bottom panel, Chart 11). However, we deem that most, if not all, of the good news is already priced in galloping homebuilders stock prices and exuberant expectations. While being contrarian is fraught with danger, as more often than not the herd is right, there is a key macro driver that gives us confidence to our going against the grain housing trade: interest rates. If our economic reopening thesis proves accurate next year, then the COVID-19 winners – homebuilders included – will take the back seat. Importantly, as the economy rebounds and is ready to stand on its own two feet, then the selloff in the bond market should gain significant steam. Using our 100-125bps rule of thumb to gauge how much monetary tightening the economy can withstand in a year’s time, then the 10-year US Treasury yield can hit 1.5% by next March. Historically, interest rates and relative share prices have been inversely correlated and a steep selloff in the bond market is bad news for homebuilding stocks (top panel, Chart 12). Chart 12...The Bad... Chart 13...And The Ugly Meanwhile on the operating housing front, some cracks are forming. New home sales, while brisk in absolute terms, are losing out to existing housing sales and homebuilders have resorted to price concessions in order to drive volumes (second, third & bottom panels, Chart 12). Profit margins are at the highest mark since the subprime crisis and are vulnerable to a squeeze not only from lower selling prices, but also from rising input costs. Framing lumber comprises roughly 15% of a new home’s commodity related costs and lumber prices have been expanding all year long (Chart 13). Finally, unfettered sell-side optimism reigns supreme. Net earnings revisions cannot go any higher as they hit a wall at the 100% ceiling. One year forward relative profit growth expectations are literally through the roof, and even five-year relative EPS growth estimates are up 1500bps since the 2019 nadir (Chart 14). All these metrics represent a high bar for homebuilders to surpass and we would lean against such extreme enthusiasm toward this niche early-cyclical group. However, there is a key risk to our bearish homebuilders call we are monitoring: cheap valuations. On relative forward P/E, trailing P/S and EV / EBITDA bases, home construction stocks offer compelling value (bottom panel, Chart 14). Whether this is a value opportunity or a trap, the jury is still out. For the time being we side with the latter. Chart 14Peak Sell-Side Euphoria In sum, home-related survey data paint a rosy picture for homebuilding demand in the coming months underpinned by low mortgage rates and low housing supply. Nevertheless, most of the good news is baked in resurgent homebuilder stock prices and the prospects of rising interest rates, a looming profit margin squeeze and extremely high earnings expectations warn that the time is ripe to shed S&P homebuilding exposure. Bottom Line: Trim the S&P homebuilding index to underweight, today. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5HOME – LEN, PHM, DHI, NVR. Anastasios Avgeriou US Equity Strategist anastasios@bcaresearch.com Current Recommendations Current Trades Strategic (10-Year) Trade Recommendations Size And Style Views October 26, 2020 Favor small over large caps July 27, 2020 Overweight cyclicals over defensives June 11, 2018 Long the BCA Millennial basket The ticker symbols are: (AAPL, AMZN, UBER, HD, LEN, MSFT, NFLX, SPOT, TSLA, V). January 22, 2018 Favor value over growth
Neutral – Downgrade Alert It no longer pays to chase the S&P homebuilding index higher; it is now on our downgrade alert watch-list. The recent pandemic-induced drubbing in interest rates boosted housing affordability and caused a knee jerk reaction in the mortgage application purchase index, which in turn served as a catalyst for the recent rally (top & middle panels). However, as the economy continues to open up, interest rates will reverse course and flip from a tailwind into a headwind. Sell-side analysts are also upgrading their earnings forecasts at the highest pace since the GFC, and we would lean against this extreme bullishness (bottom panel). Bottom Line: We are neutral the S&P homebuilders index, but it is now on our downgrade watch-list. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5HOME – LEN, PHM, DHI, NVR. For more details, please refer to the recent Weekly Report.
Dear client, Next Monday, October 19, we will be hosting our quarterly webcast, “From Alpha To Omega With Anastasios”, at 10am EST; Matt Gertken, BCA’s Geopolitical Strategist will be our guest on the eve of the US Presidential Election. Our regular weekly publication will resume on Monday October 26, 2020. Kind Regards, Anastasios Highlights Portfolio Strategy Homebuilders are more than fully priced, discounting high margins as far as the eye can see and no end to demand. The specter of higher interest rates, lumber inflation, stealing demand from the future, unfriendly bankers and uncertainty with regard to a fresh stimulus package more than offset the positives, and compel us to issue a downgrade alert for the S&P homebuilding index. While the price of credit, loan growth prospects and credit quality all weigh on relative bank performance. A fiscal stimulus bill, depressed valuations and a Fed induced resumption of dividend hikes and share buybacks keep us on the sidelines in the S&P banks index. Recent Changes There are no changes to our portfolio this week. Table 1 Feature Equities seesawed last week as President Trump returned to the White House (WH) and injected fresh volatility in markets signaling that there will be no fiscal deal prior to the elections. The SPX immediately gapped down and we cannot stress enough the importance of our newly configured Fiscal Policy Loop: fiscal hawkishness causes skittishness in markets culminating to a classic BCA riot point and then policymakers relent and fiscal dovishness restores the equity bull market (Figure 1). While we cannot rule out a slimmed-down stimulus package deal by later this month, fiscal policy- and election-related uncertainties remain elevated. The daily back-and-forth on where Congress and the WH stand with passing a new stimulus bill coupled with the prospects of a contested election that would drag on the presidential race likely into December, have caused investor fatigue. The sooner both of these uncertainties recede, the quicker the SPX will climb to fresh all-time highs (Chart 1). Figure 1The Fiscal Policy Loop Chart 1Receding Uncertainty Will Boost Stocks We have shown in recent research, and update today, that the fourth year of presidential cycles finds the SPX ending the year on average in the green with a calendar return in the high single digits (Chart 2). Peering back in 2016 is instructive as that presidential election cycle year was in some ways similar to the current one. The economy, in particular, was fighting off a manufacturing recession that spread and infected the services sectors as the vast majority of S&P GICS1 sectors saw profit contraction and more importantly revenue declines. Chart 3 shows a number of asset classes and compares 2016 with 2020. The 10-year US Treasury yield appears poised to rebound significantly, especially if Congress passes a fresh fiscal package that aides the parts of the economy that need the stimulus checks most. Fiscal easing uncertainty remains a thorny issue across different markets and if history is an accurate guide, the SPX could glide lower into the November election before rallying into year-end. Chart 2Back Up Near The Average Profile Meanwhile, a number of investors we talk to also experience COVID-19 fatigue (Chart 4). For the better part of the last 10 months media has constantly bombarded the world with pandemic news, and rightly so. However, all this seems dystopian by now, and we cannot wait for a semblance of normality to make a comeback, which a vaccine will definitively bring about. The equity market has been indurated to this news-flow and has shaken-off the recession. When the vaccine does arrive likely next year, profits will also return back to trend, as we have been arguing for some time, because the global economy will fully reopen. Chart 32016 Versus 2020 Already, if we juxtapose leading soft economic data surprises with lagging hard economic data surprises, it is clear that a stellar profit recovery looms (second panel, Chart 5). Similarly, within soft the data universe, the ISM new orders-to-inventories ratio paints a rosy picture for an earnings recovery in 2021 (third panel, Chart 5). Even within hard economic data, a simple liquidity indicator we have used in the past comparing industrial production (IP) with M2 money stock signals that S&P profits have troughed (IP vs. M2 shown advanced, bottom panel, Chart 5) Chart 4COVID Fatigue Finally, the US Equity Strategy’s four-factor macro profit growth model has slingshot higher recently and signals that a return to $162 level of EPS in calendar 2021 is a high probability outcome (Chart 6). Netting it all out, we are in the tail end of the equity market correction and as election and fiscal policy uncertainties ebb, they will pave the way for a robust SPX rally. Chart 5Profit Recovery On Track Chart 6EPS Model Concurs This week, we continue with our strategy of preferring beaten-down cyclicals to defensives and steer the portfolio away from another safe haven staples industry via downgrading a consumer goods subgroup to underweight. We also delve deeper into the banking industry highlighting some cracks in small commercial banks. Put Homebuilders On Downgrade Alert Homebuilders have had a monster run since the depths of the recession back in March and the question a lot of our clients are now asking is: does it make sense to chase them higher at the current juncture? The short answer is no. Before we get into the details of our analysis a brief recap of our recent residential real estate-related moves is in order. Going into the March carnage we were cyclically underweight the niche homebuilding index. Moreover, last December we had identified homebuilders as a high-conviction underweight in our annual Key Views report. We monetized relative gains of 41% and 43%, respectively from both positions and lifted exposure to a benchmark allocation. While in retrospect we should have upgraded all the way to overweight, we did manage to participate in the V-shaped housing-related returns by opting to go overweight the mega cap home improvement retail index instead. In addition, this summer we eked out another 10% return from a long homebuilders/short REITs pair trade. Homebuilders are enjoying the single family home renaissance as the pandemic has turbo-charged the work from home movement and employees are rushing to move into comfortable spaces in the suburbs as the traditional office is literally declared dead. Indeed, housing starts and permits have renormalized, the drubbing in interest rates has boosted affordability and caused a knee jerk reaction in the mortgage application purchase index, and sell-side analysts are fighting hand-over-fist to upgrade profit projections for the homebuilding group (Chart 7). The end result has been a boom in new home sales that are trouncing existing home sales, and the NAHB’s survey of prospective homebuyers continues to paint a rosy picture for additional demand for new single family homes especially given the low inventory of homes (top & third panels, Chart 8). Chart 7Housing Tailwinds Chart 8Price Concessions Generate Volume This is where all the good news ends. With respect to selling prices, homebuilders are making price concessions compared with existing homes and also in absolute terms new home prices are deflating (second & bottom panels, Chart 8). Therefore, at close to 15%, homebuilding profit margins are near all-time highs and under threat especially from a firming industry wage bill (second & third panels, Chart 9). Tack on surging lumber inflation and a profit margin squeeze is a high probability outcome (bottom panel, Chart 9). As a reminder framing lumber, on average, comprises 15% of a new single family home’s total input costs. While the NAHB survey points to brisk demand for new homes, the sister Conference Board survey shows that consumers’ appetite for a new home has crested (second & third panels, Chart 10). With consumers rushing to move to the suburbs due to the pandemic, there is an element of bringing housing demand forward. Chart 9Beware Margin Squeeze Chart 10Good News Fully Priced Worrisomely, if the economy continues to open up then interest rates should continue to back up. From all the major asset classes the 10-year Treasury yield is the one that has yet to discount a V-shaped economic recovery. The implication is that rising interest rate would dent affordability and at the margin weigh on housing demand (10-year Treasury yield shown inverted, top panel, Chart 10). Moving on to the credit backdrop, while demand for residential real estate loans has recovered, bankers refuse to extend mortgage credit (second & third panels, Chart 11). According to the latest Fed H8 weekly credit release, residential real estate loans are on the verge of contraction (bottom panel, Chart 11). Finally, the tug-of-war on the fiscal package front is also threatening to sustain the unemployment rate near double digits, which could jeopardize the housing recovery. Historically, housing starts have been near perfectly inversely correlated with the unemployment rate and the current message is for a leveling off in residential construction activity (middle panel, Chart 12). The recent homebuilding run has pushed relative valuations from undervalued to overvalued. The relative P/S ratio trades roughly 30% above the historical mean (a three-year high), and leaves no cushion for any mishaps (bottom panel, Chart 12). Chart 11Bankers Refusing To Dole Out Loans Chart 12In Desperate Need Of Fiscal Help Netting it all out, homebuilders are more than fully priced, discounting high margins as far as the eye can see and no end to demand. The specter of higher interest rates, lumber inflation, stealing demand from the future, unfriendly bankers and uncertainty with regard to a fresh stimulus package more than offset the positives, and compel us to issue a downgrade alert for the S&P homebuilding index. Bottom Line: Stay neutral the S&P homebuilders index, but it is now on our downgrade watch list. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5HOME – LEN, PHM, DHI, NVR. A Few Words On Banks Pundits around the globe focus on Eurozone and pan-European banks and argue that these outfits have been value destroyers since the history of the data series in late-1986 (bottom panel, Chart 13). Similarly, US banks relative share prices peaked in the mid-1970s and have never looked back, and very recently have tumbled to fresh all-time lows whether one uses monthly, weekly or daily data (top panel, Chart 13). Meanwhile, the recent drubbing in relative share prices suggests that loan loss provisioning is not over. In fact, Q3 loan loss reserves will surpass the level hit in the GFC, and likely close in on the $300bn mark (provisions shown inverted, Chart 14). Chart 13Banks, The World Over, Are Value Destroyers Chart 14More Loan Losses Loom… Historically, loan loss provisions are the mirror image of bank net operating income and most importantly bank profits decline as provisioning increases (Chart 15). Worrisomely, the longer the new stimulus checks take to arrive, the longer it will take banks to rebound. Banks have been semi-sheltered from the recession courtesy of eviction/foreclosure moratorium as well as mortgage forbearance agreements. Absent a fresh stimulus package, the unemployment rate will remain elevated, warning that lagging non-performing loans will skyrocket (bottom panel, Chart 16). Chart 15…Which Will Weigh On Profits Chart 16Fiscal Policy Easing To The Rescue? Tack on the year-to-date more than halving in the 10-year US Treasury yield and the earnings outlook remains grim for banks (top & middle panels, Chart 17). The transmission mechanism is through net interest margins (NIMs). The fourth panel of Chart 17 highlights that the pair have been joined at the hip and all-time lows in the 10-year US Treasury yield have sank bank NIMs below 3%, which is another all-time low since the history of the FDIC data. Credit growth has crested and our loans and leases model suggests that loan growth will continue to decelerate into 2021 (second panel, Chart 17). Not only is there lack of appetite for new overall loan uptake, but bankers are stringent with extending credit to businesses and consumer alike, according to the most recent Fed Senior Loan Officer survey (Chart 18). Chart 17Credit Growth Blues Chart 18Lack Of Loan Demand And Tightening Credit Supply However, there are three significant offsets to all these stiff headwinds that prevent us from downgrading banks to an underweight stance. First, the 10-year US Treasury yield is one of the few assets that has yet to discount any economic recovery. Thus, as uncertainty lifts post the November election, the economy continues to open up and Congress and the new President manage to pass a fresh fiscal stimulus bill, all this could catalyze a catch up phase in the long bond yield. Second, valuations offer a deep enough discount to absorb a little bit of more negative news as analysts and investors alike have thrown in the towel in banks (bottom panel, Chart 19). Finally, the credible Fed’s stress test loom by year-end and assuming banks pass them with flying colors a resumption of shareholder friendly activities will boost the allure of owing banks and unwind extremely oversold conditions (middle panel, Chart 19). In sum, while the price of credit, loan growth prospects and credit quality all weigh on relative bank performance. A fiscal stimulus bill, depressed valuations and a Fed induced resumption of dividend hikes and share buybacks keep us on the sidelines in the S&P banks index. Chart 19Unloved And Under-owned Bottom Line: Stay neutral the S&P banks index, but keep it on the downgrade watch list. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5BANKX – JPM, BAC, C, WFC, USB, TFC, PNC, FRC, FITB, MTB, KEY, SIVB, RF, CFG, HBAN, ZION, CMA, PBCT. Anastasios Avgeriou US Equity Strategist anastasios@bcaresearch.com Current Recommendations Current Trades Strategic (10-Year) Trade Recommendations Size And Style Views July 27, 2020 Overweight cyclicals over defensives April 28, 2020 Stay neutral large over small caps June 11, 2018 Long the BCA Millennial basket The ticker symbols are: (AAPL, AMZN, UBER, HD, LEN, MSFT, NFLX, SPOT, TSLA, V). January 22, 2018 Favor value over growth
Neutral In mid-April we moved the S&P consumer discretionary sector to the overweight column via upgrading the internet and home improvement retail sub-sectors. While the home improvement retailers hit our stop earlier this month resulting into 15% relative gains, last Friday internet retailers followed suit. We are obeying our previously instituted stop in the S&P internet retail index and crystalizing gains at the 20% relative return mark and downgrade to neutral. This move also pushes the overall S&P consumer discretionary sector to a benchmark allocation, locking in profits of 15% in excess of the broad market over the past five months. Bottom Line: Downgrade the S&P internet retail index to neutral which also pushes our S&P consumer discretionary sector allocation to benchmark for 20% and 15% relative gains, respectively, since the mid-April inception.
Highlights Portfolio Strategy We opt to stay patient and refrain from deploying fresh capital especially in the tech sector in the near-term; a better entry point will likely materialize between now and the end of the year. The softening demand backdrop that is weighing on selling prices, the rekindling of the US/China tech-related trade war and the risk of a reflex rebound in the US dollar, all warn to shy away from semi cap stocks. A balanced outlook keeps us on the sidelines in the S&P home improvement retail (HIR) index. Recent Changes There are no changes to the portfolio this week. Table 1 Feature Equities tried to regain their footing last week, but risks still lingering on the (geo)political front should sustain the tug of war between bulls and bears and rekindle volatility. While monetary and fiscal policies will remain loose, the intensity of easing is waning as both the Fed’s impulse (i.e. second derivative) of asset purchases has ground to a halt and Congress has hit a stalemate over the next round of stimulus. Crudely put, the thrust of monetary and fiscal policies is at heightened risk of shifting from stimulative to contractive (Chart 1). As a result, we remain patient with fresh capital and will wait to deploy it when the dust settles hopefully by the end of the year. Turning to equity market internals and other high frequency financial market data is instructive in order to get a clearer picture of the direction of the broad equity market. The value line arithmetic and geometric indexes and small cap stocks that led the March 23 SPX trough are emitting a distress signal (Chart 2). Chart 1Running Out Of Thrust Chart 2Market Internals... Drilling deeper on a sector basis, hypersensitive chip stocks, energy shares, and discretionary versus staples equities will likely weigh on the prospects of the broad equity market (Chart 3). The VIX index, the vol curve and the yield curve, all excellent leading indicators of the S&P 500, have crested and warn that the shakeout phase has yet to run its course (VIX shown inverted ,Chart 4). Chart 3...Say It Is Prudent... Chart 4...To Remain On The Sidelines Trying to quantify the SPX drawdown, we turn to CBOE’s equity put/call (EPC) ratio. The EPC ratio is nowhere near recent extreme readings. SPX pullbacks since the early-2018 “Volmageddon” have corresponded to significantly higher EPC ratio readings. In the past 10 such iterations, the median EPC ratio has been 0.86, the mean 0.93, with a range of 0.77 to 1.28 (Table 2). Currently, the EPC ratio is hovering near 0.58 suggesting that downside risks persist (EPC ratio shown inverted, Chart 5). Chart 5Downside Risks Persist Table 2Equity Put/Call (EPC) Ratio During Pullbacks Since 2018 Finally, the commodity complex is also firing warnings shots. Lumber has collapsed nearly $300/tbf from the recent peak, oil is trailing gold bullion and silver is also cresting versus the yellow metal, iron ore is petering out and the Baltic dry index is wobbling. True, copper and materials stocks are holding their own, but overwhelmingly commodity market internals are waving a yellow flag (Chart 6). Chart 6Commodity Yellow Flags Netting it all out, we opt to stay patient and refrain from deploying fresh capital especially in the tech space in the near-term; a better entry point will likely materialize between now and the end of the year. This week we reiterate our underweight stance in a niche technology index and shed more light on our recent downgrade to neutral of a key consumer discretionary subgroup. Chip Equipment Update: Tangled Up In The Trade War We remain committed to our intra-tech strategy of preferring defensive software and services tech names to aggressive hardware and equipment tech stocks. In that light, we reiterate our underweight stance in the niche S&P semi equipment index. Recent news of the Trump administration’s potential tightening of the noose on Chinese chip company SMIC (the country’s largest foundry) was a net negative for US semi cap names, similar to export restrictions of American technology to Huawei was a net negative for US semi cap names. As a reminder, these manufacturers count China as one of their largest export market alongside Taiwan and South Korea. Thus, this flare up in the US/Sino trade war bodes ill for semi cap companies’ future sales and profit growth projections (Chart 7). There are high odds that relative share prices have plateaued earlier this month and a fresh down cycle has commenced. Under such a backdrop, this hyper-sensitive manufacturing group will likely overshoot to the down side as is evident in the historical tight correlation with the ISM manufacturing survey: these violent oscillations are warning that a cooling off in the ISM will be severely felt in this niche manufacturing intense index (Chart 8). Chart 7Lofty Expectations Chart 8Violent Oscillations On the global demand front, there is an element that COVID-19 is stealing sales from the future and bringing demand forward. Already global semi sales are rolling over, and a couple of industry pricing power proxies are deflating at an accelerating pace: Asian DRAM prices are topping out in the contraction zone and Taiwanese export prices are sinking like a stone, warning that a deficient demand down cycle will squeeze semi cap profit margins (Chart 9). Importantly, Taiwanese tech capex, which TSMC dominates, has crested, warning that all the euphoria behind 5G deployment and uptake is likely baked in the relative share price ratio. The implication is that semi cap names remain vulnerable to any global 5G-related hiccups (top panel, Chart 10). Chart 9Waning Selling Price Backdrop Chart 10Cresting Finally, the tight positive correlation between Bitcoin prices and the relative share price ratio remains intact. Were a knee-jerk rebound in the US dollar to knock down Bitcoin, at least temporarily, it would serve as a catalyst to shed chip equipment stocks (bottom panel, Chart 10). Moreover, 90% of the industry’s sales originate abroad, thus a rise in the greenback would eat into their P&L via FX translation losses. Adding it all up, a softening demand backdrop that is weighing on selling prices, the rekindling of the US/China tech-related trade war and a reflex rebound in the US dollar, all warn to shy away from semi cap stocks. Bottom Line: Stay underweight the S&P semiconductor equipment index. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG S5SEEQ – AMAT, KLAC, LRCX. Home Improvement Retailers: Stay On The Sidelines Two weeks ago our trailing stop was triggered in the S&P home improvement retail index (HIR) and we monetized gains of 15% since the mid-April inception and moved to the sidelines. Today we reiterate our benchmark allocation in this consumer discretionary sub group. Clearly, HIR was a major beneficiary of the lockdown as the US and Canadian governments deemed these retailers “essential” and allowed them to stay open during the peak of the pandemic. These Big Box retailers saw their sales soar as the fiscal easing package replenished consumers’ wallets, and coupled with the lockdown, caused a surge in DIY remodeling activity. Our portfolio also greatly benefited from the stellar performance of the S&P HIR index, as existing home sales staged a significant comeback and inventories of homes for sale receded substantially thus further tightening the residential real estate market (top & middle panels, Chart 11). As reminder, historically a vibrant housing market is synonymous with handsome returns in relative share prices and vice versa. But now a number of stiff headwinds, which our HIR model encapsulates, signal that a lateral digestive move is in store in the coming months (Chart 12). Chart 11Unsustainable Front Running Chart 12Stiff Headwinds First, a repeat of the spike in demand for home improvement projects is highly unlikely, especially given that demand was brought forward. Also during the autumn and winter months there is a natural slowdown in the take-up of remodeling projects until the spring home selling season arrives. Second, the industry’s sales-to-inventories (S/I) ratio is literally off the charts (bottom panel, Chart 11). An inventory build-up and easing in demand will bring back the S/I ratio back to a more reasonable level. Lastly, lumber prices have taken a beating of late collapsing from over $900/tbf to below $600/tbf. This drubbing of this economically hypersensitive commodity directly cuts into HIR earnings. These Big Box retailers make a set margin on lumber sales so as prices fall they take a big bite out of profits (bottom panel, Chart 13). Nevertheless, a few offsets prevent us from turning outright bearish in this early cyclical retailers. Namely, the industry’s profit growth bar is on a par with the broad market and thus does not pose a large hurdle to overcome. Importantly, given that HIR earnings have kept pace with the massive run-up in stock prices (second panel, Chart 14), they have kept relative valuations at bay. While, the S&P HIR 12-month forward P/E trades at a market multiple, the relative forward P/E changes hands at a 20% discount to the historical mean. Thus, HIR enjoy a significant valuation cushion (bottom panel, Chart 14). Chart 13Timber! Chart 14But There Are Powerful Offsets Finally, the Fed just explicitly committed to stay on the zero interest rate line until 2023! This easy monetary policy as far as the eye can see is a powerful tonic to early cyclical and interest rate-sensitive home improvement retailers (fed funds rate shown inverted, top panel, Chart 14). Netting it all out, a balanced outlook keeps us on the sidelines in the S&P HIR index. Bottom Line: Stick with a benchmark allocation in the S&P home improvement retail index. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG S5HOMI – HD, LOW. Anastasios Avgeriou US Equity Strategist anastasios@bcaresearch.com Current Recommendations Current Trades Strategic (10-Year) Trade Recommendations Size And Style Views July 27, 2020 Overweight cyclicals over defensives April 28, 2020 Stay neutral large over small caps June 11, 2018 Long the BCA Millennial basket The ticker symbols are: (AAPL, AMZN, UBER, HD, LEN, MSFT, NFLX, SPOT, TSLA, V). January 22, 2018 Favor value over growth
Neutral In mid-April we went overweight the S&P home improvement retail (HIR) index on the back of demand-stimulating zero interest rate monetary policy, loose fiscal policy as well as rising lumber prices. As a reminder, HIR companies make a set margin on lumber sales, hence higher lumber prices are a tonic to the industry’s top and bottom lines. However, in mid-June we highlighted weakness in our HIR macro model, a hook down in existing home sales and tick up in inventories. Together, those factors compelled us to institute a stop at the 10% relative return mark, which we subsequently increased further to 15%. Last week our stop was triggered, and we booked 15% in relative gains and moved to the sidelines in home improvement retailers. Bottom Line: Downgrade the S&P HIR index to neutral and book 15% in relative gains since the mid-April inception. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5HOMI – HD, LOW.
Overweight Our S&P home improvement retail overweight continues posting healthy gains: the position is up 23%, in relative terms, since the mid-April inception. Such handsome returns compel us to move our trailing stop from 10% to the 15% relative return mark in order to protect gains. Nevertheless, we still expect to harvest more gains – a view that HD’s earnings release reiterated yesterday. Remote working has created an opportunity for homeowners to undertake remodeling projects that drove extra traffic to home improvement retail stores. Specifically, HD comparable-store sales grew by 25% year-over-year, which translated into a sizable EPS beat. The bottom panel of the chart corroborates that HIR sales are on fire. Bottom Line: We remain overweight the S&P home improvement retail index, but today we move our trailing stop from 10% to 15%. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5HOMI – HD, LOW.