Developed Countries

Foreword Today we are publishing a charts-only report focused on the S&P 500, Cyclicals/Defensives, Growth/Value, and Small/Large. Many of the charts are self-explanatory; to some we have added a short commentary. The charts cover macro, valuations, fundamentals, technicals, and the uses of cash. Our goal is to equip you with all the data you need to make investment decisions along these style dimensions. We also include performance, valuations, and earnings growth expectations tables for all styles, sectors, industry groups, and industries (GICS 1, 2 and 3). We hope you will find this publication useful. We alternate between Style and Sector chart packs updates on a bi-monthly basis. Overarching Investment Themes Macro Is bad news good news again? Investors are caught in crosscurrents of worries and deteriorating economic data. The Citigroup Economic Surprise index is in  negative territory (Chart 1) – yet the US equity market defies gravity. The bad news is good news again, as it gives the Fed cover to keep a loose monetary policy for longer. Tapering: The Fed has broadcast its plans for tapering well in advance, and Fed Chair Jay Powell’s Jackson Hole speech, with its many caveats and uncertain timetable, produced a muted reaction from financial markets. However, investors exhaled with relief, when Powell explicitly separated the decision to taper from the timing of the first rate hike, conditioned on full employment, which is “a long way off”. Covid-19 Delta variant has caught investors off guard: "What does not kill us, mutates and tries again”. While a new wave of infections has dented consumer activity, there are early signs that it is cresting (Chart 2). Delta scare was a key reason for the underperformance of consumer services and cyclical stocks over the summer. Once fears of Delta subside, these groups will bounce back. Chart 1US Economic Data Disappoints Chart 2Delta Infections Are Cresting Supply chain disruptions are still rampant: Shipping costs have soared again in recent months: After falling below 10 this summer, the number of anchored containers ships waiting to offload in the West Coast ports has spiked again to 40, a level last seen in January 2021. Container freight costs have increased nearly five-fold from pre-pandemic levels (Chart 3). There are also significant backlogs of goods (Chart 4), and inventories have been drawn down to all-time low. It will take time for supply chains to normalize, with most industry participants expecting the situation to improve only in 2022. Chart 3Transportation Costs Have Surged Chart 4Supply Chain Bottlenecks Are Not Abating Labor shortages: : Companies are still struggling to fill job openings: There are 10 million job openings to slightly over eight million job seekers (Chart 5). That puts upward pressure on wages and increases companies’ costs. Disappointing jobs report: It is confounding, given strong demand for workers, that August payroll grew only by 235,000 jobs. While this low number may have resulted from the Delta hit to service industries, jobs data is volatile, and revisions are common. Next month's report will be a decisive data point for the Fed’s tapering timing decision. Chart 5Plenty Of Job Openings To Fill Chart 6Inflation Is Broadening Companies continue rising prices: Good news for corporate America is that its pricing power remains high, with 45% of companies planning on passing surging labor and supply costs on to consumers. This leads to a broadening of inflation across categories, with even trimmed means significantly overshooting 2% (Chart 6). While pricing power protects against significant margin compression, former peak margins are elusive. Consumer mood has soured: Consumers are well-aware of rising prices and expect inflation to exceed 6.5% within 12 months - high inflation is becoming embedded into consumer behavior and may become a self-fulfilling prophecy. The consumer confidence reading has slumped to a six-month low of 114 from 125 a month earlier. Many consumers have also postponed durable goods and house purchases discouraged by soaring prices and low inventories (Chart 7). Quality balance sheets outperformed: The wall of worries has resulted in strong balance sheet equities outperforming weak ones. This is also consistent with the classical performance of assets during the slowdown stage of the business cycle (Chart 8). Chart 7Consumer Are Discouraged By Prices And Shortages Of Inventory Chart 8Strong Balance Sheet Companies Outperformed During The Slowdown Valuations and Profitability Q2-2021 earnings season was remarkable both in terms of growth delivered (96% yoy%), and earnings surprise (88%). Earnings have grown at a 14% compound rate since 2019: Chart 9Earnings Growth Is Returning To Trend Now earnings have returned to trend, and we expect normalization of growth. Analysts expect flat QoQ growth for the next three quarters. These are timid expectations; barring a black swan event, earnings growth is likely to surprise on the upside (Chart 9). Earnings growth will provide the necessary impetus for the US equity markets to move higher, with the driver of returns shifting from multiple expansion to earnings growth and cash disbursements to shareholders. Valuations remain elevated with the S&P 500 trading at 21x forward earnings. However, this level of valuations is more of a speed limit for future gains as opposed to a harbinger of a bear market. Sentiment Buy the dip investor mentality prevails. The S&P 500 has not had a 10% correction for nearly a year. This can be explained by FOMO (fear of missing out), and $2 trillion in excess savings in the US: cash that many retail investors aim to park in US equities. Retail flows into domestic equities have been exceptionally strong (Chart 10). Uses of Cash Share buybacks and other shareholder-friendly activities are on the rise again and are expected to gain steam this year and next. S&P 500 buybacks have increased from $120B reported two months ago to nearly $180B – impressive. This is another driver of returns in addition to earnings growth (Chart 11). Chart 10Retail Investors Buy On Dips Chart 11Buybacks Are A Driver Of Returns Investment Implications Low for longer: Fed’s dovish stance, Delta scare, and deteriorating economic growth data suggest that rates are likely to remain “low for longer”, and tapering may be postponed till January 2022. S&P 500: We expect US equities to perform well into the balance of the year on the back of an easy fiscal and monetary policy and steady earnings growth. Growth vs Value: Economic growth continues to slow, the Delta variant is still at the forefront of investor worries, and the Fed is dovish: Interest-rate sensitive stocks, such as Growth and Technology sector will continue outperforming. Cyclicals vs Defensives: We expect consumer cyclicals to start performing again once the onset of Delta dissipates, and more people are willing to travel and eat out. We believe that this is imminent and we are watching Delta stats closely. We also believe that parts of the Industrial sector most exposed to restocking of inventories, infrastructure, and construction will perform strongly. Small vs Large: Small is an “out of the gate” asset class, which tends to surge at the first whiff of recovery. Recently, Small started outperforming on the news that the number of new Delta cases is rolling over. Small is cheap relative to Large, and most of the earnings downgrades are already in the price. We are getting more constructive on this asset class.   Irene Tunkel Chief Strategist, US Equity Strategy irene.tunkel@bcaresearch.com S&P 500 Chart 12Macroeconomic Backdrop Chart 13Profitability Chart 14Valuations And Technicals Chart 15Uses Of Cash Cyclicals Vs Defensives Chart 16Macroeconomic Backdrop Chart 17Profitability Chart 18Valuation And Technicals Chart 19Uses Of Cash Growth Vs Value Chart 20Macroeconomic Backdrop Chart 21Profitability Chart 22Valuations And Technicals   Small Vs Large Chart 23Macroeconomic Backdrop Chart 24Profitability Chart 25Valuations And Technicals Chart 26Uses Of Cash Recommended Allocation . Footnotes  

Highlights A trio of ECB hawks raised the prospect of an ECB taper. In the past, the current set of economic conditions in the Euro Area would have prompted the ECB to tighten policy. A potential economic deceleration this fall, the transitory nature of the Eurozone’s inflation spike, and the level of inflation expectation in the region limit the ECB’s ability to taper this week. We expect a one-off return to the pre-Q2 2021 level of asset purchases couched in a very dovish forward guidance. Peripheral bonds and European corporate bonds will outperform German and other core European paper. Stay long European curve steepeners, while buying US curve flatteners. Overweight German Bunds versus US Treasury Notes, on a USD-hedged basis. European productivity will remain structurally hampered compared to that of the US. US real bond yields will rise relative to Europe. Feature Last week, a chorus of ECB Governing Council members raised the idea among investors that the central bank may soon begin to taper its asset purchases, which prompted Bund yields to hit -0.35% on Wednesday. Robert Holzmann of Austria, Klaas Knot of the Netherlands, and Jens Weidmann of Germany all suggested that monetary conditions were too accommodative for the Eurozone and that the ECB needed to remedy this problem. The complaints of this hawkish trio reflect the current environment. In August, the Eurozone HICP reached a 3% annual rate while the preliminary estimate for core CPI clicked in at 1.6%. Meanwhile, July PPI rose to 12.1%. Such robust inflation readings are at odds with the low level of interest rates in the Eurozone, where the yields on European IG credit and 10-year Italian BTPs average a paltry 0.45% (Chart 1). Beyond the level of inflation, its broad geographic nature is an additional source of concern. Headline CPI is accelerating across all the bloc’s nations, and it stands above 2% in 82% of the members’ states. Historically, this kind of inflationary backdrop resulted in either higher interest rates or some tapering of asset purchases, especially when economic activity was also improving in the Eurozone (Chart 2). Chart 1A Gap For The Hawks Chart 2In The Past, The ECB Would Have Tightened Will the ECB listen to its most hawkish members and follow its past script? We do not believe that the Governing Council is about to start a sustained period of decreased bond buying, even if a return to the pre-Q2 2021 pace of buying is likely this fall. Thus, a dovish taper is the most likely outcome of this week’s meeting. The ECB’s Three Constraints The outlook for growth, the temporary nature of the current spike in European inflation, and the low-level of Euro Area inflation expectations limit the ECB’s ability to remove monetary accommodation. First, European economic growth is at its apex and will decelerate over the next six months. Currently, domestic activity as approximated by the Services PMI stands at near a 15-year high of almost 60. Moreover, despite the spike in COVD-19 cases linked to the Delta variant, mobility remains very robust. If anything, the decline in cases in Spain and France should lead to further improvement in mobility (Chart 3). Nonetheless, the recent fall in consumer confidence and the recent US experience, which the European economy usually follows, point to a deceleration in the Services PMI. The case for a decline in manufacturing activity is more pronounced. The European manufacturing sector responds strongly to the fluctuation of the global industrial sector. US consumer spending on durable goods is 21% above its pre-pandemic trend and is beginning to weaken as pent-up demand for such products has been satiated and households shift their spending back toward services. Moreover, the Chinese credit cycle, which leads the Eurozone Manufacturing PMI by nine months, indicates a greater deceleration in the coming quarters, because European exports to China will slow (Chart 4, top and middle panels). In response to these two forces, Europe will not diverge from the deterioration in our Global Activity Nowcast (Chart 4, bottom panel). Chart 3So Far, No Delta Impact Chart 4The Coming Manufacturing Slowdown Chart 5Abnormal Goods Inflation Second, most evidence still suggests that the current inflation increase will be temporary, despite its violence. To begin with, the spike in inflation remains consigned to the goods sectors, while services inflation stands at 1.1%, in line with the experience of the past 10 years (Chart 5). Even within goods prices, the spike in CPI is limited to sectors facing bottlenecks or linked closely to commodity and shipping prices. As Chart 6 illustrates, the categories experiencing abnormal inflation are directly related to higher energy prices, cars, complex machinery, hotels, and fresh food. Meanwhile, underlying inflation as estimated by our trimmed-mean CPI measure is bottoming, but remains at a very low 0.2% annual rate (Chart 7). Chart 6Inflation Remains A Commodity and Bottleneck Story In the same vein, the surge in Selling Price Expectations of the European Commission Business Survey is a function of commodity inflation (Chart 8). In other words, companies feel they can increase their selling prices, because natural resource prices have spiked. However, inflation across many commodities is currently peaking, which suggests that Selling Price Expectations will soon do so as well. Moreover, this process indicates that headline inflation should hit its summit by year end, because Selling Price Expectations are a coincident indicator of inflation (Chart 8, bottom panel). Chart 7Narrow Inflation Chart 8Rising Selling Prices And Commodities A wage-inflation spiral also remains far away. Historically, rapidly accelerating wage growth marked periods of elevated inflation. Despite current fears, such a development is not taking place in the Eurozone. For the whole bloc, negotiated wages are growing at a modest 1.7% annual rate (Chart 9). Even in Germany, negotiated wages are only increasing at the same rate. While some labor shortages have been reported, total hours worked remain below the equilibrium level based on the Euro Area demographic profile (Chart 9, bottom panel). Furthermore, the past ten years reveal that labor shortages only caused stronger salary growth with a multi-year delay. Third, the market doubts the credibility of the ECB when it comes to achieving a 2% inflation target. So far, survey-based inflation expectations remain below 2% at all tenors (Chart 10, top panel). The same is true of market-based measures, which are still lower than the levels that prevailed before the sovereign debt crisis of the past decade (Chart 10, bottom panel). Chart 9No Wages/Inflation Spiral Chart 10The ECB's Inflation Mandate Is Not Yet Credible Bottom Line: Risks to growth over the winter, the transitory nature of the recent inflation shock, and inflation expectations that remain significantly below target are constraints limitating the ability of the ECB to announce a true tapering of its asset purchases this Thursday. A Dovish Taper? Considering the current set of conditions prevailing in the Eurozone, we expect the ECB to announce a return to the pace of asset purchases that existed prior to Q2 2021. However, the Governing Council (GC) will go out of its way to issue clear forward guidance that strongly indicates this is not the beginning of a taper campaign. Instead, the GC will hint at the transmutation of a large proportion of the PEPP monthly buying into the PSPP after March 2022. The inflation target change enacted at the conclusion of the ECB’s strategy review in July limits the central bank’s ability to go back to its old rule book and tighten policy at the first hint of inflation. First, the ECB must believe that inflation will overshoot 2% on a durable basis, which will necessitate an upgrade to its long-term inflation forecast above the target. Too many members of the GC do not share this view, which makes it unlikely that inflation forecasts will rise this much this week. Moreover, inflation expectations are also too low to warn of a meaningful change in the behavior of European economic agents, especially if the current spike in inflation proves to be transitory. Another problem for the ECB is the Fed. If the ECB were to announce a durable tapering of its asset purchase this week, it would be doing so ahead of the Fed. The GC fears that this action would put considerable upward pressure on EUR/USD, which would create a grave deflationary tendency in the Eurozone (Chart 11). Despite these shackles, the ECB will also acknowledge that the current emergency pace of asset purchases is no longer warranted. Starting Q2 2021, the ECB increased its average monthly purchase from EUR80 billion in the August 2020 to March 2021 period, to EUR95 billion since April 2021 (Chart 12). However, these increased purchases followed a 0.1% GDP contraction in Q1 in the wake of a spike in COVID-19 cases and deaths, which prompted a large reduction in mobility. Moreover, the larger bond buying also followed large increases in bond yields across the main economies of the continent, a rise which, if it had been left unchecked, would have exacerbated the economic malaise. Chart 11The ECB Fears A Strong Euro Chart 12Normalizing Purchases None of these factors are still present. The increasing level of vaccination has dulled the economic impact of the third wave of infection. The economy is expanding robustly and, even if it slows in the months ahead, growth will remain well above trend. Crucially, financial conditions are much more generous than in the first half of the year, with a euro that trades 4% below its January peak and with yields in the bloc’s four largest economies 25 to 45 basis points below their spring peaks. Bottom Line: In response to the aforementioned crosscurrents, we anticipate the ECB to announce a return of its monthly asset purchases to the level that prevailed in the August 2020 to March 2021 period. However, the GC will also clearly indicate, as it did last March, that this policy shift is a one-off, and that investors must not anticipate any further curtailment of asset purchases over the next six months. To reinforce this guidance, we expect the ECB’s inflation forecast to show a return of HICP below 2% by the end of 2023. The GC might also hint at the roll-over of the PEPP program into the PSPP after March 2022. Investment Implications An ECB that conducts a dovish taper on Thursday will support our main fixed-income themes in Europe. First, it will remain a tailwind behind an overweight position in peripheral government bonds versus German bonds. The combination of continued purchases of EUR80 billion a month of bonds over the foreseeable future, above-trend growth, and the fiscal risk mutualization from the NGEU and REACT EU programs means that investors can continue to safely pocket the yield premium offered by BTPs and BONOs. Moreover, our geopolitical strategists expect a left-wing coalition to govern Germany after the September 26 election, which will limit the pressures to tighten budgets in the periphery over the coming years. Chart 13European Corporates Remain Attractive Second, continued liquidity injections by the ECB are also consistent with a preference for European corporate credit over government securities, especially in Germany, France, and the Netherlands. European breakeven spreads for IG and high-yield debts are in the 18th and 13th percentile rank, respectively (Chart 13). Easy monetary conditions and above-trend growth will facilitate further yield-seeking behavior in the Eurozone. This process will allow these securities to offer continued excess returns over at least the next six months. Third, we hold on to our box trade of being long Eurozone curve steepeners and long US curve flatteners. In our base case scenario, the Fed will soon indicate the beginning of its tapering campaign and will be on track to raise rates by early 2023, while the ECB will still conduct a very easy monetary policy. In this context, the US yield curve will flatten relative to the European one, driven by a more rapid increase at the short end of the curve. Chart 14Still Favor Bunds Over T-Notes Finally, in a global bond portfolio, it still makes sense to overweight German Bunds (hedged into USD) relative to US Treasury Notes. Bunds display a significantly lower yield beta than their US counterparts, which creates an attractive defensive feature in an environment in which global yields are likely to rise. Moreover, as the model in Chart 14 highlights, the US/German 10-year yield spread is roughly 50bps below an equilibrium estimate based on relative inflation, unemployment and policy rates, and the size of the Fed and ECB balance sheets. US inflation is likely to remain perkier than that of Europe over the coming quarters, and the US unemployment rate will decline faster as well. Additionally, in the unlikely scenario that the Fed declines to taper its purchases this year, but the ECB does, inflation expectations will rise in the US relative to the Euro Area, which will put upward pressure on yield spreads. Bottom Line: A dovish ECB taper, whereby the GC executes a one-off adjustment in asset purchases with an easy forward guidance, will support our overweight in peripheral government bonds relative to bunds, our preference for European corporate credit relative to government paper, our Europe / US box trade, and BCA’s underweight in Treasurys relative to Bunds. Europe’s Productivity Deficit Is Not Over Compared to the US, GDP growth in the Eurozone has been trending lower since the introduction of the euro in 1999. While a weaker demographic profile has hurt Europe, so has slower productivity growth. Going forward, the gap between European and US productivity growth will somewhat narrow compared to last decade, but it will still favor the US. The cross-Atlantic gap in output per hour growth between has a cyclical and a structural component. The cyclical element is set to ebb. Last decade, the Eurozone suffered a double-dip recession, as the European sovereign debt crisis raged. As a result, capex and debt accumulation in Europe lagged that of the US, which hurt demand and, thus, output-per-hour worked (Chart 15, top panel). Going forward, the European debt crisis has been addressed, the ECB has demonstrated its willingness to do “whatever it takes” to support the monetary union and both the European Commission and the German government have thrown their full weight behind the integrity of Europe, even if it means bailing out their profligate southern neighbors. Despite this positive, some structural headwinds will continue to handicap European productivity. Since 2000, total factor productivity in the major Euro Area economies has lagged that of the US (Chart 15, bottom panel). Many factors suggest this will not change: Chart 15Europe’s Productivity Deficit The Eurozone’s big four economies continue to linger well behind the US in terms of ICT investment, which in recent decades has been a crucial driver of productivity. R&D represents a significantly lower share of GDP in the Eurozone than it does in the US (Chart 16). More investment in intangible assets has been linked to higher productivity growth. Additionally, Ortega-Argilés et al. have shown that EU companies do not convert R&D into productivity gains as well as US businesses do, because they generate lower return on investments.1 Confirming this insight, an empirical study using microdata on R&D spending for EU and US firms highlights that both R&D intensity and productivity are lower for EU firms than for their US counterparts.2 For a 10% increase in R&D intensity, US businesses generated a 2.7% increase in productivity, while EU firms enjoyed a much smaller 1% gain. The gap is larger for high-tech companies, where the same rise in R&D intensity produced a 3.3% productivity gain in the US, but only a 1.2% one in the EU. The European economy remains much more fragmented than that of the US, and the greater prevalence of small firms in the Euro Area results in a less efficient use of the human and capital stocks. Finally, the low rate of investments in recent years has caused the European capital stock to age faster than that of the US. An older pool of assets is further away from the technological frontier and thus weighs on TFP and overall labor productivity (Chart 17). Chart 16Lagging European R&D Chart 17The Ageing European Capital Stock Notwithstanding cyclical fluctuations related to the global debt cycle, the Eurozone profit margins and RoEs will not converge meaningfully toward US levels on a structural basis because of this productivity problem. Europe’s lower industry concentration ratios, lower markups, and greater share of output absorbed by wages will only accentuate this problem. Chart 18TIPS Yields Vs Real Bunds As a result of the lower trend growth rate caused by lower productivity and its inferior return on invested capital, Europe’s R-Star is unlikely to catch up meaningfully to US levels. Consequently, the gap between US and Germany real rates will remain wide and will drive the increase in US yields relative to those of Germany, as the Fed begins to tighten policy while the ECB stands pat (Chart 18). Bottom Line: Europe’s productivity deficit is not the only consequence of last decade’s sovereign debt crisis. Thus, the Euro Area’s potential GDP growth and return on invested capital will lingers behind those of the US. As a corollary, the Eurozone’s R-star is well below that of the US. Hence, we expect higher real rates to drive the increase in US yields over Germany as the Fed tightens policy ahead of the ECB.   Mathieu Savary, Chief European Strategist Mathieu@bcaresearch.com   Footnotes 1R. Ortega-Argilés, M. Piva, and M. Vivarelli, “The Transatlantic Productivity Gap: Is R&D the Main Culprit?,” Canadian Journal of Economics 47.4 (2014), pp. 1342-71. 2D. Castellani, M. Piva, T. Schubert, and M. Vivarelli, “The Productivity Impact of R&D Investment: A Comparison between the EU and the US,” IZA Discussion Papers 9937 (2016). Tactical Recommendations Cyclical Recommendations Structural Recommendations Closed Trades Currency Performance Fixed Income Performance Equity Performance

Highlights Economy – Goldilocks remains our base-case macro backdrop for the next twelve months: The transitory inflation narrative is still intact, despite persistently high consumer price increases, suggesting that the economy will not overheat. The Delta wave has roiled many communities, but COVID is unlikely to spark a growth outage unless a vaccine-resistant variant emerges. Markets – Above-trend growth and extraordinarily accommodative monetary policy is a sweet spot for risk assets: As long as the Fed’s novel policy of adding monetary stimulus to an economy growing way above trend doesn’t give rise to unnervingly high inflation, the combination will be conducive to continued equity and credit outperformance. Strategy – Continue to overweight risk assets within multi-asset portfolios: There’s more to investment returns than the state of the business, credit and monetary policy cycles but they make a powerful case against turning defensive in the near term. Feature We had several virtual meetings with clients in August and inflation, the Fed and the growth outlook were frequently recurring themes. In this week’s report, we share some of the most common questions, along with our take on them, so that all clients can see what we’ve been discussing with their peers. In the interest of space, we confine the discussion to our base-case scenarios, but future outcomes appear to be even more uncertain than they normally are against a backdrop of unprecedented policy settings. We advise investors to remain vigilant and be prepared to hold positions for shorter-than-usual durations in the event circumstances change. Inflation prints remain high, pressuring the Fed’s transitory narrative. What will happen to markets if investors reject it? Chart 1Losing Steam? Inflation prints do remain high, with headline CPI rising 0.5% month-over-month and 5.3% year-over-year in July and core CPI rising 0.3% and 4.2%. Both series modestly exceeded expectations, though they recorded their smallest sequential gains since February and their year-over-year increases came in just below the peaks recorded in June (Chart 1). It is possible that consumer price increases have begun to decelerate though it will take more data to confirm the existence of a new trend. Reports of continued bottlenecks driven by component shortages, transport challenges and the Delta infection wave suggest that even if the factors that have pushed inflation higher are beginning to abate, they may linger in some form for longer than initially expected. The transitory narrative remains intact, however. Drilling into the components of the elevated core CPI reveals that a handful of categories that have been particularly impacted by the pandemic are exerting outsized influence over the index. When we published the initial version of Table 1 in late May, nine categories powered April’s reported core inflation. This time there are eight, as the five shaded components have come off the boil and the four components shown in an indented font have newly begun to run hot. Table 1Temporary Irritants Excepting historically volatile recreational services and water, sewer and trash services, which have been increasing in price far faster than other goods and services for a while, the hot categories’ moves have been extreme relative to their own history. Unless their spaces have undergone lasting structural changes, we expect their two-plus standard deviation moves will not be sustained. The biggest outliers, lodging and new vehicles, can be explained entirely by the pandemic and once hotels are able to return to full capacity and an end to the semiconductor shortage allows automakers to resume normal production levels, they will come back to earth. The turnover among the outliers supports the transitory narrative, as price spikes in categories that have long lagged the overall basket, like airfares and used cars, or have experienced long deflationary skids, like furniture and bedding, appear to have been fleeting. Chart 2Back To The Early Nineties Markets would experience considerable disruption if investors became convinced that elevated inflation readings were not transitory. Bond yields would rise sharply; the dollar would weaken, stoking further price increases; and the technology sector would come under pressure, threatening the S&P 500. Worst of all, the Fed would be forced to begin hiking the fed funds rate sooner than expected, on its way to setting it at a higher terminal level than expected, sending rates higher across all maturities and weighing on equities generally. The sizable potential market impacts have us monitoring inflation closely, even if the inflation debate won’t likely be resolved until we have several more monthly data points. So you’re watching inflation closely, but you’re not all that worried about it? That’s the gist of it, yes. We’re watchful but not worried. Part of the reason that respective year-over-year core and headline CPI prints over 4% and 5% give everyone such a start is that inflation hasn’t been so high since the beginning of the nineties (Chart 2). But the structural factors that have helped keep inflation in check for decades didn’t suddenly disappear when the pandemic arrived. While BCA’s house view holds that investors are complacent about inflation’s longer-run trajectory, we expect that it will take a few years for prices to move sustainably higher. Table 2Inflation Checklist We developed our inflation checklist to keep tabs on when inflation is poised to rise enough to impact monetary policy and provoke a market inflection. We check the same three boxes that we have in our previous reviews: Labor demand is still red-hot, year-over-year changes in marquee inflation indexes are still well above the Fed’s target and BCA’s pipeline inflation indicator remains very elevated (Table 2). Wages have not yet broken out in response to the worker shortage, however (Chart 3), and it is as if idle workers are abstaining from working rather than using their leverage to command higher wages. The more refined trimmed-mean measures of the CPI and the PCE Index remain relatively well behaved (Chart 4). Chart 3Wages Have Risen, But They Haven't Broken Out Yet     Chart 4More Refined Inflation Measures Continue To Lag Their Marquee Peers Even if our pipeline inflation indicator has crested, it remains at an extremely high level consistent with above-target consumer price gains (Chart 5). As measured by the DXY Index, the dollar has twice bounced convincingly off support at 90 this year, helping to keep imports from adding fuel to the fire. Core consumer prices in the Eurozone and China are only rising a little more than 1% annually in any event, so the two largest economies outside the US are not yet exporting inflation stateside (Chart 6). Chart 5Inflation Pressures May Finally Be Easing Chart 6Eurozone Prices Are Rising, But They're Not Yet Elevated If we had to pick just one indicator to determine whether inflation will become problematic, it would be the shape of the inflation expectations curve. High inflation becomes self-sustaining when economic actors – workers, businesses, consumers and lenders – begin to expect it will persist into the future and change their behavior to align with their expectations. When inflation is expected to be high over the long term, individual workers or their unions insist on higher wages to maintain purchasing power, businesses at all points of the supply chain demand higher prices to protect their margins, consumers accelerate their big-ticket purchase decisions to get the most bang for their buck and lenders require higher nominal pro forma returns. The resulting feedback loops help inflation become entrenched in the same way that expectations of falling prices have paved the way for a deflationary mindset to grip Japan. As long as investors (Table 3) and households (Chart 7) expect inflation to decelerate from the short term to the intermediate term, and again from the intermediate term to the long term, the inflation genie has not gotten out of the bottle. Table 3Investors' Inflation Expectations Curve Is Inverted, ... Chart 7... And So Is Consumers' Where do you get the idea that upward S&P 500 earnings revisions are in store? Analysts are already penciling in double-digit year-over-year gains over the next four quarters and growth is plainly decelerating. In our view, the dislocations imposed by COVID-19 across all of 2020 distorts year-over-year earnings comparisons so much that they are of little use. To sidestep that distortion, we have been calculating expected growth by comparing forward four-quarter earnings projections to the annualized run rate of the last reported quarter. As an example, at the beginning of the second quarter earnings season in July, we multiplied the first quarter’s $49.13 EPS by four to get $196.52 and then compared it to the $193.25 sum of expectations for 2Q21 through 1Q22, discovering that analysts were calling for a nearly 2% decline in S&P earnings based on 1Q21's run rate. We also observed that the 2Q21 projection of $45.21 indicated that analysts expected an 8% quarter-over-quarter decline (Table 4). Table 4Expectations At The Start Of The 2Q Earnings Season Were Too Low Looking through modest seasonal effects, S&P 500 EPS tend to grow from quarter to quarter during expansions. An 8% quarter-on-quarter contraction would have been very surprising when nominal GDP, a sound proxy for S&P 500 revenue growth, was projected to grow by at least 2.25% (7% real annual growth plus 2% inflation). Assuming S&P 500 earnings could match GDP growth, we figured that 2Q index EPS would be at least $50, 2% above 1Q and 10% above analyst estimates. With nearly all constituents having reported at press time, it looks like they will settle at $52.74. Chart 8Predicted Declines In Forward Four-Quarter S&P 500 Earnings Are Rare Table 5S&P 500 Earnings BCA does not make point estimates, but a sequential perspective yielded a useful insight that pandemic-distorted year-over-year analysis missed: consensus 2Q earnings estimates were glaringly low when compared to actual 1Q results and the next three quarters’ estimates looked like they had room to rise as well. As Chart 8 shows, forward four-quarter earnings are rarely projected to fall below the most recent quarter’s annualized run rate. With quarterly earnings not projected to exceed 2Q21 until 2Q22 (Table 5), the expectations bar appears to be set low for the next four quarters, especially given 2H21 real annualized GDP growth expectations of around 6% (9% nominal, if inflation declines to no less than 3%) and 1H22 real GDP growth expectations of 3 to 3.5% (5.5 to 6% nominal, if inflation declines to no less than 2.5%). ​​​​​​​The bottom line is that earnings estimates are quite modest from a sequential perspective when viewed against S&P 500 earnings’ tendency to rise during expansions. While we expect that earnings growth will decelerate, we do not foresee that it will spite history and contract, especially given the extraordinarily accommodative monetary and fiscal policy backdrop. Investment Implications As the foregoing discussion suggests, we remain comfortable with our base-case scenario that the Goldilocks strong-growth/accommodative policy backdrop will remain in place and support risk assets over the next twelve months. Neither the too-hot right-hand tail, in which monetary policy is projected to turn restrictive soon enough to weigh on twelve-month returns, or the too-cold left-hand tail, in which growth disappoints despite copious accommodation, looks particularly likely. But as we keep highlighting in discussions with clients, we are mindful that our conviction levels are necessarily lower than usual given the unprecedented backdrop. We are bullish, but vigilantly so, and we urge investors not to let their guard down. We take heart from what we view as a powerful bias for the Fed to err on the side of providing too much accommodation. It was nothing new when Chair Powell explicitly drew a distinction between tapering asset purchases and hiking the fed funds rate in his Jackson Hole speech a week and a half ago, but it was nonetheless comforting for an investor in risk assets to have the Fed reiterate its dovish default position. A zero fed funds rate is conducive to corporate earnings growth and risk asset outperformance and it will help hold off the start date of the next recession. So too will the lagged effects of massive fiscal transfers that bolster households’ ability to consume. The path of least resistance is for risk assets to continue generating excess returns.   Doug Peta, CFA Chief US Investment Strategist dougp@bcaresearch.com

Highlights A lot of pessimism is embedded in the Aussie dollar, making it a potent candidate for a powerful mean-reversion rally. The key catalyst will be a reversal in COVID-19 infection rates which are holding the Aussie economy hostage. Marginally, there is good news on that front. On a terms-of-trade basis, the Australian dollar is very cheap. Falling commodity prices are a handicap, but the valuation margin of safety makes the AUD a safer bet on a reflationary theme. At the crosses, we are already long AUD/NZD, but AUD/JPY and AUD/CHF should be winners in the next six-to-nine months. Feature The Australian economy was on a strong recovery path before a resurgence in Covid-19 infections handicapped this improvement. Australian GDP recovered to pre-pandemic levels in Q1 and the latest Q2 release suggests the Australian economy was on the path to achieve escape velocity (Chart I-1). Chart I-1The Aussie Economy Has Recovered The bounce in the Australian dollar has mirrored the improvement in the economy. From a low of 55 cents in early 2020, the Aussie rose over 40% to a high of 80 cents in earlier this year. However, more recently, there has been a strong correction in the AUD, reflecting both domestic and global concerns about growth. The key question for investors is whether the decline in the Aussie represents an excessive move or heralds a more malignant outcome for the currency. In our view, if risk sentiment stays ebullient, then the Australian dollar will be a potent candidate for a coiled-spring rebound. However, on the downside, there has already been a lot of bad news priced into the Aussie, making the reward/risk picture more favorable (Chart I-2). The Delta Variant The Delta variant of Covid-19 is ravaging across most countries, and the Australian economy has been particularly susceptible. While in absolute terms, Australia’s infection rates are faring better than most developed markets, the momentum of the latest wave has knocked down a nascent boom in Aussie economic conditions (Chart I-3). Chart I-2The Aussie And Global Stocks Have Diverged Chart I-3The Delta Variant Is Ravaging Australia   Sydney is now entering its third month of lockdown, and the state of Victoria has just extended mobility restrictions for another three weeks. However, the population is getting vaccinated quickly, with almost 40% having received two jabs. Should the current trajectory of vaccinations continue, Australia could fully lift restrictions on its citizens by the fourth quarter. It is noteworthy that Australia has been here before, and during the last two waves in March and August of last year, the country was able to weather the storm with lower vaccination rates. As such, the latest wave should prove transient, allowing economic conditions to normalize after a weak Q3. AUD And The Global Cycle As a premier commodity producer, the Australian economy is intricately linked to the global economic cycle, especially what happens in China. Chart I-4 shows that both the Caixin and National Bureau of Statistics manufacturing PMIs in China lead Australian manufacturing activity. With the majority of Australian exports going to China, it makes the Aussie economy very sensitive to Chinese domestic conditions. Our China Investment Strategy colleagues believe that fiscal policy will be eased going forward, while the tightening in monetary conditions is past its peak, especially in the face of Covid-19 and floods ravaging China. Chinese bond yields have already dropped, reflecting an easing in domestic financial conditions. With the Chinese bond market becoming more and more liberalized, it is becoming a good proxy for monetary conditions in China. As such, the trend in bond yields has tended to lead Chinese imports. This suggests that Aussie exports should remain robust in the coming months (Chart I-5). Chart I-4How Long Will The China Slowdown Last? Chart I-5Easing Financial Conditions In China Chart I-6Chinese Policy And The AUD A similar pattern to March of last year might be repeated this year, should Covid-19 fears remain persistent. China led the pack vis-à-vis other countries by injecting stimulus much earlier on, which helped ease domestic financial conditions. As a result, imports of key raw materials such as copper, iron ore, steel, and crude oil rose higher, helping Australian export volumes. This time around, excess money supply in China is rebounding from extremely depressed levels. While the near-term trajectory suggests some more volatility for the Aussie, the cyclical outlook is improving (Chart I-6). A Terms-Of-Trade Boom Despite a slowing Chinese economy, commodity prices remain resilient. Australian terms-of-trade have outperformed that of other commodity-producing nations (Chart I-7). Australia is relatively competitive in supplying the types of raw materials that China needs and wants. For example, Australian exporters produce higher-grade ore, which is more expensive, pollutes less, and is in high demand in China. Similarly, Australia is a big exporter of liquefied natural gas, whose prices have been soaring in recent months. Going forward, Australia’s terms-of-trade improvement is likely to continue. China’s clear energy policy shift away from coal and towards natural gas will buffet LNG export volumes. Also, given that reducing, if not outright eliminating, pollution is a long-term strategic goal in China, this will provide a multi-year tailwind for both cleaner ore and gas exports. The pattern of an improving terms-of-trade picture but deteriorating domestic fundamentals has placed the AUD in a tug-of-war scenario. One of the key primary drivers of the AUD exchange rate has been the basic balance, the sum of the current account and long-term capital flows. The basic balance is making secular highs, suggesting the AUD should be above its 2011 peak near 1.10 (Chart I-8). This suggests that room for mean reversion is substantive. Chart I-7A Boom In Aussie Terms Of Trade Chart I-8The AUD Has Lagged Terms Of Trade   In a nutshell, Australia sports the best improvement in both trade and current account balances in the G10 over the last few years (Chart I-9). Investment in projects in the resource space are now bearing fruit, easing the external funding requirement. This has ended the 35-year-long deficit in the current account. A rising current account naturally increases the demand for the Australian dollar, which buffets the currency. Domestic Considerations And The RBA By most accounts, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has achieved its objectives. Most measures of inflation are near target, unemployment is close to NAIRU, and wages have bottomed and are marginally inflecting higher (Chart I-10). The next batch of numbers coming out of Australia will likely be weak, as the RBA will outline next week, but any weakness in the Aussie will represent a buying opportunity. Chart I-9A Record Surplus In Australias Basic Balance Chart I-10Fundamentals In The Aussie Economy Are On The Mend   Taking a step back, the recovery in the Australian jobs market has been spectacular. Unemployment is at 4.6%, very close to NAIRU. Meanwhile, the participation rate has recovered to pre-pandemic levels as pandemic-aid schemes wear off. The Liberal-National coalition government was very proactive, especially with the “Job Seeker” and “Job Keeper” schemes, providing a valuable cushion for domestic economic conditions. With a very low government debt burden, there is obviously scope to expand the scheme further should conditions dictate. House prices are rebounding in a trajectory the RBA likes to see, driven by credit from owner-occupied housing (Chart I-11). This suggests that at least at the margin, house prices are being driven by domestic demand/supply fundamentals. The key takeaway is that relative to its commodity-currency peers, Australia is well along its house-price adjustment path, having been one of the first developed market countries to introduce macroprudential measures. This suggests that beyond the very near term, emergency policy settings are no longer appropriate for the Aussie economy. The RBA is likely to taper asset purchases from $A5 billion a week, to $A4 billion as telegraphed (Chart I-12), but there is scope for a hawkish surprise at next week’s meeting. Markets are already discounting an increasing path for interest rates starting next year, but not so relative to the US. This could change as the RBA responds to improving economic conditions. Chart I-11A Sustainable Increase In House Prices Chart I-12The RBA Could Unexpectedly Change Policy Settings   Meanwhile, real rates are already more attractive in Australia compared to the US, especially at the short end of the curve. A Valuation Cushion The cherry on the cake for the Aussie is that it is cheap according to most of our valuation measures. As we highlighted in a recent report, trading the Aussie on a valuation basis alone has added significant alpha over the last several years. One of our favorite metrics for the Australian dollar’s fair value is its real effective exchange rate relative to its terms of trade. On this basis, the Aussie dollar is cheap by about 20% (Chart I-13). Our intermediate-term timing models, published a fortnight ago, shows the Australian dollar as 9% cheap, or near one standard deviation below the mean. Our purchasing power parity (PPP) models point to a slight undervaluation in the Australian dollar. It also helps that speculators are very short the Aussie, which is bullish from a contrarian perspective (Chart I-14). Chart I-13The AUD Is Cheap Chart I-14Investors Are Short The AUD   How Should Investors Position Themselves? AUD/USD will close its undervaluation gap in the medium-to-long term, as happens with most currencies. This will lift the AUD towards 85 cents. In the short term, long AUD/NZD and long AUD/JPY remain attractive bets for those not willing to take directional dollar bets. In our portfolio, we are already long AUD/NZD for the following reasons: The markets have already priced in a very hawkish RBNZ and a very dovish RBA (Chart I-15). Our bias is that as Covid-19 proves to be a global problem, there will be a renormalization in interest rate expectations. Terms of trade in Australia will continue to outperform that of New Zealand. AUD/NZD and relative terms of trade tend to move together (Chart I-16). Chart I-15AUD/NZD Remains A Buy Chart I-16Terms Of Trade And AUD/NZD   AUD/NZD is very cheap on a historical basis. This level of valuation has provided strong support in the past (Chart I-17). Meanwhile, the Australian yield curve has steepened, albeit with some recent flattening, but banks have still underperformed the improvement in the interest rate term structure (Chart I-18). A bottoming economy will benefit banks, which make up almost 35% of the Australian MSCI index, and thus there could be renewed foreign inflows. Chart I-17AUD/NZD Is Cheap Chart I-18Stay Long Aussie Banks   Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Data out of the US this week was mixed: The payrolls report was well below expectations. Non-farm payrolls came in at 235K, versus an expected increase of 733K. Both the labor force participation rate and average hourly earnings remained steady at 61.7% and 4.3% year-on-year, respectively. The ISM report was robust for August. The manufacturing PMI improved from 59.5 to 59.9. New orders rose from 64.9 to 66.7 The PCE deflator came it at 3.6% year-on-year, in line with estimates. The US dollar DXY index fell this week. The weak payrolls report reiterates the fact that risks from tighter monetary policy in the US are overstated. This was the conclusion from the Jackson Hole meeting last week, that saw a drop in both the US dollar and bond yields. Report Links: Arbitrating Between Dollar Bulls And Bears - March 19, 2021 The Dollar Bull Case Will Soon Fade - March 5, 2021 Are Rising Bond Yields Bullish For The Dollar? - February 19, 2021 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Euro area data remains robust: Core CPI came in at 1.6% year-on-year in August. Headline CPI was a more robust 3%. The final read from the Markit manufacturing PMI remained at a robust 61.4 in August. The services PMI did decline from 59.5 to 59. Retail sales increased by a robust 3.1% in July. The euro rose by almost 1% this week. Covid-19 cases seem to be rolling over in Europe while firing in other nations. This will increase support for the euro, as well as expectations the ECB could dial back monetary accommodation. Report Links: Relative Growth, The Euro, And The Loonie - April 16, 2021 The Euro Dance: One Step Back, Two Steps Forward - April 2, 2021 On Japanese Inflation And The Yen - January 29, 2021 The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Recent Japanese data has been on the strong side: Retail sales rose 2.4% year-on-year in July. The employment report was strong. The unemployment rate fell to 2.85 and the job-to-applicant ratio rose from 1.13 to 1.15. Housing starts rose 10% year-on-year in July. Capital spending for Q2 was 5.3% year-on-year, well above expectations. The yen was flat against the dollar this week. In an environment where global risk is ebullient, the yen tends to underperform other pro-cyclical currencies. This was very evident this week. Report Links: The Case For Japan - June 11, 2021 The Dollar Bull Case Will Soon Fade - March 5, 2021 On Japanese Inflation And The Yen - January 29, 2021 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Data out of the UK this week was encouraging: The Lloyds business barometer improved from 30 to 36. Nationwide home prices rose 11% year-on-year in August. The Markit services PMI was steady at 55 in August. The pound rose by 0.6% this week. UK will continue to benefit from higher vaccination rates, compared to the rest of the G10. That said, other pro-cyclical currencies, such as the AUD, could benefit from a robust vaccination campaign, outperforming GBP. Report Links: Why Are UK Interest Rates Still So Low? - March 10, 2021 Portfolio And Model Review - February 5, 2021 Thoughts On The British Pound - December 18, 2020 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Australian data is slated to slow, but the recent numbers have been encouraging: Private sector credit rose 4% year-on-year in August. Q2 GDP was a robust 9.6% year-on-year. Exports rose 5% month-on-month in July. The AUD was the best-performing currency this week, rising almost 2%. We discuss the AUD at length in this week’s front section. Our bias is that the AUD will benefit from easing monetary policy in China and high commodity prices. Report Links: The Dollar Bull Case Will Soon Fade - March 5, 2021 Portfolio And Model Review - February 5, 2021 Australia: Regime Change For Bond Yields & The Currency? - January 20, 2021 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 The was scant data out of New Zealand this week: Building permits rose 2.1% month-on-month in July. CoreLogic house prices are inflecting 27% year-on-year in August. ANZ Business confidence slipped from -3.8 to -14.2 in August. The NZD was up almost 2% this week. We like the NZD cyclically, but our bias is that hawkish expectations from the RBNZ could be watered down, which could make the kiwi lag other commodity currencies like the Aussie. Report Links: How High Can The Kiwi Rise? - April 30, 2021 Portfolio And Model Review - February 5, 2021 Currencies And The Value-Versus-Growth Debate - July 10, 2020 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Data out of Canada this week has been weak: Q2 GDP missed expectations, falling 1.1% versus an expected increase of 2.5%. The Markit manufacturing PMI increased from 56.2 to 57.2 in August. Net trade deteriorated in July, but Canada is still booking a C$0.8bn surplus. The CAD rose by 0.7% this week. The backdrop for the loonie is positive as the Bank of Canada continues to taper asset purchases and remains on a path to increase interest rates. The upcoming election could also usher in more fiscal stimulus for Canada. Report Links: Relative Growth, The Euro, And The Loonie - April 16, 2021 Will The Canadian Recovery Lead Or Lag The Global Cycle? - February 12, 2021 The Outlook For The Canadian Dollar - October 9, 2020 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 The data out of Switzerland this week was weak: The KOF indicator declined from 129.8 to 113.5 in August. This was well below expectations. CPI in August was slightly above expectations at 0.4% year-on-year for the core and 0.9% for headline. GDP for Q2 was in line with expectations, at 1.8% quarter-on-quarter. The Swiss franc was flat this week. The franc will continue to benefit from rolling bouts of volatility, but at the margin, it will lag the bounce in other currencies as global risk sentiment stays ebullient. Report Links: An Update On The Swiss Franc - April 9, 2021 Portfolio And Model Review - February 5, 2021 The Dollar Conundrum And Protection - November 6, 2020 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Data out of Norway this week was positive: Credit growth improved 5.3% year-on-year in July The current account balance was a healthy NOK 93.2bn in June. The unemployment rate fell from 3.1% to 2.7%. The NOK was up around 1% this week. We are long Scandinavian currencies on a bet that the dollar will fall cyclically. Meanwhile, the Norges Bank has signaled they will increase interest rates ahead of both the Federal Reserve and the ECB. This will benefit real rates in Norway. Report Links: The Norwegian Method - June 4, 2021 Portfolio And Model Review - February 5, 2021 Revisiting Our High-Conviction Trades - September 11, 2020 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Recent data from Sweden have been improving: The Swedbank manufacturing and services PMI remained robust in August at 60.1 and 64.7 respectively. The August current account balance showed a healthy surplus of SEK 80.3 billion. The economic tendency survey for August came in at 121.1 from 119.8. Consumer confidence rose from 106.5 to 108.6 in August. The SEK was up almost 1% this week. There are many signs the Swedish economy is improving. This is paring back expectations of more stimulus from the Riksbank. We are short both EUR/SEK and USD/SEK as reflation plays. Report Links: Revisiting Our High-Conviction Trades - September 11, 2020 More On Competitive Devaluations, The CAD And The SEK - May 1, 2020 Sweden Beyond The Pandemic: Poised To Re-leverage - March 19, 2020 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Limit Orders Closed Trades Footnotes