Copper
COMEX copper peaked at $4.30/lb on February 24, up a remarkable 103% since its late-March 2020 lows. Since then it has traded mostly sideways, but recently perked up and is nearing its February top. Our Commodity & Energy strategists’ most recent…
Highlights Continued upgrades to global economic growth – most recently by the IMF this week –will support higher natgas prices. In our estimation, gas for delivery at Henry Hub, LA, in the coming withdrawal season (November – March) is undervalued at current levels at ~ $2.90/MMBtu. Inventory demand will remain strong during the current April-October injection season, following the blast of colder-than-normal weather in 1Q21 that pulled inventories lower in the US, Europe and Northeast Asia. The odds the US will succeed in halting completion of the final leg of the Russian Nord Stream 2 natural gas pipeline into Germany are higher than the consensus expectation. Our odds the pipeline will not be completed this year stand at 50%, which translates into higher upside risk for natural gas prices. We are getting long 1Q22 calls on CME/NYMEX Henry Hub-delivered natgas futures struck at $3.50/MMBtu vs. short 1Q22 $3.75/MMBtu calls at tonight's close. The probability of Nord Stream 2 cancellation is underpriced, which means European TTF and Asian JKM prices will have to move higher to attract LNG cargoes next winter from the US, if the pipeline is cancelled (Chart of the Week). Feature As major forecasting agencies continue to upgrade global growth prospects, expectations for industrial-commodity demand – energy, bulks, and base metals – also are moving higher. This week, the IMF raised its growth expectations for this year and next to 6% and 4.4%, respectively, nearly a full percentage-point increase versus its January forecast update for 2021.1 This upgrade follows a similar move by the OECD last month.2 In the US, the EIA is expecting industrial demand for natural gas to rise 1.35 Bcf/d this year to 23.9 Bcf/d; versus 2019 levels, industrial demand will be 0.84 Bcf/d higher in 2021. For 2022, industrial demand is expected to be 24.2 Bcf/d. US industrial demand likely will recover faster than the EU's, given the expectation of a stronger recovery on the back of massive fiscal and monetary stimulus. Overall natgas demand in the US likely will move lower this year, given higher natgas prices expected this year and next will incentivize electricity generators to switch to coal at the margin, according to the EIA. Total demand is expected to be 82.9 Bcf/d in the US this year vs. 83.3 Bcf/d last year, owing to lower generator demand. Pipeline-quality gas output in the US – known as dry gas, since its liquids have been removed for other uses – is expected to average 91.4 Bcf/d this year, essentially unchanged. Lower consumption by the generators and flat production will allow US gas inventories to return to their five-year average levels of 3.7 Tcf by the end of October, in the EIA's estimation (Chart 2). Chart of the WeekUS-Russia Geopolitical Risk Underpriced Chart 2US Natgas Inventories Return To Five-Year Average US Liquified Natural Gas (LNG) exports are likely to expand, as Asian and European demand grows (Chart 3). Prior to the boost in US LNG demand from colder weather, exports set monthly records of 9.4 Bcf/d and 9.8 Bcf/d in November and December of last year, respectively, with Asia accounting for the largest share of exports (Chart 4). This also marked the first time LNG exports exceeded US pipeline exports to Mexico and Canada. The EIA is forecasting US LNG exports will be 8.5 bcf/d and 9.2 Bcf/d this year and next, versus pipeline exports of 8.8 Bcf/d and 8.9 Bcf/d in 2021 and 2022, respectively. Chart 3US LNG Exports Continue Growing Chart 4US LNG Exports Set Records In November And December 2020 US LNG exports – and export potential given the size of the resource base at just over 500 Tcf – now are of a sufficient magnitude to be a formidable force in global markets, particularly in Europe. This puts it in direct conflict with Russia, which has targeted Europe as a key market for its pipeline natural gas exports. US-Russia Standoff Looming Over Nord Stream 2 Given the size and distribution of global oil and gas production and consumption, it comes as no surprise national interests can, at times, become as important to pricing these commodities as supply-demand fundamentals. This is particularly true in oil, and increasingly is becoming the case in natural gas. That the same dramatis personae – the US and Russia – should feature in geopolitical contests in oil and gas markets also should not come as a surprise. In an attempt to circumvent transporting its natural gas through Ukraine, Russia is building a 1,230 km underwater pipeline from Narva Bay in the Kingisepp district of the Leningrad region of Russia to Lubmin, near Greifswald, in Germany (Map 1). The Biden administration, like the Trump administration and US Congress, is officially attempting to halt the final leg of the pipeline from being built, although Biden has not yet put America’s full weight into stopping it. Biden claims it will be up to the Europeans to decide what to do. At the same time, any major Russian or Russian-backed military operation in Ukraine could trigger an American action to halt the pipeline in retaliation. Map 1Nord Stream 2 Route In our estimation, there is a 50% chance that the Nord Stream 2 natural gas pipeline will not be completed this year or go into operation as planned given substantial geopolitical risks. The $11 billion pipeline would connect Russia directly to Germany with a capacity of about 55 billion cubic meters, which, combined with the existing Nord Stream One pipeline, would equal 110 BCM in offshore capacity, or 55% of Russia's natural gas exports to Europe in 2019. The pipeline’s construction is 94% complete, with the Russian ship Akademik Cherskiy entering Danish waters in late March to begin laying pipes to finish the final 138-kilometer stretch, according to Reuters. The pipeline could be finished in early August at the pace of 1 kilometer per day.3 The Russian and German governments are speeding up the project to finish it before US-Russia tensions, or the German elections in September, interrupt the construction process again. It is not too late for the US to try to halt the pipeline through sanctions. But for the Americans to succeed, the Biden administration would have to make an aggressive effort. Notably the Biden administration took office with a desire to sharpen US policy toward Russia.4 While Biden seeks Russian engagement on arms reduction treaties and the Iranian nuclear negotiations, he mainly aims to counter Russia, expand sanctions, provide weapons to Ukraine, and promote democracy in Russia’s sphere of influence. The result will almost inevitably be a new US-Russia confrontation, which is already taking shape over Russia’s buildup of troops on the border with Ukraine, where US and Russian meddling could cause civil war to reignite (Map 2). Map 2Russia’s Military Tensions With The West Escalate In Wake Of Biden’s Election And Ukraine’s Renewed Bid To Join NATO Tensions in Ukraine are directly tied to US military cooperation with Ukraine and any possibility that Ukraine will join the NATO military alliance, a red line for Putin. Nord Stream 2 is Russia’s way of bypassing Ukraine but a new US-Russia conflict, especially a Russian attack on Ukraine, would halt the pipeline. The pipeline’s completion would improve Russo-German strategic relations, undercut US liquefied natural gas exports to Germany and the EU, and reduce the US’s and eastern Europe’s leverage over Russia (and Germany). Biden says his administration is planning to impose new sanctions on firms that oversee, construct, or insure the pipeline, and such sanctions are required under American law.5 Yet Biden also wants a strong alliance with Germany, which favors the pipeline and does not want to escalate the conflict with Russia. The American laws against Nord Stream have big loopholes and give the president discretion regarding the use of sanctions, which means Biden would have to make a deliberate decision to override Germany and impose maximum sanctions if he truly wanted to halt construction.6 This would most likely occur if Russia committed a major new act of aggression in Ukraine or against other European democracies. The German policy, under the current ruling coalition led by Chancellor Angela Merkel’s Christian Democratic Union, is to finish the pipeline despite Russia’s conflicts with the West and political repression at home. Russia provides more than a third of Germany’s natural gas imports and this pipeline would bypass eastern Europe’s pipeline network and thus secure Germany’s (and Austria’s and the EU’s) natural gas supply whenever Russia cuts off the flow to Ukraine (through which roughly 40% of Russian natural gas still must pass to reach Europe). Germany's Election And Natgas Politics Germany wants to use natural gas as a bridge while it phases out nuclear energy and coal. Natural gas has grown 2.2 percentage points as a share of Germany’s total energy mix since the Fukushima disaster of 2011, and renewable energy has grown 7.7ppt, while coal has fallen 7.3ppt and nuclear has fallen 2.5ppt (Chart 5). The German federal election on September 26 complicates matters because Merkel and the Christian Democrats are likely to underperform their opinion polls and could even fall from power. They do not want to suffer a major foreign policy humiliation at the hands of the Americans or a strategic crisis with Russia right before the election. They will insist that Biden leave the pipeline alone and will offer other forms of cooperation against Russia in compensation. Therefore, the current German government could push through the pipeline and complete the project even in the face of US objections. But this outcome is not guaranteed. The German Greens are likely to gain influence in the Bundestag after the elections and could even lead the German government for the first time – and they are opposed to a new fossil fuel pipeline that increases Russia’s influence. Chart 5Germany Sees Nord Stream 2 Gas As Bridge To Low-Carbon Economy Hence there is a fair chance that the pipeline does not become operational: either Americans halt it out of strategic interest, or the German Greens halt it out of environmental and strategic interest, or both. True, there is a roughly equal chance that Merkel’s policy status quo survives in Germany, which would result in an operational pipeline. The best case for Germany might be that the current government completes the pipeline physically but the next government has optionality on whether to make it operational. But 50/50 odds of cancellation is a much higher risk than the consensus holds. The Russian policy is to finish Nord Stream 2 while also making an aggressive military stance against the West’s and NATO’s influence in Ukraine. This would expand Russian commodity and energy exports and undercut Ukraine’s natgas transit income. It would also increase Russian leverage over Germany – and it would divide Germany from the eastern Europeans and Americans. A preemptive American intervention would elicit Russian retaliation. The Russians could respond in the strategic sphere or the economic sphere. Economically they could react by cutting off natural gas to Europe, but that would undermine their diplomatic goals, so they would more likely respond by increasing production of natural gas or crude oil to steal American market share. In any scenario Russian retaliation would likely cause global price volatility in one or more energy markets, in addition to whatever volatility is induced by the cancellation of Nord Stream 2 itself. US-Russia tensions are likely to escalate but only Ukraine and Nord Stream 2, or the separate Iranian negotiations, have a direct impact on global energy supply. If Germany goes forward with the pipeline, then Russia would need to be countered by other means. The Americans, not the Germans, would provide these “other means,” such as military support to ensure the integrity of Ukraine and other nations’ borders. The Russians may gain a victory for their energy export strategy but they will never compromise on Ukraine and they will still need to focus on the broader global shift to renewable energy, which threatens their economic model and hence ultimately their regime stability. So, the risk of a market-moving US-Russia conflict can be delayed but probably not prevented (Chart 6). Chart 6US-Russia Conflit Likely Bottom Line: The Nord Stream 2 pipeline is not guaranteed to be completed this year as planned. The US is more likely to force a halt to the Nord Stream 2 pipeline than the consensus holds, especially if Russia attacks Ukraine. If the US fails to do so, then the German election will become the next signpost for whether the pipeline will become operational. If the Americans halt the pipeline, then US-Russian conflict either already erupted or will occur sooner rather than later and will likely impact global oil or natural gas prices. Investment Implications Our subjective assessment of 50% odds the US will succeed in halting completion of the final leg of Nord Stream 2 are higher than the consensus expectation. This translates directly into higher upside risk for natural gas prices in the US and Europe later this year and next. Given our view, we are getting long 1Q22 calls on CME/NYMEX Henry Hub-delivered natgas futures struck at $3.50/MMBtu vs. short 1Q22 $3.75/MMBtu calls at tonight's close. The probability of Nord Stream 2 cancellation is underpriced, which means the odds of higher prices in the LNG market are underpriced (Chart 7). The immediate implication of our view is European TTF prices will have to move higher to attract LNG cargoes next winter from the US, if the Nord Stream 2 pipeline's final leg is cancelled. This also would tighten the Asian markets, causing the JKM to move higher as well (Chart 8). Any indication of colder-than-normal weather in the US, Europe or Asian markets would mean a sharper move higher. Chart 7Natgas Tails Are Too Narrow For Next Winter Chart 8Nord Stream 2 Cancellation Would Boost JKM Prices Robert P. Ryan Chief Commodity & Energy Strategist rryan@bcaresearch.com Matt Gertken Vice President Geopolitical Strategy mattg@bcaresearch.com Commodities Round-Up Energy: Bullish The US and Iran began indirect talks earlier this week in Vienna aimed at restoring the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), otherwise known as the "Iran nuclear deal." All of the other parties of the deal – Britain, China, France, Germany and Russia – are in favor of restoring the deal. BCA Research believes this is most likely to occur prior to the inauguration of a new president who is expected to be a hardliner willing to escalate Iran’s demands. US President Biden can unilaterally ease sanctions and bring the US into compliance with the deal, and Iran could then reciprocate. If a deal is not reached by August it could take years to resolve US-Iran tensions. China could offer to cooperate on sanctions and help to broker negotiations following the signing of its 25-year trade deal with Iran last week. Russia likely would demand the US not pressure its allies to cancel the Nord Stream 2 deal, in return for its assistance in brokering a deal. Base Metals: Bullish Iron ore prices continue to be supported by record steel prices in China, trading at more than $173/MT earlier this week. Even though steel production reportedly is falling in the top steel-producer in China, Tangshan, as a result of anti-pollution measures, for iron ore remains stout. As we have previously noted, we use steel prices as a leading indicator for copper prices. We remain long Dec21 copper and will be looking for a sell-off to get long Sep21 copper vs. short Sep21 copper if the market trades below $4/lb on the CME/COMEX futures market (Chart 9). Precious Metals: Bullish Gold held support ~ $1,680/oz at the end of March, following an earlier test in the month. We remain long the yellow metal, despite coming close to being stopped out last week (Chart 10). The earlier sell-off appeared to be caused by a need to raise liquidity to us. We continue to expect the Fed to hold firm to its stated intent to wait for actual inflation to become manifest before raising rates, and, therefore, continue to expect real rates to weaken. This will be supportive of gold and commodities generally (Chart 10). Ags/Softs: Neutral Corn continues to be well supported above $5.50/bu, following last week's USDA report showing farmers intend to increase acreage planted to just over 91mm acres, which is less than 1% above last year's level. Chart 9 Chart 10 Footnotes 1 Please see the Fund's April 2021 forecast Managing Divergent Recoveries. 2 We noted last week these higher growth expectations generally are bullish for industrial commodities – energy, metals, and bulks. Please see Fundamentals Support Oil, Bulks, And Metals, which we published 1 April 2021. It is available at ces.bcaresearch.com. 3 For the rate of construction see Margarita Assenova, “Clouds Darkening Over Nord Stream Two Pipeline,” Eurasia Daily Monitor 18: 17 (February 1, 2021), Jamestown Foundation, jamestown.org. For the current status, see Robin Emmott, “At NATO, Blinken warns Germany over Nord Stream 2 pipeline,” Reuters, March 23, 2021, reuters.com. 4 The Democratic Party blames Russia for what it sees as a campaign to undermine the democratic West and recreate the Soviet sphere of influence. See for example the 2008 invasion of Georgia, the failure of the Obama administration’s 2009-11 diplomatic “reset,” the Edward Snowden affair, the seizure of Crimea and civil war in Ukraine, the survival of Syria’s dictator, and Russian interference in US elections in 2016 and 2020. 5 The Countering Russian Influence in Europe and Eurasia Act of 2017, and the Protecting Europe’s Energy Security Act of 2019/2020, contain provisions requiring sanctions on firms that have contributed in any way a minimum of $1 million to the project, or provide pipe-laying services or insurance. There are exceptions for services provided by the governments of the EU member states, Norway, Switzerland, or the UK. The president has discretion over the implementation of sanctions as usual. 6 The German state of Mecklenburg-Vorpommern is creating a shell foundation to enable the completion of the pipeline. It can shield companies from American sanctions aimed at private companies, not sovereigns. Investment Views and Themes Recommendations Strategic Recommendations Tactical Trades Commodity Prices and Plays Reference Table Summary of Closed Trades
Highlights The Biden Administration's $2.25 trillion infrastructure plan rolled out yesterday will, at the margin, boost global demand for energy and base metals more than expected later this year and next. Global GDP growth estimates – and the boost supplied by US stimulus – once again will have to be adjusted higher (Chart of the Week). Energy and metals fundamentals continue to tighten. OPEC 2.0's so-far-successful production management strategy will keep the level of supply just below demand, which will keep Brent crude oil on either side of $60/bbl. Base-metals output will struggle to meet higher demand from the ongoing buildout of renewables infrastructure and growing electric-vehicle sales. Of late, concerns that speculative positioning suggests prices will head lower – or, at other times, higher – are entirely misplaced: Spec positioning conveys no information on price levels or direction. Energy and metals prices, on the other hand, do convey useful information on spec positioning, demonstrating specs do not lead the news or prices, they follow them. Short-term headwinds caused by halting recoveries and renewed lockdowns – particularly in the EU – will fade in 2H21 as vaccines roll out, if the experience of the UK and US are any guide. Continued USD strength, however, would remain a headwind. Feature If the Biden administration is successful in getting its $2.25 trillion infrastructure-spending bill through Congress, the US will join the rest of the world in the race to re-build – in some cases, build anew – its long-neglected bridges, roads, schools, communications and high-speed transportation networks, and, critically, its electric-power grid. There's a lot of game left to play on this, but our Geopolitical Strategy group is giving this bill an 80% of passage later this year, after all the wrangling and log-rolling in Congress is done. In and of itself, the infrastructure-directed spending coming out of Biden's plan will be a catalyst for higher US industrial commodity demand – energy, metals and bulks. In addition, it will support the lift in the demand boost coming out of higher GDP growth globally, which will be pushed higher by US fiscal spending, as the Chart of the Week shows. Of note is the extremely robust growth expected in India, China and the US, which are among the largest consumers of industrial commodities globally. Overall growth in the G20 and globally will be expansive in 2022 as well. Chart of the WeekBiden's $2.25 Trillion Infrastructure Bill Will Boost Global Commodity Demand Higher GDP growth translates directly into higher demand for commodities, all else equal, as can be seen in the relationship between EM and DM GDP, supply and inventories and Brent crude oil prices in Chart 2. While we have reduced our Brent forecast for this year to $60/bbl on the back of renewed demand-side weakness in the EU due to problems in acquiring and distributing COVID-19 vaccines, we expect this to be reversed next year and into 2025, with prices trading between $60-$80/bbl (Chart 3). OPEC 2.0, the oil-producer coalition led by the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) and Russia, has done an excellent job of keeping the level of oil supply below demand over the course of the pandemic, which we expect to continue to the end of 2025.1 Chart 2Higher GDP Growth Presages Higher Commodity Demand Chart 3Brent Crude Oil Prices Will Average - / bbl to 2025 As the Biden plan makes its way through Congress, markets will get a better idea of how much diesel fuel, copper, steel, iron ore, etc., will be required in the US alone. What is important to note here that the US is just moving to the starting line, whereas other economies like China and the EU already have begun their investment cycles in renewables and EVs. At present, key markets already are tight, particularly copper (Chart 4) and aluminum (Chart 5). In both markets, we expect physical deficits this year and next, which inclines us to believe the metals leg of this renewables buildout is just beginning – higher prices will be required to incentivize the development of new supply.2 Chart 4Copper Will Post Physical Deficit... Chart 5...As Will Aluminum This is particularly important in copper, where growth in mining output of ore has been flat for the past two years. Copper is the one metal that spans all renewables technologies, and is a bellwether commodity for global growth. We expect copper to trade to $4.50/lb (up ~ $0.50/lb vs spot) on the COMEX in 4Q21 on the back of increasing demand and tight supplies – i.e., falling mining supply and refined copper output growth (Chart 6). Worth noting also is steel rebar and hot-rolled coil prices traded at record highs this week on Chinese futures markets. Stronger steel markets continue to support iron ore prices, although the latter is trading off its recent highs and likely will move lower toward the end of the year as Brazilian supply returns to the market.3 We use steel prices as a leading indicator for copper prices – steel leads copper prices by ~ 9 months. This makes sense when one considers steel is consumed early in infrastructure and construction projects, while copper consumption occurs later as airports and houses are fitted with copper for electric, plumbing and communications applications. Chart 6Copper Ore Output Flat Does Speculative Positioning Matter? Of late, media pundits and analysts have cited an unwinding of speculative positions in oil and metals markets following sharp run-ups in net long positions as a harbinger of weaker prices in the near future (Chart 7).4 At other times, speculation has been invoked as a reason for price surges – e.g., when oil rocketed toward $150/bbl in mid-2008, which was followed by a price collapse at the start of the Global Financial Crisis (GFC).5 Brunetti et al note, "The role of speculators in financial markets has been the source of considerable interest and controversy in recent years. Concern about speculative trading also finds support in theory where noise traders, speculative bubbles, and herding can drive prices away from fundamental values and destabilize markets." (p. 1545) Chart 7Speculative Positioning Lower In Brent Than WTI We recently re-tested earlier findings in our research, which found that knowledge of how specs are positioned – either on the long or the short side of the market – conveys no information on the level of prices or the change that should be expected given that knowledge. However, knowledge of the price level does convey useful information on how speculators are positioned in futures markets.6 In cointegrating regressions of speculative positions in crude oil, natural gas and copper futures on price levels for these commodities, we find the level of prices to be a statistically significant determinant of spec positions. We find no such relationship using spec positions as an explanatory variable for prices.7 On the other hand, Chart 2 above is an example of statistically significant relationships for Brent and WTI price as a function of supply-demand fundamentals displaying coefficients of determination (r-squares) of close to 90% in the post-GFC period (2010 to now). This supports our earlier findings regarding spec behavior: They follow prices, they don't lead them.8 We are not dismissive of speculation. It plays a critical role in markets, by providing the liquidity that enables commodity producers and consumers to hedge their price exposures, and to investors seeking to diversify their portfolios with commodity exposures that are uncorrelated to their equity and bond holdings. Short-Term Headwinds Likely Dissipate COVID-19 remains the largest risk to markets generally, commodities in particular. The mishandling of vaccine rollouts in the EU has pushed back our assumption for demand recovery deeper into 2H21, but it has not derailed it. We expect COVID-related deaths and hospitalizations to fall in the EU as they have in the UK and the US following the widespread distribution of vaccines, which should occur in the near future as Brussels organizes its pandemic response (Chart 8). Making vaccines available for other states in dire straits will follow, which will allow the global re-opening to progress as lockdowns are lifted (Chart 9). Chart 8EU Vaccination Rollouts Will Boost Global Economic Recovery Chart 9Global Re-Opening Has Slowed, But Will Resume In 2H21 The other big risk we see to commodities is persistent USD strength (Chart 10). The dollar has rallied for the better part of 2021, largely on the back of improving US economic prospects relative to other states, and success in its vaccination efforts. The resumption of the USD's bear market may have to wait until the rest of the world catches up with America's public-health response to the pandemic, and the global economy ex-US and -China enters a stronger expansionary mode. Bottom Line: We remain bullish industrial commodities expecting demand to improve as the EU rolls out vaccines and begins to make progress in arresting the pandemic and removing lockdowns. Global fiscal and monetary policy, which likely will be bolstered by a massive round of US infrastructure spending beginning in 4Q21 will catalyze demand growth for oil and base metals. This will prompt another round of GDP revisions to the upside. The dollar remains a headwind for now, but we expect it to return to a bear market in 2H21. Chart 10The USD's Evolution Remains Important Robert P. Ryan Chief Commodity & Energy Strategist rryan@bcaresearch.com Ashwin Shyam Research Associate Commodity & Energy Strategy ashwin.shyam@bcaresearch.com Commodities Round-Up Energy: Bullish Going into the April 1 meeting of OPEC 2.0 today, we are not expecting any increase in production. OPEC earlier this week noted demand had softened, mostly due to the slow recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic in the EU, which, based on their previous policy decisions, suggests the producer coalition will not be increasing production. The coalition led by KSA and Russia will have to address Iran's return as a major exporter to China this year, which appears to have been importing ~ 1mm b/d of Iranian crude this month (Chart 11). This puts Iran in direct competition with KSA as a major exporter to China, in defiance of the US re-imposition of sanctions against Iranian exports. China and Iran over the weekend signed a 25-year trade pact that also could include military provisions, which could, over time, alter the balance of power in the Persian Gulf if Chinese military assets – naval and land warfare – deploy to Iran under their agreement. Details of the deal are sparse, as The Guardian noted in its recent coverage. Among other things, government officials in Tehran have come under withering criticism for entering the deal, which they contend was signed with a "politically bankrupt regime." The Guardian also noted US President Joe Biden " is prepared to make a new offer to Iran this week whereby he will lift some sanctions in return for Iran taking specific limited steps to come back into compliance with the nuclear agreement, including reducing the level to which it enriches uranium," in the wake of the signing of this deal. Base Metals: Bullish Copper fell this week, initially on an inventory build, and has now settled right under the $4/lb mark, as investors await details on the US infrastructure bill unveiled in Pittsburgh, PA, on Wednesday. According to mining.com, a major chunk of the proposed bill will be devoted to investments in infrastructure, which will be metals-intensive. Precious Metals: Bullish Gold fell further this week, as US treasury yields rose, buoyed by the increased US vaccine efforts and President Biden’s proposed spending plans (Chart 12). USD strength also worked against the yellow metal, which has been steadily declining since the beginning of this year. COMEX gold fell below the $1,700/oz mark for the third time this month and settled at $1,683.90/oz on Tuesday. Chart 11 Chart 12 Footnotes 1 Please see Five-Year Brent Forecast Update: Expect Price Range of $60 - $80/bbl, which we published 25 March 2021. It is available at ces.bcaresearch.com. 2 Please see Industrial Commodities Super-Cycle Or Bull Market?, which we published 4 March 2021 for additional discussion, particularly regarding the need for additional capex in energy and metals markets. 3 Please see UPDATE 1-Strong industrial activity, profit lift China steel futures, published by reuters.com 29 March 2021. 4 See, e.g., Column: Frothy oil market deflates as virus fears return published 23 March 2021. 5 Brunetti, Celso, Bahattin Büyüksahin, and Jeffrey H. Harris (2016), " Speculators, Prices, and Market Volatility," Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 51:5, pp. 1545-74, for further discussion. 6 Please see Specs Back Up The Truck For Oil, which we published 26 April 2018, and Feedback Loop: Spec Positioning & Oil Price Volatility published 10 May 2018. Both are available at ces.bcaresearch.com. 7 We group money managers (registered commodity trading advisors, commodity pool operators and unregistered funds) and swap dealers (banks and trading companies providing liquidity to hedgers and speculators) together to test these relationships. 8 In our earlier research, we also noted our results generally were supported in the academic literature. See, e.g., Fattouh, Bassam, Lutz Kilian and Lavan Mahadeva (2012), "The Role of Speculation in Oil Markets: What Have We Learned So Far?" published by The Oxford Institute For Energy Studies. Investment Views and Themes Strategic Recommendations Commodity Prices and Plays Reference Table Summary of Closed Trades
Highlights Copper prices will continue to rally, following a surge this week to highs not seen since early 2013 on the back of falling inventories, particularly in China, where physical demand has taken stocks to their lowest levels in almost 10 years (Chart of the Week). Physical premiums for the copper cathodes delivered to off-exchange bonded warehouses in China this week are up almost 60% since November – to $73/MT – providing further evidence of market tightness. Mine output in Peru, the second largest producer behind Chile, was down 12.5% to 2.15mm MT last year in the wake of COVID-19 containment measures. Given this large decline in output, the multi-year flattening of supply growth will continue. Upside demand pressure is building, as COVID-19 vaccination rates rise. Funding for the build-out of renewable energy generation is ramping up, and now includes expected US fiscal stimulus focused on renewables. Recovering global GDP, and China’s metals-intensive Five-Year Plan also will contribute to demand growth. We continue to expect COMEX copper to trade above $4/lb this year, but the likelihood this occurs in 1H21 (vs 2H21 as we earlier forecast) is increasing. Forward curves will become more backwardated, as markets continue to tighten. Feature Copper prices will continue to surge on the back of unexpected strength in Chinese demand, which has taken inventory levels to near-decade lows. This is something of an anomaly going into a Lunar New Year – the year of the Metal Ox – when activity typically slows. The big draw from global stocks that went into China’s inventories last year means global stocks will remain tight as the rest of the world continues its recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic (Chart 2). Particularly noteworthy are the huge drops in copper inventories held in the Shanghai Futures Exchange (SHFE, panel 3), and the London Metal Exchange (LME, panel 5), which are driving global drawdowns. Away from the commodity-exchange inventories, premiums for delivery of copper cathodes from bonded warehouses into China surged close to 60% from November levels to $73/MT earlier this week, as demand for physical material surges, according to reuters.com. Cathodes are used to make wire, tubes, for melting stock and in copper alloys. Demand for cathodes is rising outside China, which indicates they will retain a physical premium, even with exports from Chile restored to normal following weather-related disruptions. Chart of the WeekCopper Prices Surge As Global Storage Draws Chart 2Falling Global Inventories Support Copper Prices Chart 3Sources of Copper Demand Strength This year’s departure from a seasonal demand downturn in Chinese copper demand likely is due to government efforts to limit travel to contain COVID-19 contagion, which means workers remain available to meet stronger demand for manufactured goods domestically and abroad. In addition, domestic demand – from electrification and infrastructure to housing – is particularly robust, which has kept pressure on inventories (Chart 3). Longer-Term Copper Demand Strength Baseline industrial, construction and infrastructure demand for copper – what’s already in place and continues to grow in line with the expansion of global GDP – will be augmented by the global build-out of renewables-based electricity generation, as the world moves toward a low-carbon future (Chart 4). Chart 4Incremental Renewables Demand Requires Significant Capex While this will not tax existing resources to the extent other materials will – e.g., copper demand from renewables will require less than 20% of existing identified reserves to meet cumulative demand to 2050 vs. the more than 100% of reserves required to meet cobalt demand by 2050 – this is still significant in a market requiring large capex increases to battle declining ore quality (Chart 5).1 Chart 5Higher Prices Needed To Spur Mining CAPEX Copper Supply Side Remains Challenged Short- and long-term challenges to global copper supply abound. Peru’s mine output was down 12.5% last year – to 2.15mm MT – in the wake of COVID-19 containment measures (Chart 6). Given Peru’s unexpectedly large decline in output, the multi-year flattening of supply growth we highlighted last month will continue.2 Indeed, we expect mined and refined output to show little or no growth this year, as was the case last year. This can partly be blamed on a lethargic recovery in mining capex, which hit a 10-year low in 2017. Longer term, as the continued global inventory drawdowns illustrate, the rate of growth in mined and refined production is far below the rate of growth in consumption globally. This is occurring as the pace of China’s recovery from COVID-19 aggregate demand destruction can be expected to start winding down later this year and growth ex-China ramps up (Chart 7). Chart 6Peru Posts Sharply Lower Output Prices for ore and refined copper will have to move higher to incentivize new production over the near term just to meet existing demand, to say nothing of new demand coming on from the global buildout in renewable-energy generation.3 Chart 7Supply Growth Lags Demand Growth Investment Implications As the rates of COVID-19 infection, hospitalization and deaths continue to fall globally, markets will begin to see evidence of an organic recovery in aggregate demand globally taking hold (Chart 8). We also expect this will remove a significant amount of the embedded risk premium in the broad trade-weighted USD, which will be bullish for commodities generally. The combination of organic growth and a weaker USD will boost the level of copper demand globally, even if China is slowing in 2H21, as our China Investment Strategy expects. This will put the weak y/y production growth in mined and refined copper in sharp perspective vis-à-vis copper demand, and will push copper prices higher. These fundamentals also will deepen the backwardation in CME COMEX copper futures for high-grade refined metal, as inventories continue to draw, and markets continue to tighten. We remain long the PICK ETF, and December 2021 COMEX copper futures, which are up 8.42% and 21.7% respectively since their inception dates on December 10, 2020 and September 10, 2020. Chart 8As COVID-19 Receeds Copper Demand Will Increase Robert P. Ryan Chief Commodity & Energy Strategist rryan@bcaresearch.com Commodities Round-Up Energy: Bullish The US EIA estimates December and January LNG exports will hover close to 10 BCF/d, continuing a trend noted at the end of last year (Chart 9). November and December LNG exports last year were at record levels – 9.4 BCF/d and 9.8 BCF/d. In January, LNG exports were 9.8 BCF/d, another record for that month. Below-normal temperatures in Asia have spurred demand for US LNG at a time when spot outages at other exporting states reduced global supplies. The EIA expects US LNG exports to average 8.5 BCF/d and 9.2 BCF/d this year and next. Working natural gas stocks at the end of January were 2.7 BCF, up 2% y/y and 8% over the rolling five-year average inventory level. Base Metals: Bullish The European Commission estimates EV nickel demand will be the “single-largest growth sector for nickel demand over the next twenty years.” In a study released by the Commission, global nickel demand is expected to increase by 2.6mm tons by 2040, versus 92k tons in 2020. Internal supply will be sufficient to meet demand for the 27 EU states to 2024/25, according to the study, and thereafter physical deficits will follow. The study notes that without an end-of-life recycling buildout, this deficit will persist, as mining.com noted in its report on the study. Precious Metals: Bullish After sustaining a triple bottom in at ~ $840/oz, platinum prices have rallied almost $400/oz since November (Chart 10). Lower supplies and investor demand drove the rally. Going forward, we expect increasing auto demand – first in China, and then, later, in the rest of the world as organic growth revives – will support demand for platinum-group metals, particularly for platinum and palladium. Platinum posted a 390k-ounce deficit in 2020, while palladium demand exceeded supply by just over 600k oz, according to Johnson Matthey, the PGM refiner. The world consumes ~ 10mm ounces of palladium and ~ 7mm ounces of platinum p.a. Ags/Softs: Neutral Corn, wheat and soybeans were trading 2 – 3% lower, following the USDA’s February 2021 World Agricultural Supply and Demand Estimates (WASDE) released on Tuesday. Markets drastically overestimated the amount by which the USDA would cut ending stocks for the 2020/21 crop year, with the Department trimming corn stocks to 1.5mm bushels (vs a 1.4mm bushel estimate of analysts), according to farmprogress.com. Chart 9 Chart 10 Footnotes 1 Please see Table 13, p. 27 in Dominish, E., Florin, N. and Teske, S., 2019, Responsible Minerals Sourcing for Renewable Energy. Report prepared for Earthworks by the Institute for Sustainable Futures, University of Technology Sydney. 2 Please see Pandemic Uncertainty Will Fall, Weakening USD, Boosting Metals, published 28 January 2021. It is available at ces.bcaresearch.com. 3 Please see Renewables, China's FYP Underpin Metals Demand, published 26 November 2020. It is available at ces.bcaresearch.com. Investment Views and Themes Recommendations Strategic Recommendations Commodity Prices and Plays Reference Table Summary of Closed Trades
Highlights Pandemic uncertainty is keeping the USD well bid by raising global economic policy uncertainty. When this breaks – i.e., as higher vaccination rates push contagion rates down – the USD will resume its bear market. Renewable-energy output surpassed fossil-fuel generation in Europe for the first time in 2020. With the Biden administration re-committing to renewables, and China and Europe continuing their build-outs, copper demand will rise to meet grid-expansion needs. Copper mine output fell 0.5% in Jan-Oct 2020. Treatment and refining charges – already at 10-year lows – will remain depressed as supplies tighten. Major exchanges’ refined copper inventories were down 17% y/y in December, suggesting weak mine output continued into end-2020. Stocks will continue to fall this year, backwardating the COMEX's copper forward curve (Chart of the Week). Based on the World Bank’s forecast for real global GDP growth of 4% this year, and our expectation for a weaker USD, COMEX copper prices will likely breach $4.00/lb by 2H21. COVID-19 uncertainty drives metals: If infection and hospitalization rates outpace vaccinations, additional lockdowns in the US and Europe will stymie the recovery. Success in expanding vaccinations will push economic activity higher. We expect the latter outcome. Feature Pandemic uncertainty is driving global economic policy uncertainty, which is keeping a safe-haven bid under the USD (Chart 2). Chart of the WeekPhysical Copper Deficit Signals Continued Inventory Draws This continues to stymie the recovery in industrial commodity prices, particularly oil and base metals.1 The uncertainty caused by the COVID-19 pandemic feeds directly into global economic policy uncertainty, which drives USD safe-haven demand. Chart 2USD Remains In The Thrall Of Pandemic Uncertainty Pandemic uncertainty will not abate until vaccination distribution is sufficient to put infection, hospitalization and death rates on a clear downward trajectory, and remove the threat of widespread lockdowns, which once again are required to deal with rampant contagion rates and the possible spread of vaccine-resistant COVID-19 mutations locally and globally. As markets see empirical evidence of falling COVID-19-related infection, hospitalization and mortality, safe-haven demand for USD will weaken. Massive fiscal and monetary support will continue to support GDP globally, until organic growth takes off after sufficient populations are vaccinated, per the World Bank’s assumptions (Chart 3).2 Fiscal stimulus in the US exceeds 25% of GDP, and will continue to expand as the Biden administration rolls out additional spending measures. With the Fed remaining willing and able to accommodate this massive fiscal profligacy in the US, the USD will face increasing pressure on the downside as normalcy returns. Chart 3Massive Fiscal Support Globally Will Be Replaced By Organic Growth A weaker USD and stronger economic growth would boost copper prices this year and the next. A 5% decline in the broad trade-weighted USD this year would push spot COMEX copper prices above $4.30/lb, all else equal, while a 4% boost in world GDP – in line with the World Bank’s forecast for real growth this year – would lift prices to just under $4.05/lb, based on our modeling (Chart 4).3 Chart 4Lower USD, Stronger GDP Bullish For Copper Prices Renewable Generation Will Boost Copper Demand In addition to these stronger fundamentals, base metals demand – particularly for copper – will continue to benefit from the build-out of renewable-energy electricity generation globally, particularly in Europe and China. The return of the US to the Paris Agreement to combat climate change, and a renewed effort by the Biden administration to fund expanded renewable-energy resources will add to the increase in base-metals demand accompanying this global build-out (Chart 5).4 Europe is moving out ahead of the US in its deployment of renewable electricity generation, which, for the first time ever, surpassed fossil-fuel generation in 2020.5 S&P Global Market Intelligence this week reported renewable energy sources accounted for 38% of electricity generation in the EU vs 37% for fossil fuels. Renewables also surpassed fossil-fuel generation in the UK last year. Wind, solar and hydro all saw strong gains. Chart 5Copper Is Indispensible For A Low-Carbon Future Copper Supply Continues To Tighten It is important to once again note that all of these, and other renewable technologies, will require higher base metals output, none moreso than copper, which spans all renewable technologies. With copper-mining capex still weak and ore qualities falling in the mines that are producing, the supply side remains challenged (Chart 6). Over the past two years, p.a. supply growth on the mining side has been close to flat. The International Copper Study Group (ICSG) this week reported copper mine output fell 0.5% in the first 10 months of 2020. Refined copper output was up 1.5% over the same interval. Treatment and refining charges – already at 10-year lows – will remain depressed as supplies tighten. We expect full-year mined and refined output to fall on either side of zero growth for 2020, and 2021 (Chart 7).6 Major exchanges’ refined copper inventories were down 17% y/y in December, according to the ICSG, suggesting weak mine output continued into end-2020. An apparent increase in refined copper consumption of 2% noted by the ICSG also contributed to lower inventories. The Group estimates global refined copper balances adjusted for changes in Chinese bonded stocks, which are believed to have increased 105k tons y/y in the Jan-Dec 2020 interval, posted a physical deficit of ~ 380k tons. Chart 6Weak Capex, Lower Copper Ore Quality Remain Chief Supply-Side Challenges Chart 7Mined, Refined Copper Supply Growth Remains WeakWe expect inventories will continue to fall this year – as seen in the Chart of the Week – as demand strengthens and supply growth remains weak, which will backwardate the COMEX copper forward curve. Metal Ox Year Brings Short-Term Uncertainties The approach of the Chinese New Year beginning 12 February 2021 normally would herald massive travel and celebration, which, all else equal, would dampen economic growth until festivities ended. This year, however, reports of a re-emergence of COVID-19 infections is casting doubt on this year’s celebrations. In addition, winter industrial curtailments to reduce pollution also should reduce short-term demand for metals generally. These transitory factors should show up in lower levels of economic activity on the industrial side. For this reason, we expect seasonal weakness to show up in 1Q21 activity, to be followed in 2Q21 by higher growth y/y. Bottom Line: Copper fundamentals continue to paint a bullish price picture, particularly on the supply side. Although risks abound on both sides of the market, we expect the massive support being provided by fiscal and monetary policy globally to transition to organic growth in 2H21, in line with the World Bank’s expectations. The enormous fiscal stimulus being unleashed by the US – coupled with an ultra-accommodative Fed – will result in a weakening of the USD that will provide a tailwind to copper prices in 2H21 and next year. We remain long the PICK ETF, expecting copper miners and traders to benefit from this bullish backdrop, which we expect to persist for the next decade. The recommendation is up 6.4% since inception December 10, 2020. We also remain long December 2021 copper, which is up 19.6% since it was recommended on September 10, 2020. Robert P. Ryan Chief Commodity & Energy Strategist rryan@bcaresearch.com Commodities Round-Up Energy: Bullish After falling 11% in 2020 due to COVID-19-induced demand destruction, US energy-related CO2 emissions will rebound this year and next, according to the Energy Information Administration (Chart 8). The EIA forecasts US energy-related CO2 emissions this year and next will be 4.8 and 4.9 billion MT, which would amount to a 4.7% and 3.2% gains, respectively. The EIA tracks emissions from coal, petroleum and natural gas usage in the US in its estimates. Petroleum accounts for ~ 46% of total emissions in 2021 and 2022, while natgas contributes ~ 33% of all energy-related emissions in both years, on average. Reflecting its market-share loss in the power-generation market, coal accounts for ~ 21% of total US energy-related CO2 emissions in 2021 and 2022. Base Metals: Bullish Globally, crude steel production was down 0.9% y/y at 1.864 billion MT, the World Steel Association reported this week. China’s steel production was up 5.2% last year, to 1.053 billion MT, the country a market share of 56.5%, up from 2019’s level of 53.3%. Output in all of Asia totalled 1.375 billion MT, up 1.5% y/y, with India’s production falling close to 11% to 99.6 billion MT. China’s iron-ore imports set a record last year on the back of its strong steel-making performance, reaching 1.2 billion tonnes, a 9.5% increase y/y. Higher infrastructure spending was the primary driver of increased steel demand last year. Iron ore delivered to the Chinese port of Tianjin (62% Fe) closed just above $169/MT on Tuesday, up ~ 9% YTD. Precious Metals: Bullish Gold continues to trade ~ $1,850/oz, down more than $100/oz from its highs earlier this month on the back of persistent USD strength (Chart 9). The pandemic uncertainty feeding into global economic policy uncertainty is the proximate cause of dollar strength. COVID-19 vaccine rates are increasing, and governments remain committed to widespread distribution, which likely will be visible to markets during 1H21. Once this occurs, we expect gold to rally along with other commodities, as the safe-have bid is priced out of the USD. Ags/Softs: Neutral US corn prices rallied on the back of stronger China purchases of the grain on Tuesday. Farm Futures reported a 53.5mm-bushel order out of China on Tuesday was responsible for the gain earlier this week. Farmers continue to expect Chinese buying to remain strong, given falling corn stocks in China. Chart 8 Chart 9 Footnotes 1 At the margin, this increases the cost of purchasing commodities and lowers the cost of producing them ex-US in local-currency terms, both of which depress prices. Pandemic uncertainty and global economic policy uncertainty (GEPU) are cointegrated; the USD and GEPU also are cointegrated. We discussed the effects of pandemic uncertainty on the USD and its impact on oil prices in last week’s balances and price forecast update entitled Brent Forecast: $63 This Year, $71 Next Year. This report is available at ces.bcaresearch.com. 2 Please see the Bank's Global Economic Prospects released 5 January 2021 entitled Subdued Global Economic Recovery. The IMF upgraded its global growth outlook to 5.5% this year and 4.2% next year, in its World Economic Outlook Update released this week. We continue to use the more conservative World Bank forecasts. The Israeli economy is providing something of a natural experiment vis-à-vis the rate of COVID-19 vaccination and economic growth. According to reuters.com, the country got an early start on vaccinations, and has one of the highest rates in the world. If maintained, this will result in GDP growth of 6.3% in 2021 and 5.8% next year. Without these early and intensive vaccination rates, 2021 growth likely would be 3.5%. 3 The models in Chart 4 use the broad trade-weighted USD and global copper stocks as common regressors, and estimate copper prices given the World Bank estimates for World, EM ex-China, China and DM real GDPs. In the discussion above, we use elasticities from the World GDP model to highlight the impact of changes in copper prices from the different variables. 4 Please see Renewables, China's FYP Underpin Metals Demand, which we published 26 November 2020. We discuss the implications of essentially rebuilding the global electric-generation grid to accommodate more renewable energy resources vis-à-vis base metals demand. Copper, in particular, spans all technologies that will be deployed to achieve a low-carbon generation pool globally, as Chart 5 illustrates. 5 Please see For 1st time, renewables surpass fossil fuels in EU power mix published by S&P Global Market Intelligence 25 January 2021. 6 Benchmark treatment and refining fees charged by smelters to refine raw ore fell to 5.9 cent/lb this year, down from 6.2 cent/lb last year, according to reuters.com. This 10-year low reflects an abundance of smelting capacity relative to concentrates on the supply side needing to be refined. Investment Views and Themes Recommendations Strategic Recommendations Commodity Prices and Plays Reference Table Summary of Closed Trades
Copper prices have rallied roughly 70% since late March, fueled by a weak dollar, generous global liquidity conditions, expectations of a robust economic recovery, and supply constraints. Most of these fundamental tailwinds remain broadly in place,…
Highlights Rising commodity prices and a weaker dollar will lead to higher inflation at the consumer level beginning this year. In the real economy, tighter commodity fundamentals – restrained supply growth, increasing demand, and falling inventories in oil, metals and grain markets – will push prices higher, which will feed US CPI inflation and inflation expectations going forward. Stronger fiscal stimulus, and the expanding budget deficits that will accompany it – along with the Fed’s oft-affirmed willingness to accommodate them – will allow the USD to resume its bear market, and will also boost commodity prices. Policy support will be kicking into a higher gear as COVID-19 vaccines are more widely distributed, contributing to a revival in organic growth globally. This will keep the rate of growth in commodity demand above that of supply. Increasing inflation expectations will be evident in longer-dated CPI swaps markets used by traders, portfolio and pension-fund managers to manage longer-term inflation risks (Chart of the Week). Risks remain elevated to the upside and downside: Fundamentals and policy are supportive; public-health risks are acute, and political risk is elevated, particularly in the US, where tensions remain high following the assault on the Capitol in Washington. Feature In the real economy, industrial commodities – particularly oil and copper – are signaling prices will move higher. The real economy and financial markets are pointing to higher inflation going forward. This will become apparent in the longer-term US CPI swaps markets used by traders, portfolio and pension managers as commodity prices continue to rise and the USD resumes its bear market.1 In the real economy, industrial commodities – particularly oil and copper – are signaling prices will move higher. Production-management in the oil market is keeping the rate of growth in supply below that of demand, a trend we expect will continue this year. In the copper market, demand growth will outstrip supply growth this year and next (Chart 2). As a result, both markets will see physical supply deficits this year. Chart of the WeekReal And Financial Markets Point To Higher Inflation Chart 2Copper Supply-Demand Balances Point To Growing Deficits Physical Deficits in Oil, Copper Indicate Supplies Are Tightening Fiscal stimulus in the US will be accommodated by the Fed, which, despite some dissonant messaging, continues to signal its policy of targeting average inflation can be expected to result in lower real rates, as inflation overshoots its 2% target. Policy support is helping to maintain commodity demand globally. Fiscal policy worldwide continues to be supportive. In the US, it likely will become even more expansionary, following the electoral wins of Democrats in Senate run-off elections last week, which will bolster president-elect Joe Biden's position in stimulus-package negotiations after he takes office next week. This expansion of fiscal stimulus will dwarf the levels seen in the wake of the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) in 2008-09 (Chart 3). This fiscal stimulus in the US will be accommodated by the Fed, which, despite some dissonant messaging, continues to signal its policy of targeting average inflation can be expected to result in lower real rates, as inflation overshoots its 2% target. This continued policy support will lead to a resumption of the USD bear market, following a brief dead-cat bounce over the past few days. This will support demand by lowering the local-currency costs of dollar-denominated commodities, and restrict supply growth at the margin by raising the local-currency cost of production. Chart 3Massive US Fiscal Stimulus Will Grow Real Economy Will Boost Inflation Expectations Global fiscal and monetary policy support will further energize the rebound in industrial activity and trade globally. This will keep the rate of growth in commodity demand generally above that of supply, and keep prices elevated. The top panel in the Chart of the Week shows the relationship between CPI 5-year/5-year (5y5y) swaps and crude oil and copper prices, price indexes like the DJ UBS commodity index and the S&P GSCI index, and EM trade volumes in the post-GFC period (2010 to now). The curve in the top panel shows the average of single-equation regressions that use these variables as to estimate CPI 5y5y swap rates; the average coefficient of determination for these equations is just below 0.81, meaning these real variables explain ~ 81% of the level of the CPI 5y5y swaps level post-GFC. This also illustrates how prices and activity in the real economy feed into inflation expectations, which we have demonstrated in the past.2 There also is a correspondence between our measures of real activity – i.e., BCA’s Global Industrial Activity index, Global Commodity Factor and EM Commodity-Demand Nowcast – and CPI 5y5y swaps can be seen in Chart 4. These gauges are more heavily weighted to industrial, manufacturing and trade activity than the commodity indexes, and have an average correlation of ~51% with the level of CPI 5y5y swaps. These series are not as highly correlated with CPI 5y5y swaps as the real and financial variables we used above, but they are, nonetheless, useful indicators to track. Chart 4Real Economic Activity Feeds Into Inflation Expectations Real Economic Activity Feeds Into Inflation Expectations Financial Markets Point To Higher CPI Swaps The Fed’s oft-affirmed willingness to accommodate expanding fiscal deficit strongly supports a weaker-dollar view. The bottom panel in the Chart of the Week shows the average of single-equation estimates that use dollar-related financial variables as regressors against CPI 5y5y swap rates – i.e., the USD broad trade-weighted index, the DXY index, and DM financial-conditions index; the average coefficient of determination for these equations is just below 0.83, meaning these financial variables explain ~ 83% of the CPI 5y5y swaps levels. The Fed’s oft-affirmed willingness to accommodate expanding fiscal deficits strongly supports a weaker-dollar view, which also will boost commodity prices and feed into the CPI swaps market. This fiscal and monetary support will be kicking into a higher gear as COVID-19 vaccines are more widely distributed, contributing to a revival in organic growth globally. This will keep the rate of growth in commodity demand above that of supply. As CPI swaps rates continue to move higher, longer-maturity TIPS breakevens will follow suit (Chart 5). We remain strategically long TIPS versus nominal US Treasuries. We remain strategically long TIPS. Chart 5Expect TIPS Breakevens To Stay Well Bid Risks Remain Elevated CPI 5y5y swap rates will move higher on the back of rising commodity prices, growth in real economic activity, and a weaker dollar. While fundamentals and policy continue to be supportive – and jibe with our longer-term view that industrial commodity prices will move higher – downside risks remain acute. On the health front, COVID-19 pandemic risks remain high, with public-health officials now warning the risk of a more contagious variant of the virus that emerged in the UK could become the dominant strain by March. Public health officials are considering expanded lockdowns to contain the spread of this strain, which reportedly is 50% to 74% more transmissible, according to the MIT Technology Review.3 Fed policy remains supportive of markets in general and commodities in particular. However, with officials offering conflicting views on the policy stance going forward – specifically re the need to taper sooner rather than later – uncertainty around monetary policy will remain a near-constant feature of the market. Lastly, short-term political risk is elevated, particularly in the US, where tensions are high going into the second impeachment of US President Donald J. Trump, following the assault on the US Capitol. This is an evolving story we will be following closely. Bottom Line: CPI 5y5y swap rates will move higher on the back of rising commodity prices, growth in real economic activity, and a weaker dollar. While risks remain elevated, we expect policy risks to be managed and for organic growth to pick up going into 2H21. Robert P. Ryan Chief Commodity & Energy Strategist rryan@bcaresearch.com Commodities Round-Up Energy: Bullish Brent prices reached an 10-month high on Tuesday at close to $57/bbl. Saudi Arabia’s surprise cuts will offset the slowdown in demand growth caused by renewed lockdowns in most DM countries, which is expected to be most pronounced in 1Q21. Consequently, in its most recent forecast, the EIA revised its demand estimate for OECD demand by -450k b/d on average in 2021. Separately, cold weather in Asia, combined with supply and shipping constraints, pushed JKM LNG prices close to $20/MMBtu earlier this week (Chart 6). The cold wave will push storage in Europe lower ahead of the summer injection season, as LNG cargoes are redirected towards Asia to meet higher space-heating demand. Base Metals: Bullish Chinese imports of metallurgical coal from Australia fell to 447.5k MT in December, the lowest level since January 2015, when Refinitiv, a Reuters data and analytics service, started tracking them. Met coal imports peaked last year in June 2020 at 9.6mm MT, according to reuters.com. The proximate cause of this collapse is the Chinese retaliation to Australia’s call for an investigation into the source of the COVID-19 pandemic. China’s imports from Indonesia have surged, while India’s imports from Australia have picked up much of the loss in Chinese demand, Reuters notes. Precious Metals: Bullish Gold prices fell by $78/oz to $1,834/oz on Friday – a 2-week low – following Democrats win in run-off elections that gave them both of Georgia’s Senate seats last week. The decline in gold prices largely reflects the rise in US real rates, which rose following an increase in US nominal rates that was not accompanied by higher inflation reports in the short term (Chart 7). Going forward, we expect investors will increasingly focus on inflation risks as fiscal policy in the US expands. Democrats will be able to provide extra COVID relief – increasing monthly income-support payments to individuals to $2,000 from $600 – in a reconciliation bill in 2021. This will pressure real rates down as inflation expectations steadily move higher. Ags/Softs: Neutral In its global supply-demand estimates released earlier this week, the USDA lowered its global grain and soybean production and yields forecasts, which pushed prices sharply higher. CME spot corn prices held sharp price gains, which sent futures limit up Tuesday, on the back of lower production and yields. Soybean and wheat futures also responded to reduced supply estimates in the wake of the WASDE release. Chart 6DECLINE IN GOLD PRICES REFLECTS A RISE IN US REAL RATES Chart 7TIGHTENING MARKETS PUSH UP LNG PRICES Footnotes 1 We focus on US CPI swaps because they are responsive to the perceived stance of US monetary policy, even if the Fed’s preferred inflation gauge is the PCE deflator and not the CPI. US monetary policy has a strong bearing on the trajectory of US interest rates and the USD, which impacts commodity prices directly. Please see Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS), posted by the US Treasury, which notes: TIPS “provide protection against inflation. The principal of a TIPS increases with inflation and decreases with deflation, as measured by the Consumer Price Index. When a TIPS matures, you are paid the adjusted principal or original principal, whichever is greater.” A fixed interest payment, which changes as the CPI changes, is made twice a year. 2 See, e.g., Trade And Commodity Data Point To Higher Inflation, which we published 27 July 2017. Our approach – i.e., treating inflation expectations as a function of global real variables and financial variables – is consistent with that of the Bank for International Settlements (BIS), which is described in Has globalization changed the inflation process?, posted 4 July 2019. We treat the events of the GFC and central banks’ responses to them as a regime change. In our modeling we estimate dynamic OLS and ARDL equations, to ensure we are modeling cointegrated systems. The average of the coefficients of determination estimated using real variables in DOLS models is pulled lower by the model using COMEX copper futures as an explanatory variable. 3 Please see We may have only weeks to act before a variant coronavirus dominates the US published by the MIT Technology Review 13 January 2021. Investment Views and Themes Recommendations Strategic Recommendations Commodity Prices and Plays Reference Table Summary of Closed Trades
Copper has had an impressive run this year, rallying 60% since the beginning of April to its highest level since March 2013. However, long copper is among the most crowded macro trades amid rebounding economic activity and hope surrounding the vaccines’…
BCA Research's Commodity & Energy Strategy service's Copper Prices model indicates that the rebound in copper prices this year has been justified. Copper has rebounded particularly strongly from the recession, and that was thanks to China: earlier this…